Did anyone see the videos that were pre-made assuming Wish would be a success? Aged like milk lol.
I don't understand why Disney would trust the music of their 100th anniversary celebration princess flick in the hands of a popstar ghostwriter and some sound engineer who worked with Lady Gaga. Criticize Lin-Manuel Miranda all you want, but there's no denying that he knows how musicals work. All the faults of Julia Michaels songwriting are seen in the Selena Gomez song "Bad Liar", which she co-wrote. Like the forced/arrhythmic verses and repetition.
One of my many problems with Wish is that Rosas lacks cultural character. They should've just set the story in New York City instead of making it some island in the Mediterranean sea that the king (and villain) made to be a safespace for people from all over the world live in.
Every other Disney princess flick attempts to honour some real world culture(s), even if they're mostly set in fictional lands. Belle is French, Merida is Scottish, Jasmine is Arab, Mulan is Chinese, Moana is Polynesian, Tiana is from the Southern U.S, Frozen is Scandinavian-inspired, etc. Even other princesses like Snow White, Aurora and Rapunzel, while not having a clear setting (AFAIK), are obviously Europeans and were inspired by European fairy tales. And this is why some people can feel "representation" with the princesses.
But WTF is Asha supposed to be? She isn't Southern European or any Mediterranean ethnicity. Her fictional island is basically New York City and her friends are all colours of the rainbow (one's Yellow, another is Brown, another is black, etc). If she's supposed to be "Brown" or broadly "POC", then there's a ton of princesses that actually focus on real world Brown cultures/people (i.e - Moana, Raya, Jasmine, etc).
I feel like Wish is the zenith of Disney's attempts to be inclusive and inoffensive, while ultimately appealing to no one. In the past, they got some shit for Jasmine supposedly being Arab, but her palace (inspired by India's Taj Mahal) tells a different story. The film was supposed to be set in Baghdad, but the Gulf War made the creators change the name to Agrabah. IIRC, Mulan also got criticism by actual Chinese audiences for looking pan-East Asian or Japanesey. Princess and the Frog, despite all the media hype for being the first "African American princess", didn't have an African prince. Naveen has an Indian name and comes from a fictional kingdom, Maledonia; that name possibly combines two real life countries (Maldives and North Macedonia).
Frozen tried to cram every Scandinavian culture and then the sequel introduced a Sami-inspired people because audiences didn't know that Anna's boyfriend was Sami. Moana saw some criticism for trying to be pan-Polynesian, instead of picking one of the many diverse Polynesian/Pacific Islander cultures. Even Raya and the Last Dragon was being hyped up for it's "representation" of pan-Southeast Asian cultures, yet ironically, many of the film's talent were East Asian descent. The film failed to reach audiences in China and Japan btw, because (shocker), East Asians don't look at a Vietcong or other dark-skins and see "representation".