Yes, Colosseum and XD Gale of Darkness were great, no arguments there, although, the Character design for the second Protagonist was off ... Like no joke:
View attachment 1005621
Dear god, what is wrong with your face?!
Wes was a breath of fresh air for a protagonist
View attachment 1005622 Also, his manga version was kick ass:
View attachment 1005623
Like, I would totally pay top dollar for a full on pokemon game where you played as a character like Wes.
But, back onto point, Yes, those games did prove that 3d pokemon games can work, yes, those games should be handled by the people who made them (Genius Sorority) - But I would like to point out that Genius Sorority has shares owned by both Nintendo and the PKM company.
From what I understand from research, Genius Sorority has been working on their own projects like Denpa Men. They were also responsible for the mediocre Dragon Quest Swords for the Wii.
Granted, I don't know what they're doing now, but you would think that Nintendo and Gamefreak would work in tandem with this company. Especially considering that a lot of the workers from Genius Sorority were from companies that worked on the Dragon Quest series.