Realistically, how many big bad gun-toting antifash troons are they gonna have actually show up to middle-of-nowhere Colorado to point guns at armed fascists in the middle of a pandemic? Not many. Either because it's too far, or because waaah covid, or because it's fun to larp as a tough man on the internet but the thought of actually getting shot is a bit scawwy.
So you just send the three people that showed up out for patrol with Bonnie, and oh look, the fascists only showed up on Penny's patrol, whoops, haha! Or you leave the newbies as the last line of defence for the valuable alpacas Kevin and co., and come back victorious at daybreak because you scared those nasty right wingers off with your big bad guns (which are such obvious overcompensation that Freud would have a field day). They may be retards, but they're semi-cunning retards upon occasion, and I'm pretty sure they could manage to spin it in a way believable to the rest of the eunuch brigade.