Lolcow Derek Smart

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
i kinda misread the title as Derek Stiles.
Derekstiles.jpg


???????????????
?

anyways, so what you're all saying is this guy is basically Phil Fish before Phil Fish was Fishing it up to his Fishiest?

He's sort of a crossbreed between Phil Fish, Jay Geis, and TJChurch. He's released games that were ridiculously ambitious, but, rather like Peter Molyneux, you can't really take any of his claims seriously because he can't manage worth shit and habitually allows what he'd like to run well afoul of reality, and then, when this happens, he takes to the internet, where he gets in marathon flamewars, several of which persist to this day. His is one of the most massive egos in vidya gaeming, and even though it's been like 15 years since Battlecruiser 3000AD, Smart still somehow sticks around. His recently early access for $99 tells you pretty much everything.
 
He's sort of a crossbreed between Phil Fish, Jay Geis, and TJChurch. He's released games that were ridiculously ambitious, but, rather like Peter Molyneux, you can't really take any of his claims seriously because he can't manage worth shit and habitually allows what he'd like to run well afoul of reality, and then, when this happens, he takes to the internet, where he gets in marathon flamewars, several of which persist to this day. His is one of the most massive egos in vidya gaeming, and even though it's been like 15 years since Battlecruiser 3000AD, Smart still somehow sticks around. His recently early access for $99 tells you pretty much everything.

Somebody should take Battlecruiser 3000AD and mod the shit out of it - if that's even possible - to prove it can be done.
 
Somebody should take Battlecruiser 3000AD and mod the shit out of it - if that's even possible - to prove it can be done.
They tried.

They failed. The architecture is too old - and too shit. Like a friend of mine said about Big Rigs: Over the Road Racing:

No amount of modding will fix a game with problems this huge.

If you're not familiar with Battlecruiser 3000AD and have never played it, I scarcely know how to describe it to you. Ignore that it looked like the SNES Wing Commander game - the game was literally unplayable at launch. Literally every feature that Smart had promised either flat-out wasn't delivered on, or was delivered in a slipshod, essentially threadbare state at best. The game crashed constantly, and the manual was zero help whatsoever with either the interface or game itself. You couldn't even progress past the second mission in the campaign until the 2.0 patch, which came out close to a year later, and even that gave it only basic functionality.

Impossibly, the engine, which is now about 25 years old, runs like absolute shit even on computers with about thirty thousand times the resources needed to play the game. This is because the game's architecture is so bad at multithreading that the game actually plays worse on a better machine. The most modern versions of the game were made for a single-core PC. In 2012.

Battlecruiser 3000AD was one of those games - the ones where PCs that were just coming out could barely fucking handle thing under ideal circumstances, and even then odds are good that something would catastrophically fuck up and then catch fire, like Wing Commander Privateer 2: The Darkening. It's fared better on re-releases, but only barely. It looks - and plays - like a game that got locked inside this temporal stasis capsule and defies any attempt to play it normally. You can download any of Smart's games for free from his site, but be forewarned - Battlecruiser 3000AD is too broken to fix.

In this game lies a tragedy - a testament to a broken dream, and of ambition unfulfilled. It had such an enormous, promise-filled premise that one couldn't help but feel the wonder when it was first proposed, but that turned out to be a textbook tragic dream. Smart himself mismanaged the project spectacularly.

Smart himself is a brilliant guy, but his ego is what ultimately has led to him becoming one of the longest running jokes on Usenet. During his flame wars, Smart has religiously claimed to possess a doctorate and frequently titles himself as Ph.D. The problem: His thesis is not listed anywhere, and he has not divulged even basic details about his doctorate, such as which college he attended or who was his supervisor, leading the bulk of the internet to assume, perhaps rightly, that it's as phony a claim as Vade's new headmate.
 
In this game lies a tragedy - a testament to a broken dream, and of ambition unfulfilled. It had such an enormous, promise-filled premise that one couldn't help but feel the wonder when it was first proposed, but that turned out to be a textbook tragic dream. Smart himself mismanaged the project spectacularly.

That description fits, to the letter, David Allen's Horizons and Alganon. Maybe that's why Smart took over Alganon.
 
  • Agree
Reactions: mrdk_04 and Jaimas
anyways, so what you're all saying is this guy is basically Phil Fish before Phil Fish was Fishing it up to his Fishiest?
Pff, I've said it before, of the folks mentioned by the OP, Phil Fish doesn't really count as a lolcow and neither does Brianna Wu. Sure, they did several pretty odd things and caused completely pointless drama, but NEITHER can hold candle to Derek Smart as far as really bloody hilarious drama shit is concerned. The dude got decades worth of shit done, and all of it is utter weirdness.
 
Pff, I've said it before, of the folks mentioned by the OP, Phil Fish doesn't really count as a lolcow and neither does Brianna Wu. Sure, they did several pretty odd things and caused completely pointless drama, but NEITHER can hold candle to Derek Smart as far as really bloody hilarious drama shit is concerned. The dude got decades worth of shit done, and all of it is utter weirdness.
And for all Fish's bizarre turns, Fez shipped not just as a playable, original game, but a great one. Even after all the years of havoc Derek Smart wreaked on Usenet and Coke machines, none of the games he's made have come close to any of those.
 
Back