College Kiwis: On Dealing With Major Regret.

So, recently I’ve switched from STEM to elementary education.
I don’t think the classes I’ve taken amount to anything more than “General Studies”.
Makes sense.

What do I do now??
If you're a wahman, you will probably be happier. But be sure to marry well.
If you're a man, you will be not make very much money and work in a very female-centric environment. Perhaps reconsider.

I wish I knew, though I've graduated engineering, just don't enjoy engineering jobs.
You don't have to use your engineering degree to "be an engineer". You can just have a more legit resume for non-engineering jobs than people with fluff majors, or do a short stint of engineering to establish legitimacy/street cred before pivoting to a business role, etc.

In an overly credentialed society, an engineering degree is for the most part still a credential that means something.
 
Last edited:
I disagree with calling it "not smart enough" for the major, either you like it and your good at it or you don't and you're not. I don't mean in some new age bullshit way "everyone's special" participation trophy way, both things must be true to be successful and not miserable. I'd say I'm dumber than many far worse engineers.
"Smart" is an incredibly retarded metric and you realize this by the time you've finished up high school. The "smartest" people I knew in high school fawned over the same Ivy Leagues, being prodigies in whatever APs they were doing, and whatever else your average Indian or Chinese tiger mom thinks of as success.
Even if you're skilled at memorization, you can still be dumb as shit. For fields where outside-the-box thinking is genuinely needed this is what separates the A students from generational talent. International Relations as a field is a good example; the average A student might wind up interning at some soulless neolib global agency, work in DC, and climb up the ranks thinking their worldview is correct because the textbook said so. The true IR theorists are absolutely nothing like this; John Mearsheimer, whos entire career is built off of saying "no, global money agencies are useless and power politics is all that matters" and he sticks out (literally 1/3rd or so of all IR papers cite him in some capacity) because he went against the fold. Mearsheimer might sound "dumb" to most people in the field, but he will be remembered the most out of those in it.
It's far, far better to be skilled in one field, pursue that field and contribute meaningfully towards it than to try and be the best at everything, live your life as a Linkedin profile and die never having lived. Reject the bullshit tech gurus try to push (Musk/Vivek lol) because it's guaranteed to increase the chance of you offing yourself hundredfold.
OP, conviction (liking it) matters 100 times more than whatever grade, outside approval, or other external metric you get. It's within you, pursue your dreams
 
I’d love to go back but, honestly, I am FAR behind on math (was originally on track to be some kind of engineer but to be honest it was to impress my family, for once).
If you sit down right now and begin grinding six hours a day you could be on track entirely within a few months. Math is one of those things that unless you have actual learning disabilities, you can improve at as much as you want - particularly if you were capable of doing Engineering in the first place!

Beyond that all of the resources you need to get good at it are totally free. Just start.
 
A lot of people in this thread who're suggesting pursuing passions and having conviction probably have not been broke, probably have not massively failed or have not faced negative repercussions for rash decisions. A lot of this stuff is fine to imagine but to the 10% who hit the wall trying to jump over it, that impact is enough to handicap and paralyze you for life. OP, I would not suggest giving up and turning back to pursue something else with full conviction or whatever other batshit crap, try to pursue whatever you want on the side, you probably will not survive trying to juggle several things at same priority and you probably will not survive trying to pivot shift halfway through your education. All I can say is be careful, a lot of things done in the 20s have permanent consequences later on in life. Also make connections, I dont like nepotism and I really dislike having to interact with other people against my will but the world of industry thrives on nepotism, its an undisclosed necessity needed to survive.
 
I agree with the folks who are suggesting that you reach out to your guidance counselor for ideas and suggestions. That can be helpful.

I would also suggest that you take time to consider how the skills of your education can be applied to various fields, even in an abstract manner. I graduated into a recession with a degree in graphic design. I have since learned how to apply my artist training to a variety of things, including data analysis and workflow efficiencies.

Elementary Education should set you up for cat herding, in general, which can be applied to a variety of fields including event planning. If you have an interest in anything medical, you could further pursue nursing with a focus in pediatric care. While your major, in general, is intended to give you a direction and specific training, it is not a limiter or restriction on what you can do with it after graduation.
 
some of the best life advice I ever got was from a Star Wars book titled Traitor. In it, a character named Vergere gives advice to Jacen Solo in the form of a simple mantra "Choose. And act." This was to get Jacen to stop agonizing over every single decision he had to make (something I personally struggle with).
You are a giga autist but that's somewhat wholesome. You are right, this shit can be agonizing.
 
  • Feels
Reactions: Frank(en) Castle
You don't have to use your engineering degree to "be an engineer". You can just have a more legit resume for non-engineering jobs than people with fluff majors, or do a short stint of engineering to establish legitimacy/street cred before pivoting to a business role, etc.

In an overly credentialed society, an engineering degree is for the most part still a credential that means something.

You are right, and I don't at all regret having the paper, but I've yet to figure out what I genuinely like. It's pretty frustrating.
 
There are endless ways to transition from one career to another, even unrelated ones. The biggest loss of choosing the wrong major is the time sunk. God only know I wish I had spent more time reading in college instead of goofing off. Professors and fellow students can help, but inevitably everybody must learn whatever topic on one's own; nobody can learn it for you, so don't feel like you can't reinvent yourself without sinking more time and money into formal education (though some jobs require it). Find a job for now and study to prepare for your next move in your free time. Then, you have a sensible explanation for why you're transitioning from one type of career to another for a job interview. Don't say, "I realized I made a huge mistake;" come up with some tenuous connection of "well, I enjoy this about my current career, but I realized I could apply these skills over here and discovered I'm really interested in doing that." Even the STEMiest jobs benefit from the sort of soft skills, especially communication and writing, that you get more of in a liberal arts or humanities track. You'll be surprised how many people in the working world can't articulate themselves at all. For example, you might be a worse software developer but better suited to manage a team or a project than a 100% coding kind of guy. I don't want to sound like I'm handwaving the difficulty of getting a good job, but it does no good to lose faith either.
 
I think it matters how much student debt you have, and will have after switching.

Not an issue/manageable? Switch now. Fuck it. All you've lost is time
Considerable amount? Just finish it, ride out a couple years paying off the loan, and then do your STEM degree. Don't put yourself in crippling debt

STEM or elementary, people are struggling to find employment regardless, so you can take a chance with switching and hope the job market gets better when you're done (assuming your STEM field is having job market issues right now). Also, having an elementary degree along with a STEM degree could be very beneficial to you, depending on what that STEM degree is. I understand following your heart and all that crap, but you can't put yourself in an awful financial position in doing so.

Tell your family before you do anything, though.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Toji Suzuhara
You are right, and I don't at all regret having the paper, but I've yet to figure out what I genuinely like. It's pretty frustrating.
Every Fortune 500 has entire teams of "Pricing Analysts", "Financial Analysts", "Business Analysts", "Risk Analysts" that all amount to learning their internal business systems, keeping them running, and producing/interpreting reports. Then you can move up the chain from Analyst I to Analyst II or Senior Analyst, Associate, Senior Associate, or whatever else they call their individual contributor ranks, and then Manager, Senior Manager, Associate VP, Senior VP, Director, etc.

So one path is to take one of those generic analyst jobs, learn that business line and company's systems well, then either get promoted up out of the grunt work, or use your knowledge & reputation to lateral over into an adjacent team/biz line.

They'll probably also have a dedicated Project/Program Management Office, with people regarded as internal consultants: clueless about individual business lines but eager to slap their project templates onto everything, make slides, and update "stakeholders" on Green/Amber/Red status. If you start here you're more likely to get stuck because you may not learn anything else, but if you move there from another area they'll be excited to have someone who knows an actual biz line (and the other teams you're assigned to will appreciate that you've done "real work" before).
 
So, recently I’ve switched from STEM to elementary education. I wish I could tell you my thought process behind that

My guess is you realized there is too much math and/or you're just not cut out for it.

I am about two semesters away from graduating and I don’t think the classes I’ve taken amount to anything more than “General Studies”.

Yes, Elementary Education is exactly that - general studies. If you've ever talked to someone in K-12 education you realize pretty quickly that these people are typically unremarkable in every way. There are very few exceptions, but for the most part these people aren't particularly talented. And the pay will reflect that.

As far as what to do, well you've left out some pretty important information such as:
  • What are you good at? For instance, do you have any particular skills beyond what the average barista/dishwasher/warehouse worker might have?
  • What do you enjoy doing that is actually a marketable skill? Everyone likes to play vidya, watch porn and shitpost online, so...other than that?
The fact that you haven't considered these things doesn't bode well for you actually solving this "problem". Also, if you're actually trans please stay away from teaching. Kids have enough shit to deal with already, no need to throw your mental illness in their face too.
 
I can't imagine putting in at least 10 additional years of schooling just to go hundreds of thousands of dollars into debt to work extremely long and arduous shifts at a hospital.
I don't necessarily mean becoming a doctor. Nursing, physical therapy, radiology: all careers that can make bank, even with a 2 year degree.
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Toji Suzuhara
I started out in college studying nursing, with the intent to also complete pre-med courses. During my second year of college, though, my mental health took a turn for the worse and I realized that, while I was actually doing well in my classes, I was not going to survive clinicals. So, I opted to switch over to history (with a focus on the history of science, since I'd already made it well over a quarter of the way to a degree in biology and didn't want to waste my credits). Having no idea what to do with that, I decided that it made sense to join one of my friends in grad school for political science, and to focus on ethnic conflict and genocide in Sub-Saharan Africa for bonus uselessness because it sounded neat at the time.

At one point, I did plan to go to either lawschool or a doctoral program in secondary education, but both were ideas from my then-fiancé's family. I didn't want to do it and, after we broke up, I pretty much just went through the motions of applying because I didn't know what else to do with my life. I didnt know it at the time, but I would later be diagnosed with what I can really only describe as the boring kind of Borderline Personality Disorder (although I'll admit that I spent years refusing a full psych evaluation because I was afraid to learn that Dogshit Manchild - 'Deserves to Die in a Dumpster Fire' Subtype was an actual diagnostic category in the DSM-V). Sadly, I will never know the simple joys of running to the ER screaming that I want to die because my favorite shirt's ruined. I was, however, ridiculously good at allowing other people to define who I was and hold complete control how I felt when this happened. At one point, I stumbled, hungover and maybe still a little drunk from a movie party the night before, into an early admissions exam that I hadn't studied for because I didn't actually care, and somehow managed to get a score high enough to look like a typo (it was the 2014 or 2015 MAT, for anyone familiar with admissions exams; raw scores over 500 are so rare that anything above 510 just looks wrong). Sometimes, I'm still a little impressed by my 23 year old self's dedication to squandering opportunities, but yeah. In the end, I opted not to go for a third, potentially more useful degree.

So, with a bachelor's in history, a master's in political science, and absolutely no idea what I wanted to do, I started looking for work. I did honestly struggle for awhile, but that was mostly because I live in a place where trees outnumber people, and where the most lucrative career opportunities usually require a road onto Forest Service land, a 1992 Honda Civic with no muffler, several months' supply of Sudafed purchased by some dudes called Squirmy and Slim, and a handgun in case you get out there to check on your investment and find some cunt rummaging around the trunk (face tats are optional, but highly encouraged). Overall, I've done well for myself, and having a degree in something has opened a lot of doors, none of which lead to a garage full of stolen high school lab equipment. In retrospect, a lot of what I thought was totally aimless bullshitting around was actually my own deeply buried awareness of what I do and don't enjoy, leading me down a path that ended with me being considerably more experienced and worldly than my peers from high school who chose to go straight into either the High Asian meatgrinder, the meth mines out near the Tennessee line, the true horror that is fast food, or even genuinely high-paying construction or agricultural management jobs.

TL;DR, you should live life for yourself sometimes. Maybe even if you don't really know what that means yet. As long as you don't do anything completely stupid and ensure that you're going to have food and shelter, it's better to have meaningful experiences that you enjoy than it is to waste your entire life doing what you think is expected of you by others. If you want to teach some kids, teach some kids. It's vitally important work that carries a lot of meaning. I work in healthcare and I've seen old people who did everything "the right way". Their kids never visit, they've never been on vacation to anywhere that isn't covered in neon and fake palm trees, they think their neighbors talking about the dinner menu are gossiping about them because they see Spanish as an unlearnable shadow tongue, they think smoking a joint will cause you to go crazy and eat some dude's face, and they always bitch about the rain until the Sun comes out to be bitched about again. Basically everyone dies either unconscious or delirious, shitting themselves in a room they share with a stranger who just wishes they'd go already so they can watch Yellowstone in peace. You don't want to get there without prioritizing the things you love, because they're not going to be there in that fucking room.
 
Last edited:
I don't necessarily mean becoming a doctor. Nursing, physical therapy, radiology: all careers that can make bank, even with a 2 year degree.
Those professions still require years of training and experience before you're making true money.
 
Back