[Spoilers for the whole series excluding the Layton Crossover follow]
[This is bound to somewhat controversial; please be civil in the comments and remember that just because someone disagrees with your subjective interpretation of a fictional story doesn't mean they are "evil"]
The character writing in ace attorney is undoubtedly one of the biggest strengths of the series as a whole, however there are still a few… questionable tropes that plague the games. What do you think about them? More specifically:
- What do you think is the most egregious example of a problematic character trope used in ace attorney?
- Is there any such trope that you think people don't talk about enough?
- Conversely, is there any trope which people often complain about but you don't find it to be problematic?
For reference, here's a list of all such character tropes (I'm being rather generous with the term "character tropes" tbh) used in ace attorney grouped by game. Note that just because I've included a trope here doesn't mean I necessarily believe it is problematic, it just means that I can see an argument for it being so, regardless of whether I agree or not. Also, while I've tried to make the list exhaustive, I'm sure I've missed a few of them.
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney
- April May: Femme fatale, kind of.
- Sal Manella: "funny" pervert/creep. Pedophile, considering that Maya is 17.
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Justice for All
- "Director Hotti", or rather, the guy posing as him: "funny" pervert/creep, again.
- Franziska von Karma: assaulting people to unconsciousness as a funny gag
- Max Galactica, Sean Dingling (Bat): pedophiles
- Benjamin Woodman: Depending on how you interpret his character, he's either a pedophile or a harmful stereotype of neurodivergent people. Or both.
- Shelly de Killer: "cool" honourable serial killer
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Trials and Tribulations
- Dahlia Hawthorne: Very stereotypical femme fatale
- Jean Armstrong: Harmful stereotype of a gay man, or a trans woman, or both.
- Victor Kudo: "funny" old pervert/creep
- Terry Fawles: Similar to Benjamin Woodman in a way, but not quite.
- Diego Armando (Godot): heroic toxic masculinity. Whether he's supposed to be a criticism of such toxic masculinity or a glorification of it depends on how you interpret him.
- Franziska von Karma: same as before
Apollo Justice: Ace Attorney
- The Kitakis: "wholesome" neighbourhood gangsters
- Wesley Stickler: …a bit of an anomaly. Is "does creepy stuff for non creepy but ridiculous reasons" a trope? Does it count as problematic?
- "Director Hickfield", or rather, the guy posing as him: same as before, but this time with pedophilia.
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Dual Destinies
- Robin Newman: a poorly aged portrayal of gender. There's a few moments where characters pretty much say "there is no way Robin Newman is a woman, he is so manly!", which is eventually dismissed because she is just putting on an act and is actually secretly stereotypically feminine, reinforcing the binary stereotypes of gender.
- Norma de Plume: has random "haha, this fat person is so ugly" type of jokes for no reason.
Phoenix Wright: Ace Attorney - Spirit of Justice
- Geiru Toneido: femme fatale, kind of.
- Uendo Toneido: His DID is treated like a "quirky" characteristic, where he can miraculously switch alters on command for his Rakugo act. Still, this does subvert the "evil hidden personality" trope, so there's that.
- Armie Buff: she has a "she can finally stand on her own feet again" scene which is questionable for similar reasons as the miracle cure trope, though it's not quite the same.
Ace Attorney Investigations: Miles Edgeworth
- Franziska von Karma: same as before
I can think of no original character from this game who fits here, surprisingly. Maybe I'm forgetting some.
Ace Attorney Investigations 2: Prosecutor's Gambit
- Shelly de Killer: "cool" honourable serial killer, this time with extra badassery.
- Franziska von Karma: again, same as before.
- Bodhidharma Kanis: yet another "cool" assassin, who arbitrarily decided to save someone's life once. There's a literal "epic showdown" scene between him and Shelly de Killer.
- Florence Niedler, Hilda Hertz: "haha, abusing old people is funny"
The Great Ace Attorney: Adventures
- Jezaille Brett/Asa Shinn: femme fatale
- Joan Garrideb, John Garrideb, Juror 5 in TGAA1-4: "haha domestic abuse is funny"
The Great Ace Attorney: Resolve
- Barok van Zieks: "understandably" racist guy.
That's all.