Creepy Unsolved Mysteries - From unsolved murders to unidentified people to unexplained supernatural events, what are some of the creepiest unsolved mysteries you've ever heard of?

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.

5 Years After Murders Of Abigail Williams And Liberty German In Indiana, Court Documents Uncover Previously-Unknown Details​

DELPHI, Ind. (CBS/AP) — It has been five years since two young teenage girls, Abigail Williams and Liberty German, were murdered on a hiking trail in Delphi, Indiana.

Their killer has never been caught.

But on Wednesday, CNN reported that court documents reveal never-before-known information about cellphone video that one of the girls captured.

The bodies of Liberty German, 14, and Abigail Williams, 13, were found in a rugged area near a hiking trail on Feb. 14, 2017, one day after they vanished while walking on that trail near the Monon High Bridge, just outside their hometown of Delphi, Indiana, about 60 miles northwest of Indianapolis.

Police previously shared a short clip – only one and a half seconds of the recording that Libby made – in which a man is heard saying, “Down the hill.”

But CNN has learned the video is actually 45 seconds long. It is not clear what it shows.

There are also new details about the timeline of the murders – and how quickly it all may have happened. The girls were dropped off at the trial at 1:35 p.m., and 2:07 p.m., Libby shot some pictures and posted two images to Snapchat.

Six minutes later was when Libby shot the video showing a man in close proximity. The girls’ bodies were found the next day.
Holy shit, it's been that long already? Your comment made me go back and watch the video that was released, specifically this one on youtube. Combing through the comments, I came across this one which was left two weeks ago:

delphi murders yt comment.jpg
The few replies to this are just people commenting various bullshit for the last few days. After a few cursory searches, I can't really find anyone by that name, but I'm not the greatest person in regards to finding info about specific people. IDK, it's a youtube commenter so I take it with a handful of salt, but I do find it interesting.
 
Holy shit, it's been that long already? Your comment made me go back and watch the video that was released, specifically this one on youtube. Combing through the comments, I came across this one which was left two weeks ago:

View attachment 3109537
The few replies to this are just people commenting various bullshit for the last few days. After a few cursory searches, I can't really find anyone by that name, but I'm not the greatest person in regards to finding info about specific people. IDK, it's a youtube commenter so I take it with a handful of salt, but I do find it interesting.

There's actually a local news article that has this information as well, but with a slight variations in the story.

The person who wrote it was arrested as well for something but from what he said the police were trying to get him to implicated his father / step father.

It sounds pretty legit too because the state police then put out a statement not directly addressing these allegations but rather the police hadn't put out any of this information.
 
It sounds pretty legit too because the state police then put out a statement not directly addressing these allegations but rather the police hadn't put out any of this information.
Incidentally, that Kegan Kline person was originally arrested in 2016 and is still awaiting trial. The closest trial date, in May of 2022, was recently canceled. The next intended action is in September. Incidentally he was bonded out at some point apparently. His current address is 509 Southlea Drive Apt. F. Kokomo, IN 46902, at least according to the Indiana courts site. The case number is 52C01-2008-F4-000254 in Miami County Court (yes in Indiana).

As for Tony Kline, assuming he's an Anthony Kline, I'm not seeing any real candidates for a criminal case involving this guy yet. A couple of the domestics might be him, as well as some of the credit card debt cases. I'll wait on more specific details of this guy.

The transcript of the interview is 190 pages and might have useful details.
 
Last edited:
If there's a winter coat there's a way.

It looks like it costs $30 for a hardcover on Amazon which isn't bad for a 480 page book. I thought it would be the £143 for a used pocket plus shipping kind of expensive.
What about a kindle version?
 
  • Thunk-Provoking
Reactions: Puff
It's a little late, but the Jane Doe known as Little Miss Nobody was identified last month after being unidentified for 62 years.

Her name is Sharon Lee Gallegos, and she was abducted, and most likely murdered by a currently unknown couple who had been stalking the family. What's even worse is that they mostly had tried to go after her before since Sharon who was usually a very friendly, and cheerful child became incredibly distressed whenever she saw them.

The couple abducted Sharon after trying to lure her into their van with the offer of candy, and clothes, and when she refused, they dragged her in, and drove off. They ceased their stalking afterwards and were never seen again. Their motives are still unknown.

Sharon's remains were too decomposed and charred to properly find an actual cause of death. What they could only determine was that there weren't any puncture wounds, or any broken bones.

Although officials received a tip saying it might've been Sharon after they discovered the body only ten days after she'd been taken, the tip was dismissed as initial age, footprints, and clothing didn't appear to match hers. They also received another tip from the public saying the same thing, but nothing ever came of it until recently.

Sharon was identified through DNA testing, and her family never stopped thinking about her, or mourning the loss of her. Her nephew, Ray Chavez, has thanked the community for keeping his aunt safe, and never forgetting her.

Rest in peace, Sharon. Blessed are the pure in heart indeed.

1650409935987.png1650410044266.png
 

There's actually a local news article that has this information as well, but with a slight variations in the story.

The person who wrote it was arrested as well for something but from what he said the police were trying to get him to implicated his father / step father.

It sounds pretty legit too because the state police then put out a statement not directly addressing these allegations but rather the police hadn't put out any of this information.
This is not blaming the victims or whatever but I had been wondering all these years why a couple of young girls would go hiking in some random ass part of the woods…and why their parents would allow that to happen. Sneaking away or coming up with a excuse to hike in order to meet a cute boy who looks like an underwear model where their parents would definitely disapprove? That makes a lot more sense.

Hope the killer gets found. Still is odd that the real length of the video the girls recorded is 45 seconds and only about 1.5 seconds has been shared.
 
This is not blaming the victims or whatever but I had been wondering all these years why a couple of young girls would go hiking in some random ass part of the woods…and why their parents would allow that to happen.
Hiking is fun. Wandering around in the bush looking for skeletons, snakes, dragons and wallabies is fun. Used to do it a ton when I was a teenager. Admittedly I did have my German Shepherd with me, otherwise my parents might have objected to me going out by myself. It's honestly not strange to me that two teenagers went on a hike together. Teenagers always went bush bashing where I grew up. Maybe a little unusual in that they/I were girls, but girls go hiking all the time.
 
I had been wondering all these years why a couple of young girls would go hiking in some random ass part of the woods
I've always been under the impression that they were on a popular hiking trail and weren't even that far in the woods (aside from having been forced off trail by their killer). I think there were several other people out on the same trail when it happened, some of whom had passed the girls shortly before it happened, which is what made the whole thing all the more shocking for locals.
 
MISSING: TRICIA KELLETT-CALL: 312-744-5594

That format, and number might be familiar to you because it's the exact description used in the infamous Joanna Lopez broadcast, and it's just been discovered to have been used in another one for a completely different person who's been confirmed to actually be real.
1657240480148.png


Tricia Kellett was abducted in Chicago on May 7th, 1982. She last seen playing with some puppies on her neighbor's porch before getting into a car with one, or two men inside. She was never seen again.

Marvin Pontarelli, an absolutely vile man who had an extensive history of breaking, and entering, kidnapping, rape, assault, prostitution, and pedophilia, and who had also been sexually abusing Tricia's friends was investigated, and in addition to finding a stash of weapons, and sexual paraphernalia similar to what the Toy Box Killer would've used as well as fuckton of CP, Pontarelli admitted to killing her, and burying her on one of his family's properties.

However, he later recanted his story, and then said that another man named Larry Fassler who'd been earlier imprisoned on drug charges, and whom Pontarelli wanted to have CP photos of for blackmailing purposes since the former owed him money, kidnapped her and took her to Mexico as his captive. He also claimed that Fassler had even done such things like that before.

Fassler, who may, or may not have because a sex offender due to information on him specifically being scant, and inconsistent (as is on this entire case in general), was interviewed, and investigated, and that was when something incredibly eerie was discovered. He had while he had the address of where Tricia's was taken written down and labeled with Tricia's name, Pontarelli's name, and as well as the date October 1982 below it.

When questioned about this, Fassler said it was because that was the day the police had called him about the case. He also mentioned how he thought Pontarelli was the one who did it because of his pedophilia, and violent history.

After that interview, he was no longer a suspect. Fassler would continue to be in-and-out of prison on drug charges throughout the remainder of his life, and aside from writing a book in 2006 about how to survive in prison, nothing significant happened involving him. He died in prison sometime in the late 2000s, or early 2010s.

Marvin Pontarelli, however, continued to evade charges despite his massive rap sheet that should've seen him put away because they were almost always dropped. Even worse, the families of the victims were often seen driving new expensive vehicles as well as sporting new, and expensive clothing.

Pontarelli came from a wealthy family, and it's theorized that due to corruption, bribery, and blackmail, he was able to pay off his victims, and continue on destroying lives. Just how many is unknown, but eventually, his crimes finally caught up to him, and he died in prison in 1994.

Despite witnesses stating that he was indeed the man they saw Tricia getting into the car with, and his own confession, it appears that he was never formally charged with her disappearance. Outside making the bullshit claim that maybe he had a split-personality that killed Tricia, he never revealed more about what happened to her either.

Needless to say, all these revelations blow the theory of Joanna's broadcast just being a hoax, ARG, testing screen, or mistake right out the water. Not only that, the broadcast contains an incredibly important detail Joanna's omitted; an actual last known sighting that happened to be six years prior to the broadcasts air date.

This all but confirms that the channel was airing missing persons cases from years ago, which means that Joanna could've gone missing for as long as Tricia was, if not longer. This changes everything and broadens the range of when she could've gone missing considerably. Not only that, it possibly also solves it.

You see, a while back, someone contacted the search claiming to be Joanna. However, she stated to be born in 1970 which would've made her nineteen at the time of first broadcast, and thus would not be eligible for it because she would no longer be a minor.

Due to its airing, and lack of actual information saying exactly she went missing, it was believed she went missing 1988. However, if WMAQ was reporting on cases from years ago, Joanna could've very well gone missing before then when she was a minor, and thus still eligible for a broadcast.

The case is still ongoing, but if this is true, we might just have our girl.

Now, I must address the incredibly fucked up theory that's sprung up after the horrific revelations by the Tricia case-that being that the corruption went as far as even the broadcasting stations, and that's why the slides are so bare bones, and why they had such terrible airing times. It also suggests that Joanna met the same fate as Tricia, and that's why their slides are presented in the same style.

On the surface, this appears disturbingly possible, but it should be mentioned that while Pontarelli was wealthy, and had connections, he wasn't nearly powerful enough to influence entire broadcasting stations. Not only that, while we still don't know her exact age, Joanna was not in the age range of Pontarelli's known victims. It is possible he, or one of his connections are responsible for her disappearance, but it isn't likely.

Neither is the idea that they would set up these broadcasts just to taunt the victims' loved ones. If the stations were corrupt, why would they even air these at all, and not just tell the families to fuck off? Not only that, but why even air them at such times when the people effected by them most likely wouldn't even see them? The first Joanna broadcast reportedly did last all night, but even so, there's a high chance nobody who knew her even saw it.

Pontarelli was a monster of a man, and while I have no doubt he would enjoy mocking the families of the victims who didn't take his bribe money, it's very unlikely he had either the wealth, power, or connections to go that far, and if he did, he most likely done it a different way, or have not done it at all.

I dunno. All I do know is that I never would've guessed a relatively small internet mystery like the Joanna Lopez broadcast would've led to a rabbit hole, and possibility as nightmarish as this, even if the latter is far-fetched.

It would be funny if it wasn't just so fucking real now.
 
Last edited:
Can we add the Georgia Guidestones getting bombed and then destroyed the next day as one of these creepy unsolved mysteries?


Kandiss Taylor claimed the guidestones are satanic and made demolishing them part of her platform. Comedian John Oliver featured the guidestones and Taylor in a segment in late May. McCarthy said right-wing personalities including Alex Jones had talked about them in previous years, but that “they sort of came back onto the public’s radar” because of Taylor.

“God is God all by Himself. He can do ANYTHING He wants to do,” Taylor wrote on social media Wednesday. “That includes striking down Satanic Guidestones.”
Lol are government is an open air lolcow breeding zone
https://wgntv.com/news/nexstar-media-wire/georgia-guidestones-demolished-after-bombing/
 
The disappearance of Michaela Garecht.

On Nov 19, 1988 Michaela Garecht and her friend Katrina Rodriguez walked to a market called Rainbow Market in Heyward California to by snacks. They rose their scooters there and left them out when they got there. After buying their snacks they headed home only to realize they forgot their scooters. They went back to get them and Michela realized her scooter was farther down the parking lot near a parked car. When went to get it but when she did a man grabbed her and dragged her into the car. Katrina was too shocked to move as her friend was dragged into the car screaming. Katrina went to a clerk who called the police. Katrina was the only witness and described the man in as white and his early 20s, having long blonde dark hair, and having an old sedan. that was wither tan or cream colored. A man named Loren Herzog was believed to be the suspect years later but there was never any proof. After Jaycee Dugard, a girl who disappeared in 1991 was found alive in 2009 there has been more interest in the case.
While Loren Herzog surely killed many other people* this past December they charged David Emery Misch with the murder of Michaela Garecht.

https://medium.com/murder-by-design/serial-killer-charged-in-michaela-garecht-case-c76b15b23dd9

* Although we'll likely never know how many because he hung himself while on parole in 2012. He was living in a trailer on prison grounds because nowhere was willing to accept him, much like Lawrence Singleton, and his partner in crime Wesley Shermantine was about to spill the beans to a bounty hunter named Leonard Padilla. Shermantine was pissed off and had nothing to lose because he was still on death row and Herzog was out, after his murder charges were overturned via appeal.
 
Back