I will also try to necro. I don't read many comics and I'm trying to read some comics. I've only ever read 2 comics in my life, which I will now compare and contrast.
Watchmen - I fucking hated Watchmen. Absolutely despised it. With every page I could feel Alan Moore peering over my shoulder, demanding that I recognize his genius as being far too great for comics, while also insisting that I not enjoy the experience. Alan Moore only wanted Watchmen to be read ironically by hipsters who are too cool for comics.
Sandman - On the other hand, this was actually pretty good. I really enjoyed Dream being a sort of alien main character. (And if there was anything I didn't hate about Watchmen, it was Dr. Manhattan.) He had his own code and morality which, while I don't think it was always portrayed consistently, made for a cool character. I was far more interested in the stories where Dream went off doing insane god shit rather than the basic bitch boring stories about basic bitch boring people and their basic bitch boring lives. I did like the one about Joshua Norton. And anybody who remembers Chesteron is alright in my book. I'm not sure why people always sperg out over Death, I didn't find her all that interesting. I think it might just be goth waifu lust. I'll forgive the gay shit. It was actually controversial in the 90s rather than being free internet points like it is today.
I don't inherently mind superhero stuff as long as it's actually good, and I'm a casual fan of the DCAU. No weeb shit.
What should I read?