Why does Rockstar keep going back to the same well? Vice City was almost entirely a homage to the show Miami Vice and was heavily defined by it's 80s setting,
You never played the original game. LS,LC & VC are basically the entire GTA universe. Outside of their London DLC/Expansion GTA has always been about the US. I love VC (2002), but there is no law that says it's 80's or nothing. Granted, I wish R* would stop leaning so hard into the 80s vibe in this game if it's neither set in the 80s nor has the population/tone/atmosphere of the fictional 80s vision of Miami.
Why not somewhere based on like, Dublin? Shanghai? Mexico City?
The Housers were fascinated by US pop culture, not Mexican, Chinese or Irish culture.
They might all be mostly gone, but that sentiment will remain. America still exports it's culture and the world follows (as pozzed and gay as that culture may now be).
There's an empty market for any dev team/publishing house to fill the void, but no one seems to want to do it.
I believe there's money to be made in a satirized Tijuana or Monterrey that showcases and parodies the state of Mexico/Southern Border culture, social climate and history.
Seeing Narcos, DEA Agents, Bleeding heart west coasters, all mixed in and mocked would be dimes, but current year wouldn't allow it because showcasing beaners as criminals or shedding some light into the brutal underworld of cartels is something the media, NGOs, and "concerned citizens" don't want anyone to see.
A game where you can take up the role of a young man unwillingly plunged into becoming a sicario after a life of poverty and hunger, committing crimes like human trafficking and drug distribution; working for people like corrupt DEA agents and Chapo-parodies... no major publisher is going to fund that today.
Best to play it safe and continue mocking America.