So here's the thing. If I, as a consumer, order without Honey, I don't get any discounts. With Honey, I would get a small discount. I can find discount codes and enter them myself, which might net me a bigger discount than Honey, but nothing's stopping me from just using Honey and adding my own discount codes, which gives me either both the small and the large discount, or just the large one. Honey is at worst no added benefit, and at best gives me a small discount for zero effort.
Further adding to Honey's value is that affiliate link cashback thing that was mentioned earlier in this thread. Purchases made with Honey and PayPal net me a percent back or whatever, out of the money Honey earns by hijacking affiliate links. If I were to buy with Linus' affiliate link, I wouldn't get any cashback whatsoever.
Honey is objectively good for consumers. I can see why shills like Linus and GamerNexus might loathe it for what it does, but from my perspective Honey is doing no harm, and actually provides a small value to me (which is all they ever claimed to do in the first place).
Besides, I consider it a moral good to not let influencers get affiliate link money. That money comes out of product advertising budget, which comes out of the price I pay for the product. I'd rather get a percent of what I pay extra back, than have that percent go into a shill's pockets.