#Comicsgate - The Culture Wars Hit The Funny Books!

[CapeKnight]

Is Frog a slow artist who once told someone to kill themselves? Yes. But there are slower people in the industry who publicly antagonize fans far worse who got a free pass because they are friends with the right people and have the right politics. Much like what she writes, what Gail Simone says can be put in the trash without further consideration.

The point Vikki is trying to make is to insinuate that Frog was fired for reasons unrelated to the totally legitimate foundations behind "OG" Comicsgate, but smuggled himself so he could subvert the pure and good Comicsgate that was into a personality cult. This is what I mean when I analogized "Anti-CG" as Trotskyites. It is also absolutely delusional. Now we have people here in effect arguing things like Tim Doyle hiring private investigators to look into Frog's shit was because his art was slow or something.

I'd like to think a broken clock can be right twice, at least, so I don't dismiss all of Gail's words. Ethan's words can't really be trusted, because he's not aiming them at the right things, not that there isn't some truth to certain things he says or claims. In fact, the irony of it all is that the things that are almost always accurate are things about himself, that he projects onto others. I don't dismiss all of his words either.

You might need to help me brush up on Soviet history. It's been awhile for me, but could you clarify the similarities between "Anti-CG" and Trotskyites? Might be my habit of staying up late into the night is severely affecting my ability to see the analogy here, or it could be that I'm forgetting something here. Not saying that you are wrong, I just need some help seeing the point.

 

[Newman's Own]

You might need to help me brush up on Soviet history. It's been awhile for me, but could you clarify the similarities between "Anti-CG" and Trotskyites? Might be my habit of staying up late into the night is severely affecting my ability to see the analogy here, or it could be that I'm forgetting something here. Not saying that you are wrong, I just need some help seeing the point.

Trotsky was an OG from Lenin's group when the commies took over. After Lenin's death and Stalin's ascension Trotsky was marginalized deposed, exiled/escaped and eventually murdered. His "Trotskyite" followers had more anarcho-communist sympathies and were likewise marginalized, expelled and or murdered.

OGCG bears multiple similarities including paranoia and persecution complexes.

Everything Tim Doyle did was over Twitter drama not Ethan getting fired or who he voted for. Tim's a vindictive social justice nut case.

 

[CapeKnight]

Trotsky was an OG from Lenin's group when the commies took over. After Lenin's death and Stalin's ascension Trotsky was marginalized deposed, exiled/escaped and eventually murdered. His "Trotskyite" followers had more anarcho-communist sympathies and were likewise marginalized, expelled and or murdered.

OGCG bears multiple similarities including paranoia and persecution complexes.

Everything Tim Doyle did was over Twitter drama not Ethan getting fired or who he voted for. Tim's a vindictive social justice nut case.

Oh yeah, I knew Trotsky was initially the one Lenin wanted, not Stalin. From what I understand, many could say Stalin co-opted the movement.

Who would be Trotsky in the case of "Anti-CG"? Since we all know who is probably the Stalin of CG.

 

[Newman's Own]

Oh yeah, I knew Trotsky was initially the one Lenin wanted, not Stalin. From what I understand, many could say Stalin co-opted the movement.

Who would be Trotsky in the case of "Anti-CG"? Since we all know who is probably the Stalin of CG.

It's an imperfect analogy. You could call any of the creators cast out after Ethan took over Trotsky but it wouldn't matter. I wised up during the Tennaple exile so I guess you could pick him.

 

[Mister Dongs]

I'd like to think a broken clock can be right twice, at least, so I don't dismiss all of Gail's words. Ethan's words can't really be trusted, because he's not aiming them at the right things, not that there isn't some truth to certain things he says or claims. In fact, the irony of it all is that the things that are almost always accurate are things about himself, that he projects onto others. I don't dismiss all of his words either.

I don't necessarily believe everything or even most things Frog says either. But I can place the story in the environment within which the incident took place, when the two main publishers and the indie scene were aggressively pushing the same leftist ideology and comic professionals were attacking any criticism of the "diversification" of their properties, as if these stories were just some soulless brand, as based on racism, sexist and fascism. And if you think this is empty rhetoric on my part, just remember how they went in on Zack. Who publicly stood by Zack? Frog. If you think that didn't play a factor in it and believe Gail Simone wholeheartedly because you don't like Frog to the point where you'll believe anything negative said about him by anyone? Dunno what else I can say.

But speaking of self-projection, most anything Gail Simone accuses Frog of doing could just as easily be applied to herself. Being late and hard to work with? Simone was fired from Batgirl (Frog at least was allowed to file a resignation) for not turning in scripts and not responding to e-mails or calls from her editors, claimed "sexism" was the reason for it and sicced her online fanbase on DC until she was restated. In fact, without Gail Simone stoking up an outrage mob herself in the 1990s with Women in Refridgerators, where she called the death of female characters as grounds for sexism of the comic book creators, she would have never been elevated/bribed with a writer position and moved beyond the fanfic she was pumping out at the time. She never moved beyond it in craft, that's for sure. I suspect what pisses off Gail the most is how she sold all her leverage for a writing gig on a B-list DC title compared to what Frog has done.

It's an imperfect analogy. You could call any of the creators cast out after Ethan took over Trotsky but it wouldn't matter. I wised up during the Tennaple exile so I guess you could pick him.

I agree that it's an imperfect analogy. Frog fits the mold of Lenin far more than Stalin.
Technically "OG Comicsgate" fits the mold of the "Bread and Roses" Kropotkinite followers who opposed Lenin than Trotskyites, but the main players in "Anti-CG" adopt far more of Frog's ideas in practice than YBZ or say Douglas Ernst. That's why I analogized them to Trotskyites.

I also agree that TenNapel is a good pick. Talented, vain, factional, puritanical and you can't see daylight between how he does things and how Frog does them while both insist the other is vile corruption of "real CG".

 

[Newman's Own]

I agree that it's an imperfect analogy. Frog fits the mold of Lenin far more than Stalin.
Technically "OG Comicsgate" fits the mold of the "Bread and Roses" Kropotkinite followers who opposed Lenin than Trotskyites, but the main players in "Anti-CG" adopt far more of Frog's ideas in practice than YBZ or Douglas Ernst.

I agree that TenNapel is a good pick. Talented, vain, factional, puritanical and you can't see daylight between how he does things and how Frog does them while both insist the other is vile corruption of "real CG".

I disagree. I think Meyer would be the Lenin in this analogy without a doubt. A man of vision who was the initial figure head of a movement he had no idea what to do with once it proved at least temporarily successful.

Ethan is clearly the Stalin character complete with the purges, the pragmatism over ideology, secret police and vain historical revisionism. Anyone whose heard the story of applause for Stalin and watched a recent Ethan live stream live stream with multiple creator/sycophants might see the parallel. Adam Post is always the last one to stop "clapping" much to Micah's chagrine.

As to Trotsky, Doug T would make a good analog. Trotsky was romanticized by many who vilified Stalin rightly and vilified by Stalanist tankies to this day. The truth is somewhere in between but makes for a less compelling story than the more extreme interpretations of noble hero or scurrilous traitor.

The main difference is that Trotsky, Stalin, Lenin and Van Sciver are all collectivist in there rhetoric and actions while Meyer and TenNaple are individualists, at least by my reckoning. I can't imagine Doug or Richard referring to their fans collectively as a group of "alpha males" or demanding loyalty to the cause.

All analogies are imperfect by nature though.

 

[CapeKnight]

I don't necessarily believe everything or even most things Frog says either. But I can place the story in the environment within which the incident took place, when the two main publishers and the indie scene were aggressively pushing the same leftist ideology and comic professionals were attacking any criticism of the "diversification" of their properties, as if these stories were just some soulless brand, as based on racism, sexist and fascism. And if you think this is empty rhetoric on my part, just remember how they went in on Zack. Who publicly stood by Zack? Frog. If you think that didn't play a factor in it and believe Gail Simone wholeheartedly because you don't like Frog to the point where you'll believe anything negative said about him by anyone? Dunno what else I can say.

But speaking of self-projection, most anything Gail Simone accuses Frog of doing could just as easily be applied to herself. Being late and hard to work with? Simone was fired from Batgirl (Frog at least was allowed to file a resignation) for not turning in scripts and not responding to e-mails or calls from her editors, claimed "sexism" was the reason for it and sicced her online fanbase on DC until she was restated. In fact, without Gail Simone stoking up an outrage mob herself in the 1990s with Women in Refridgerators, where she called the death of female characters as grounds for sexism of the comic book creators, she would have never been elevated/bribed with a writer position and moved beyond the fanfic she was pumping out at the time. She never moved beyond it in craft, that's for sure. I suspect what pisses off Gail the most is how she sold all her leverage for a writing gig on a B-list DC title compared to what Frog has done.


I agree that it's an imperfect analogy. Frog fits the mold of Lenin far more than Stalin.
Technically "OG Comicsgate" fits the mold of the "Bread and Roses" Kropotkinite followers who opposed Lenin than Trotskyites, but the main players in "Anti-CG" adopt far more of Frog's ideas in practice than YBZ or say Douglas Ernst. That's why I analogized them to Trotskyites.

I agree that TenNapel is a good pick. Talented, vain, factional, puritanical and you can't see daylight between how he does things and how Frog does them while both insist the other is vile corruption of "real CG".

Oh no, I'm not saying to believe someone wholeheartedly. Fuck that. I don't like either of them equally. I'm just a bit of a scale, choosing when to shift who to completely shit on and let the weight fall on them, this time around, it's just been Ethan, and I think rightfully so. I spent the last 2 years shitting on SJWs in other fields of things, and in each turn, I came to find some level of hypocrisy in those who pretend to stand up against them. There's some good faith actors in there, so I leave them alone. When it came to ComicsGate though, I was just a little surprised (since I wasn't around during GamerGate) to see that the big head prominent figure is just this bad as well.

Gail is rightfully called a whale. Her Women in Refrigerators was just bad takes, because it hyper focuses on the notion that women are the only ones who have it bad, and leaves out the fact that every other character also suffers similar fates. Jason Todd would love to answer to that, he's been the poster boy for that kind of story. The fact that she even gets work is beyond me, but I suppose you could call me a "sexist" for this, but I generally hold men to a higher standard than women in terms of conduct based on how society has been. Which is just the main reason of my criticism of Ethan. He acts all alpha, but he's more like an omega. I don't expect women like Gail to be able to actually achieve the "equality" they so claim to seek, but is actually seeking power plays, because society hasn't exactly treated women like they have agency to begin with, which makes them infantile and manifests in weirdos like Gail. If Gail really wanted women to be empowered, she'd have stepped down herself years ago and given the job to more capable women, or even men who can write women better than she could, but then again, because of how society has essentially become gynocentric, I don't ever expect that to happen. Ethan, however, is a man, who claims to have worked his way up in the world from a poor family (or so he claims), so he should be very familiar that the world generally treats men much harsher, yet he bitches and acts like the opposite of someone who had to build things up from scratch. Gail and Ethan are two sides of the same kind: they're both stuck in Post-Modernist thinking, explaining their constant shitty conducts. Gail gets off the hook more because that's just how society is, and if you want that to change, you'd have to restructure society, which is what this culture war bullshit is supposed to really be about, and I don't see Ethan as having done a good enough job, if even trying at all. To the point where I think he should just shut the fuck up, and go fuck off in the sunset and let his movement and his e-celeb status die off because he did more harm than good, much like how MauLer and the EFAP furfags regressed the topic of "Objectivty and Subjectivity".

I'd just like a new actual counter culture that isn't full of shit.

 

[Southern Man]

EVS was obviously behind the trolling of Waid after Waid did his show. But he isn't a man, he's got the mind of a bi-polar little girl and therefor he lacked the guts to admit it.

 

[Mister Dongs]

I disagree. I think Meyer would be the Lenin in this analogy without a doubt. A man of vision who was the initial figure head of a movement he had no idea what to do with once it proved at least temporarily successful.

Marx was the man with the vision though.
Lenin was the man with the ability to develop an effective means of realizing that vision, and totally had an idea of what to do with power once seizing it - blood vengeance and dabbing on everyone who ever doubted him.

One of the first things Lenin did after becoming the autocrat of the Soviet Union was to harness the state press to print a book he wrote dedicated to his comrades in the Third Internationale centered in Berlin (where everyone thought the Revolution was going to kick off) like Karl "Cuck" Kautsky and their refusal to organize attacks against the established order, abandon pacifism or anarchism, use the enemy's tactics against them, so-on, and then have the book smuggled into Germany to be perused by the Berlin socialist underground.
Descriptively, he titled it:

Lenin concluded with the conciliatory gesture that, while the readers and their leaders held pathetic, childish sensibilities that made them worthless non-entities in the great class struggle, unlike him and the Bolsheviks who actually got shit done, they were still at least one thousand times better than right-wing capitalists, who were worthy only of extermination. This had its desired effect, leading to the failed German Revolution of 1918 led by Rosa Luxembourg (VikkiVerse), where the ringleaders were viciously stomped to death by German reactionaries. Lenin probably jerked off so hard to the news of this that his brain exploded.

If you can imagine a more Frog-level move than this, I'd like to hear it.

 

[Newman's Own]

Marx was the man with the vision though.
Lenin was the man with the ability to develop an effective means of realizing that vision, and totally had an idea of what to do with power once seizing it - blood vengeance and dabbing on everyone who ever doubted him.

One of the first things Lenin did after becoming the autocrat of the Soviet Union was to harness the state press to print a book he wrote dedicated to his comrades in the Third Internationale centered in Berin (where everyone thought the Revolution was going to kick off) like Karl "Cuck" Kautsky and their refusal to organize attacks against the established order, abandon pacifism, use the enemy's tactics against them, so-on,, and then have the book smuggled into Germany to be perused by the Berlin socialist underground, Descriptively, he titled it:

View attachment 1272210

Lenin concluded that while the readers and their leaders held pathetic, childish sensibilities that made them worthless non-entities in the great class struggle, unlike him who actually got shit done, they were still at least one thousand times better than right-wing capitalists, who were worthy only of extermination. This had its desired effect, leading to the failed German Revolution of 1918 led by Rosa Luxembourg (VikkiVerse), where the ringleaders were viciously stomped to death by German reactionaries. Lenin probably jerked off so hard to the news of this that his brain exploded.

If you can imagine a more Frog-level move than this, I'd like to hear it.

When I speak of Lenin as the visionary I'm not speaking of the idea of communism. That wasn't even an original idea for Marx who followed Hegel, Kant and others. Lenin was a failure as a head of state unable to feed his people or organize labor post revolution. He didn't know what he was doing. Stalin tightened things up. If Lenin had lived there was a very good chance the revolution would have been countered or replaced by another by the 40's.

I'm speaking in terms of action. Meyer's vision of what comics should be wasn't original but it was him that inspired thousands of nerds. They sperged out because he started in comics what "ethics in journalism" did for gamergate and video games. Ethan was denying CG existed when it started. Ethan joined the fight after the victory (unlike Stalin, analogies are always imperfect) while Meyer was the man instigating the fight and leading from the front. Ethan didn't lead a revolution. He inherited one like Stalin did.

As to FROG level moves. Ethan played out the betrayal of Trotsky (who was a rival to the man and not a betrayer of the cause) theater again and again and again. What could be more Stalin than the FROG painting rivals as betrayers to destroy them?

Nerkish, Lim, TenNaple, Miller and others were all painted as traitors for silly or imagined miss deeds against the cause when for the most part their sin was being the first to stop clapping.

I'm not picking up on the Rosa Luxembourg analogy at all.

 

[Wise Man]

Last Week is was Jon, Anna, and Cecil. This week it's Yaboi Zack in the cross hairs. The shithawks never rest.
And a broken clock is NEVER right because Time doesn't stand still and most clocks are digital now anyway.


And stop with this faggotrious Lenin and Stalin shit, nobody fucking understands you. (by nobody, I just mean I don't, but I'm everybody's voice)

Yaboi Zack is Zeon Daikun​	and EVS is Degwin Sodo Zabi​
Misunderstood idealist, critical of authority but optimistic about humanity. Stressed himself to an early grave. Promoted Spacenoid rights, but said #Spacenoid is not the destination, and that we all must seek to surpass it.​	Corrupt Oligarch and opportunist, hijacks his friend Zeon's movement into forming his own kingdom (Naming it the Principality of Zeon). Also sits down a lot in a chair, fat, bald, and has a big nose. Promotes #Spacenoid Supremacy, commits mass genocide against neutral space colonies that refuse to join.​

Anime is real, it's always been with us.

 

[Smug Freiza]

Ro convinces a drunk ginger fuck who is neither CG or anti-CG to buy Vestige, play a recording of a clip he sent to Crypto, and promises that since he plays the recording, that if he gives him his order number, he'll send him extra merch. I could barely make out what was said in the recording because it's a bunch of yelling, but damn was that hilarious.

Also, Ro calls @Mister Dongs the "Kiwifarms cuckold representative".

Liamstream is where all the hilarity ensues.

If that idiot Ryzie Lee sends his contribution ID to Ro all for an extra Vestige sticker he is even stupider than he appeared on stream. It was obvious that they want his dox so they can use him to dismiss the recorded evidence in Panboy's trial as inadmissible. Whether or not the drunkard, pillow fucking, weeb dole bludger takes the bait, we'll have to wait and see.

I doubt it's a lie. There are plenty of other Republicans that were silently drummed out of the industry because of their politics. Sometimes they weren't even outspoken, see Mitch Breitweiser for example.

Mike S Miller was blacklisted for his homophobic postings on public forums, the exact same thing happened to him in Comicsgate. His posting in Comicsgate was far less egregious with a simple "pride is a sin", compared to his old postings about homosexuals being compared to pedophiles and bestiality. Comicsgate blacklisted him for less.

Also Mitch Breitweiser worked at Marvel, not DC. DC seems far more tolerant of conservatives than Marvel. Again Mitch had a poor reputation for being late with his work, just looking at Red Rooster proves there might be some validity to those rumors.

Just to hammer the point home to people with short term memory, remember this?

Who Vandalized a Comics Pizzaria After Ethan van Sciver's Appearance? | Bleeding Fool

by Micah Curtis | After receiving multiple threats online, Ethan Van Sciver (Green Lantern, The Flash) appeared at Gotham City Pizza in Florida to do live drawing and sign comics, plus talk to fans. After his appearance, the business was vandalized, allegedly by SJW’s looking to intimidate the...

bleedingfool.com

I remember the Gotham City pizza incident, what about it? Was there any conclusive evidence to prove it was because of Ethan's appearance? SJW's normally want their message heard, I'm surprised the shop wasn't spray painted with "fuck nazis" or "say no to hate" or some other slogan.

It could have been a disgruntled customer who didn't get enough pizza toppings, or could have been drunk youths just looking to vandalize property. It might have even been the store owner himself looking to get some attention and headline catching stories to advertise his business.

Nobody knows at this point.

That guy really got around YouTube and I always wondered to myself, how on earth does anyone listen to him for more than 5 seconds and believe he's someone you want on your side?

I always always bewildered at the warm reception he got in this thread.... he's like if TheQuartering was into comics

People are naturally sympathetic to anti-SJW figures online, just because most people find SJWs to be repulsive. However history has shown with Sargon, Kraut N Tea, Mundane Matt and multiple others that eventually the anti-SJW becomes the SJW or worse.

That would seem to be all the evidence necessary to posit a theory that the people who said that was why his contract wasn't renewed might not be lying.

Speaking of historical revisionism, the greatest example comes from Comicsgate itself. Ethan was never fired or blacklisted, he asked to get out of his contract early so he could focus on Cyberfrog. This was common knowledge initially but over the years it has morphed from being blacklisted to being fired like a game of telephone.

EVS was obviously behind the trolling of Waid after Waid did his show. But he isn't a man, he's got the mind of a bi-polar little girl and therefor he lacked the guts to admit it.

I've noticed it is a common theme around Ethan for years now, that his supporters imitate his enemies online. The first example was Alfie Norris several years before Comicsgate. He had several accounts in parodies of his name (and actual name) harassing him, his girlfriend and his family. Next we have the Mark Waid in Ethan's chat, more recently the twitter imposters of Vikkiverse, her sister and several other accounts @TheLaughingMan keeps track of.

Its quite the coincidence.

 

[GranDuke]

Last thing I expected in this thread is discussion about who is Lenin and who is Stalin of CG. I think you are seriously overthinking how gay-ops operators work.

Speaking of historical revisionism, the greatest example comes from Comicsgate itself. Ethan was never fired or blacklisted, he asked to get out of his contract early so he could focus on Cyberfrog. This was common knowledge initially but over the years it has morphed from being blacklisted to being fired like a game of telephone.

I vaguely remember him claiming that he was offered Vertigo project before he left, but decided against it due to money being lower than what he felt he could get from crowdfunding. And he probably made a right choice as far as money goes, but it does show that despite being right-wing sperg DC was still willing to work with him. Or at least thats what he claimed. Or maybe I'm remembering things wrong.

 

[Newman's Own]

Speaking of historical revisionism, the greatest example comes from Comicsgate itself. Ethan was never fired or blacklisted, he asked to get out of his contract early so he could focus on Cyberfrog. This was common knowledge initially but over the years it has morphed from being blacklisted to being fired like a game of telephone.

That was Ethan's story but given his clear narcissism I don't see much possibility that Ethan would cop to not having his contract renewed if he could spin a different more flattering yarn.

The story is disputed by multiple sources. I think it would be foolish to accept Gail or Ethan's version at face value.

Also, hasn't Ethan's version of his exit from DC changed a number of times. In literature he is what's called an unreliable narrator.

I've noticed it is a common theme around Ethan for years now, that his supporters imitate his enemies online. The first example was Alfie Norris several years before Comicsgate. He had several accounts in parodies of his name (and actual name) harassing him, his girlfriend and his family. Next we have the Mark Waid in Ethan's chat, more recently the twitter imposters of Vikkiverse, her sister and several other accounts @TheLaughingMan keeps track of.

Its quite the coincidence.

I totally agree. None of that is proven but it is a preponderance of coincidence.

Last thing I expected in this thread is discussion about who is Lenin and who is Stalin of CG. I think you are seriously overthinking how gay-ops operators work.

It's more of a mental exercise than anything. Analogies are quirky devices prone to sparking entertaining but useless debate. I was entertained by it. I can't speak for Dongs but I suspect he enjoyed it too.

Analogies are always imperfect.

 

[CapeKnight]

I enjoyed the Soviet history analogies. Thank God I egged it on. Allowed me to refresh my memory on things.

 

[A nameless trool]

Oh no, I'm not saying to believe someone wholeheartedly. Fuck that. I don't like either of them equally. I'm just a bit of a scale, choosing when to shift who to completely shit on and let the weight fall on them, this time around, it's just been Ethan, and I think rightfully so. I spent the last 2 years shitting on SJWs in other fields of things, and in each turn, I came to find some level of hypocrisy in those who pretend to stand up against them. There's some good faith actors in there, so I leave them alone. When it came to ComicsGate though, I was just a little surprised (since I wasn't around during GamerGate) to see that the big head prominent figure is just this bad as well.

Gail is rightfully called a whale. Her Women in Refrigerators was just bad takes, because it hyper focuses on the notion that women are the only ones who have it bad, and leaves out the fact that every other character also suffers similar fates. Jason Todd would love to answer to that, he's been the poster boy for that kind of story. The fact that she even gets work is beyond me, but I suppose you could call me a "sexist" for this, but I generally hold men to a higher standard than women in terms of conduct based on how society has been. Which is just the main reason of my criticism of Ethan. He acts all alpha, but he's more like an omega. I don't expect women like Gail to be able to actually achieve the "equality" they so claim to seek, but is actually seeking power plays, because society hasn't exactly treated women like they have agency to begin with, which makes them infantile and manifests in weirdos like Gail. If Gail really wanted women to be empowered, she'd have stepped down herself years ago and given the job to more capable women, or even men who can write women better than she could, but then again, because of how society has essentially become gynocentric, I don't ever expect that to happen. Ethan, however, is a man, who claims to have worked his way up in the world from a poor family (or so he claims), so he should be very familiar that the world generally treats men much harsher, yet he bitches and acts like the opposite of someone who had to build things up from scratch. Gail and Ethan are two sides of the same kind: they're both stuck in Post-Modernist thinking, explaining their constant shitty conducts. Gail gets off the hook more because that's just how society is, and if you want that to change, you'd have to restructure society, which is what this culture war bullshit is supposed to really be about, and I don't see Ethan as having done a good enough job, if even trying at all. To the point where I think he should just shut the fuck up, and go fuck off in the sunset and let his movement and his e-celeb status die off because he did more harm than good, much like how MauLer and the EFAP furfags regressed the topic of "Objectivty and Subjectivity".

I'd just like a new actual counter culture that isn't full of shit.

Gail is profitting of the sexism of the comicbook industry. She is a very visible (due to twitter and body weight) woman in a field with very few prominent women. She is the go-to person when editors look for a woman writer. And she has a massive ego because of it, because a hair-dresser got to write some b-rate superhero titles. From what I have read from her, she is Zack-tier at her best. And she can write some funny tweets and funny word baloons.
And, judging from my experience with her in conventions, she went through a lot of shit early on, was told too many times she was wrong and big, strong men was the only way to do comics. She did otherwise and needs to flex about her wins. Constantly. This is why she acts like a cunt and she pulled an EVS with the Batgirl editorial. Her fake-geek-auntie youtube videos are exactly how she comes across IRL.


EVS is... I believe he is aware of his narcisism and often overplays it for show. He can also be entertaining when he does that, his larger than life persona is fun in small doses and can host a talk show quite well, maybe because of his narcisism. I can see how he could get jobs at DC (his pencils and storytelling are good) and also get on some people's nerves.
At the point he was left on his own, free from editorial and social media policies, he is getting wilder and more unhinged. The constant stress and confrontations are like a drug getting him high and validating his ego. And I can see him saying one thing, then another - what matters to him is to look good to present company.

But I cannot see him as the puppetmaster running gay ops. He is so desperate to brag about them he would be unable to keep them secret. I can see a Wormtongue in the background (maybe Ro, maybe somebody we do not see) running a lot of shit in his name while pledging full allegiance to him, dethroning everyone threatening their influence.

Both of them are products of the late 90's comicbook industry - mediocre (Gail)/solid (EVS) creators with massive egos, raised to great standards by shill media, fanbois and fungirls, the convention circle and wannabes who buttered them up to get a foot in the door. I have been in a lot of conventions and have met some legendary creators from the 70's and 80's. They tend to be the kindest, most humble normal people one can meet.
The 90's ones are so bloated with ego, weird and prone to be insulted by any comment.
EVS says that the Wizard magazine made comics great. I believe it created the culture that destroyed comicbooks. And then Women In Refrigerators, Bleeding Cool and all those pop culture blogs created a generation of nobodies that thought they would be Alan Moore reborn if they added a Latina Lesbian character with the side of her head shaved in their sci fi comic. As if Love And Rockets was never a thing...

 

[CapeKnight]

But I cannot see him as the puppetmaster running gay ops. He is so desperate to brag about them he would be unable to keep them secret. I can see a Wormtongue in the background (maybe Ro, maybe somebody we do not see) running a lot of shit in his name while pledging full allegiance to him, dethroning everyone threatening their influence.

I slightly agree and disagree. I think Ethan runs gay ops here and there, but he's not the definite puppet master, at least, not always. We've seen that Ro is the one who wears the pants in the dynamic between them, so it's clear that Ro and WC run things, but I'm pretty sure if not a lot, then some of it is discussed beforehand and told to Ethan either before or after it was being conducted. WC have elevated themselves by claiming to do things in good faith for what's best for CG.

 

[Elwood P. Dowd]

As to Trotsky, Doug T would make a good analog. Trotsky was romanticized by many who vilified Stalin rightly and vilified by Stalanist tankies to this day. The truth is somewhere in between but makes for a less compelling story than the more extreme interpretations of noble hero or scurrilous traitor.

But who will be Comicsgate's Dzerzhinsky?

“We stand for organized terror - this should be frankly admitted. Terror is an absolute necessity during times of revolution. Our aim is to fight against the enemies of the Soviet Government and of the new order of life. We judge quickly. In most cases only a day passes between the apprehension of the criminal and his sentence. When confronted with evidence criminals in almost every case confess; and what argument can have greater weight than a criminal's own confession?”
― Felix Dzerzhinsky

Sure seems like this is the direction they and their gayops are moving in.

 

[cow-wannabe]

In this case I find it more likely he got fired for a mix of politics and laziness as Waid still works at Marvel. Ethan's known to be a slow and lazy artist, which is what probably did the most damage. Politics also really didn't help.

Thing is, Waid has "Kingdom Come" under his belt, so he's got that best-seller/critical success to help offset some of his dickishness.

So, for right or wrong, Waid is always going to be seen as that dick who wrote a classic, while EVS is always going to be that dick who did a TMNT knock-off and was an also-ran on Green Lantern.

 

[Smug Freiza]

But I cannot see him as the puppetmaster running gay ops. He is so desperate to brag about them he would be unable to keep them secret. I can see a Wormtongue in the background (maybe Ro, maybe somebody we do not see) running a lot of shit in his name while pledging full allegiance to him, dethroning everyone threatening their influence.

I slightly agree and disagree. I think Ethan runs gay ops here and there, but he's not the definite puppet master, at least, not always. We've seen that Ro is the one who wears the pants in the dynamic between them, so it's clear that Ro and WC run things, but I'm pretty sure if not a lot, then some of it is discussed beforehand and told to Ethan either before or after it was being conducted. WC have elevated themselves by claiming to do things in good faith for what's best for CG.

The Praetorian and other leaks provide a good look at how CG operates behind the scenes. This will be a long post, with information already provided to this and other threads so I'll spoiler it to prevent it taking up too much space.

Spoiler: LEAKED DM'S

The above image was from a WC group chat, the person Gat Hanzo (author of Vestige) is talking to is Praetorian himself. From this screenshot we can see that Praetorian was the one who was running the CG Anon account with Warcampaigns prior knowledge since Gat tells him to "kill the account". Gat also reveals that he doesn't trust Rax(?) and Yellow Flash, TUG they trust but only one way information implies that TUG feeds them intel on others.


Here we can see Praetorian is sharing a private DM with Ethan to Panboy Soychild Donglover. Ethan clearly approves of CG Anons actions in going after Nerkish, but probably had no fore knowledge of it. Ethan also guesses wrongly that CG Anon is Sketch Therapy, which Panboy replied "CAN'T EVER TELL HIM". This to me, means that Warcampaign's gayops may not always be sanctioned by Ethan in advance. The line about "Ro Kabir was out of town, when that happened, so it wasn't us" seems to also imply that Ro is the one who gives the others their marching orders on gayops and since his out of town they can feign innocence to Ethan if he suspects they were involved.


Here Praetorian is talking to TUG, telling him "he has an all access pass" which implies TUG is in deeper with Warcampaign than his willing to admit. It could be that Praetorian is just buttering TUG up and stoking his ego, since in the first message Gat Hanzo implies that TUG and Warcampaigns relationship will be a one way street from now on. Notice TUG is leaking information from a larger CG creator group to Praetorian/WC as Nerkish tries to defend himself against the Discord allegations.


In the final image we see TUG leaking more of Nerkish's responses to Praetorian and comments "Lol. Fun times" implying that TUG seems to relish in Nerkish's angst and the gayop he has taken part in. TUG is extremely two faced in nature, he can't be trusted by anyone in any of the movements he takes part in.

The following image was leaked in the MBA thread on the Weeb Wars board. An individual was doxed and created the account @AzraelStCloud to come and explain himself. He claims that TUG recruited him to engage in gayops against Kick Vic youtuber Mad Black Atheist, he leaked this conversation where he was getting targeted by pro-Vic supporters while trying to be under cover in MBA's crew. Azrael clearly wants out of the Op but TUG "wrote to senpai to tell him you're a friendly".



There were also the DMs leaked in DA Talks videos regarding TUG and his two faced nature with Emosh and Senpai in the ISWW movement. There are about 10 in total, I won't post them all because this has probably gone on long enough but his video can be found on bitchute here:

DATalks

ThatUmbrellaGuy Aka Matthew Lewis and His Wife Ashley Exposed pt.1

www.bitchute.com

TLDR I believe TUG is the Wormtongue within Comicsgate, there have just been too many examples of him playing a role in gayops within Comicsgate and Weeb Wars. I believe he must have dirt on multiple CG creators because otherwise he would have been kicked to the curb a long time ago.