- Joined
- Dec 25, 2017
She is not a bad writer. Many consider Prisoner of Azkaban the best of the series precisely because it had a good plot involving a mystery and good characters. It's definitely the favorite book of many because it's the best she has written in the series.Is JK actually a good writer? The 7th book is rushed and full of contrivances so she could actually end it in 7. Her play, that she has a writing credit on, is widely regarded as a bad continuation of the story and the script she wrote for FB 2 is poorly structured as to not have a second act at all.
Maybe she just got lucky with a magical mystery series for kids that grew beyond her ability. People should let her be.
The problem with book 7 is, to try to explain it simply, that a person buys a suitcase thinking on the few belongings they have to take on a trip. The trip gets delayed and you keep buying more and more things. By the time you finally are ready to leave, you have too much to put in the suitcase and it cannot be properly closed.
Rowling knew how the books would finish (or had a general idea) by the time she started to write. Book 2 to 6 have elements that were necessary, but it's mostly filler. You can tell by how much of it becomes so irrelevant by the end of the books and only characters that are some how prominent in the first book show up to take a role.