Culture Pixar’s ‘Win or Lose’ features Disney’s first openly Christian character in nearly two decades - Sorry for all the tranny shit, here’s a token PoC (Parishioner of Christ)

L/A
IMG_2641.webp
Pixar’s “Win or Lose” features Disney’s first openly Christian character in nearly two decades after removing a transgender character. Pixar Animation Studios

Win or Lose,” Pixar’s first original series not based on an existing intellectual property, has something not seen in the Disney universe in nearly two decades: a distinctively Christian character.

In fact, the series about a championship youth softball tournament begins with a prayer. The first of the eight episodes opens with Laurie, a young girl struggling with self-confidence, alone on the bench, her hands clasped in prayer.

“Dear Heavenly Father, please give me strength,” Laurie says. “I have faith, but sometimes the doubt creeps in. … I just want to catch a ball or get a hit — for my team, of course.”

That simple prayer is the first Christian reference in a Disney film since the “Bridge to Terabithia” (2007), a live-action film which featured two children attending church together and discussing religion on their trip home, according to WDW News Today, a website dedicated to reporting news about Disney’s theme parks.

Disney is the parent company of Pixar, which is based in Emeryville.
The inclusion of a Christian character stands in contrast to Pixar’s decision to redact a transgender storyline from “Win or Lose” during the series’ production, a move revealed by the Hollywood Reporter in December.

“When it comes to animated content for a younger audience, we recognize that many parents would prefer to discuss certain subjects with their children on their own terms and timeline,” Disney said in a statement about the edited storyline.

“Win or Lose,” written and directed by Pixar veterans Carrie Hobson and Michael Yates, explores the challenges and bursting emotions of children and adults navigating this most complex world. Each of the eight episodes focuses on a different character, with every episode culminating in the championship game.

Although “Win or Lose” was completed before Donald Trump became president for the second time, Hobson commented on the pressures many creatives feel during these culturally divisive times.
“My mission is just the same as it has always been, which is just try to speak authentically,” Hobson said. “To me, stories spark conversation. That’s the power of storytelling.”

“Win or Lose” debuted on Disney+ on Feb. 19. Episodes 5 and 6 drop on Wednesday, March 5, followed by the release of its final episodes 7 and 8 on March 12.

Reach G. Allen Johnson: ajohnson@sfchronicle.com
 
This is a whiplash of a news for me. I don't even know how to take this yet.

But knowing how Disney is, I wouldn't be too keen to see a good representation.
I expect the Christian to be the outcast and the troon to be the noob in the end of the season cliffhanger.
 
  • Like
Reactions: CloverKitty
Disney's commitment to selling products based on identity politics instead of storytelling is ironclad and immune to any possible pendulum swings. They will ride the pendulum whichever way it goes.
 
  • Like
Reactions: frozen_runner
X to doubt. They're deep in DIE and this is just a smokescreen. Disney holds alot of IPs and companies who'll happily push the Commie poison while the legit stuff fronts.

until they have a hero that shouts tnd while shit stomping tiny hats i wont care.
Hilariously, Disney has alot of old cartoons made by Walt himself that features Uncle A himself being shown in a positive light. Just like Song of the South, current year Disney wants people to forget about it.
 
I expect the Christian to be the outcast and the troon to be the noob in the end of the season cliffhanger.
The (ex)troon episode isn't out yet but you are kinda right. Kai, the one that supposed to be trans, is a star player and Laurie, the Christian, is the weakest member of the team that might only be in the team because her dad is the coach. Neither is a social outcast but one is clearly more popular than the other.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: pot of sneed
Why do people need to know a character is transgender or Christian in the first place? Unless it's actually a significant part of the story and not just shoehorned in.

Remember when Andy in toy story took our a Quran and began praying in his bedroom? I remember in The Iron Giant when the kid teaches the robot about Judaism, was a great part to a wholesome story - btw did anyone know that WALL-E was a buddhist?
 
  • Agree
Reactions: chalkyresidue
Why do people need to know a character is transgender or Christian in the first place? Unless it's actually a significant part of the story and not just shoehorned in.
No shit. I grew up watching catdog. I have no idea what religion, what pronouns, or what sexual preference the catdog had. I just know it was half cat, half dog and that's all we needed to know
 
At probably his lowest point, he asks his dad if he thinks she will go to hell, and his dad reassures his sobbing child that god has mercy and wouldn't damn an innocent little girl who was basically sunshine personified.
For Christians who hope in the doctrine of invincible ignorance (e.g. Catholics) it’s not that bad. I have heard that some protestants can be quite dogmatic about asserting “unbaptised = hell, no exceptions” but idk.
 
I have heard that some protestants can be quite dogmatic about asserting “unbaptised = hell, no exceptions” but idk.

Hell no. That's been much more of a Catholic and Catholic-adjacent (liturgical denoms) thing. And maybe Mormon, I've heard the stories about them non-consensually baptizing the dead just incase.
 
Remember when Andy in toy story took our a Quran and began praying in his bedroom? I remember in The Iron Giant when the kid teaches the robot about Judaism, was a great part to a wholesome story
But there was the scene with the deer where he teaches the robot it has an immortal soul. And he and his mom say grace at dinner. Is saying grace really that different than having a kid pray before a little league game? Children's media often reflects how real kids navigate and try to understand the world, and religion can be a part of their character or behavior without being the main focus of the plot.

For Christians who hope in the doctrine of invincible ignorance (e.g. Catholics) it’s not that bad. I have heard that some protestants can be quite dogmatic about asserting “unbaptised = hell, no exceptions” but idk.
I think the more relevant point though is the movie isn't presenting doctrine, it's presenting humanity. It isn't trying to instruct or present some hard truth when it comes to the afterlife. It's not a religious authority saying those things, it's a little kid casually giving her opinion (and another kid disagrees) and an ordinary man shaken by the death of a child and trying to comfort his own. The characters are presented as real, flawed people who are struggling when they're faced with a horrific tragedy. Their feelings of fear, uncertainty, hope are realistic and the point of a story that's trying to help children understand loss and grief. The movie isn't proving wrong anyone who believes the little girl is damned to eternal hellfire, the main character is so devastated because he believes it's a real possibility. It's just portraying that there are also people who don't believe that, and there are people who question their faith when it's suddenly no longer an abstract concept but someone they care about. I'm sure even the most dogmatic people are aware of that reality.
 
Back