Crime Overweight people are publicly weighed and ordered to slim down under new rules in Turkey - with inspectors patrolling public spaces

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Source / Archive

Overweight people are publicly weighed and ordered to slim down under new rules in Turkey - with inspectors patrolling public spaces
By ELENA SALVONI
Published: 20:15 EDT, 21 May 2025 | Updated: 20:33 EDT, 21 May 2025


Turkey has rolled out a nationwide scheme to stop and weigh people in public, with inspectors then telling them to slim down if they are found to be overweight.

Health workers have been deployed across each of the country's 81 regions with weighing scales and tape measures as the drive to assess 10 million people by July 10 is underway.

Passersby are stopped by medical examiners for spot body mass index (BMI) checks while walking through town squares, shopping centres and parks, and even as they prepare to board buses or head to football matches, according to reports.

Speaking at a nursing conference last week, Turkey's Minister of Health Kemal Memişoğlu declared that '50 percent of our society is overweight.'
He pointed to the various health risks associated with being overweight, telling the meeting: 'Being overweight means being sick, it means we will get sick in the future.

'Our young children are overweight, their body resistance is high and that's why they don't get sick, but when they start getting older, that weight will turn into joint and heart diseases.'

But Memişoğlu was not spared the scales in Ankara last week - and was told by health officials that he was among the large proportion of the population counted as 'above normal weight'.

'Which dietitian should I go to?' he reportedly said afterwards, before adding in a follow-up post on Thursday: 'Turns out I'm a little over. It's up to me now, I'll be walking every day.'

1748077721521.webp1748077749939.webp1748077774122.webp1748077806556.webp1748077834757.webp1748077861691.webp

Another person who was checked by the inspectors, psychiatrist and academic Gökben Hızlı Sayar, wrote on X: 'I got caught in a fat checkpoint in Üsküdar Square. Luckily, they scolded me a little and let me go.

'Like drivers warning of speed traps, I tipped off three other chubby people heading that way. Solidarity, my fellow fat comrades!'

Memişoğlu responded to people joking about the scheme on social media: 'Dear young people, I read what you write on social media. You are very entertaining, but the issue of being overweight is serious.'

Pictures from around Turkey have shown people being guided onto weighing scales and having their height measured before their weight is calculated.

The anti-obesity campaign, which is described by officials as a 'national fight' and is running under the tag line 'know your weight, live healthy,' began on May 10 and plans to survey one in eight Turks.

People with a BMI over 25 are referred to state-run Family Health centres and Healthy Life centres, where they can receive free nutritional counseling and follow-up services.

Turks have hit out at the measures, which many have argued point to the government being out of touch with the daily realities of soaring food prices and wage stagnation, and the impact this can have on healthy eating.

1748077908108.webp1748077928892.webp

The Erdogan government has also been criticised for the very public nature of the scheme, with Turks questioning why people need to be weighed in public.

Meanwhile an article in Turkish daily newspaper Evrensel pointed out that the scheme was rolled out in the same week that a new generation weight loss injection was launched in Turkey - something it labelled 'a 'strange' coincidence'.

The World Health Organisation (WHO) estimated in 2023 that some 30 per cent of Turkish people are obese.

Health experts warned earlier this year that a BMI score is not 'nuanced' enough to measure obesity, with more assessments needed before someone is told they are obese.

The new Lancet Commission of more than 50 experts from around the world argued that doctors should only diagnose patients as clinically obese if they have illnesses directly caused by obesity alone, such as type 2 diabetes.

1748078044961.webp1748078063095.webp

BMI first gained popularity in the 1970s as a way of judging body fat. A healthy BMI is typically measured between 18.5 and 25.

Anything under 18.5 is considered underweight. BMIs between 25 and 29.9 fall into overweight territory, and above 30 is considered obese.

It is useful for tracking population trends in body weight, but has well-known limitations when applied to individuals, Dr Arya Sharma, an obesity researcher at the University of Alberta in Canada, told Live Science.

For example, many professional athletes qualify as overweight or obese based on solely their BMI. But they have much more muscle mass, which weighs proportionally more than fat.
 
Well yeah, it's just a formula, weight in kg divided by height in meters squared, it's not really supposed to be "nuanced." Brian Shaw did a DEXA scan video a few years ago, weighed in at 413lbs at 6'8 (a BMI of 45.4) and the scan came back at 17.9%. A normal dude would have a BMI of like 23 or so at that bodyfat.

That said, outliers to that extreme are rare, and a scale costs like $20 while an xray machine costs like $50,000, so I think we'll be using BMI for a while despite fatties protest that it's inaccurate. Even though for sedentery fatties it's probably inaccurate in the other direction.
That particular line of kvetching always pisses me off. Yes, BMI ain't perfect. What it is, however, is completely doable with items you have at home.

You don't have to aim for the perfect BMI - but you should be mindful of it and keep it in mind. If you're obese by the BMI scale and you're not a bodybuilder, you should absolutely take a moment to consider if you are at an unhealthy weight.
 
Nigga, BMI is rejected as junk science by pretty much every serious medical organization. There’s literally no reason to use it when we have way more accurate methods.
It’s not bad as a rough and ready general screen which is what it should be used as. If you’re very short, or very tall or have a lot of muscle it can be a bit off but you just combine it with actually looking at people and then you can tell if you’ve got some stacked rugby player, or even someone low weight but with a beer gut. It’s a sensible general population measure.
I don’t agree with stopping people in public, I’m pretty petite but I’d be telling them to fuck right off.
A better way is how the Japanese do it. You get weighed at work as part of your physical and of you’re overweight you’re given advice to lose it. We also have to get GPs back to talking about people’s weight because they just don’t any more. Weigh and measure every time you go to docs or once a quarter or something
 
It's mostly a non-white/low IQ problem.

Not saying there's no fatso whities but in general.
In the US, it's mostly spics and negros who are obese.
Many European countries have less obesity (per capita and overal) than many middle eastern, south american and even african countries.
Japan has some of the lowest obesity in the whole world.
I have to stop you there. A lot of red states have large white populations and BMI's that are pretty big as one poster on another forum said, ham planet levels. It is not mostly niggers and beaners that are obese. Niggers only make up 14% of the US population. Obesity is an economic issue. The issues causing it will never be addressed because rich people wouldn't like it. In the US rich people get what they want.
Kinda based but ultimately useless if you don’t teach people how to lose weight. Most people are completely oblivious to even basic concepts like calorie counting. Nutrition should be taught in school.

This is even worse in poor countries where even the experts may be decades behind the rest of the world in terms of knowledge about fitness and nutrition and are most likely still believing in outdated ideas.

BMI itself is pretty much junk science. It would be better to take body measurements, but that would take a lot more work.
BMI is stupid shit Obammy brough into the mainstream. Till then no one even knew what it was at least in the general public. It's based on your height and weight. Weight is weight and doesn't matter what it is or how tall you are. It really needs to just go away.
 
Violating everyone's civil rights is probably actually worth it if you can get the modern lifestyle fat problem under control. Obviously the "do nothing about it" approach doesn't work, look at the US.
School lunches became worse than they already were last time we tried doing anything about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Clotso Coof
A lot of red states have large white populations and BMI's that are pretty big as one poster on another forum said
Exceptions exist but the numbers speak for themself
1748165427581.webp

Don't get me wrong, lots of white americans are fatsos too. Though those same red states tend to have higher amounts of blacks aswel, actually
But especially internationally, it's 100% a low IQ (therefore non-white non-asian) issue.
 
Back