- Joined
- Dec 6, 2020
If I remember rightly Atwood was inspired to write it after seeing what was going on in Iran and how feminists in the West were doing nothing to fight it while complaining about people like Mary Whitehouse and Pat Robertson and viewing them as the biggest threats to liberalism.I don't remember who said it, but I recall someone saying that if you changed the religion that The Handmaid's Tale criticizes, you effectively change its genre. When the story places Christianity as its target, The Handmaid's Tale is fiction; when when you change its focus to Islam, The Handmaid's Tale transforms into a documentary.
The point of the book is not ”this is what Christians will do if they ever gain any power, so you have to make sure any Nativity plays in school are accompanied by a guy in a black robe ominously chanting ’Hail Satan, hail Baphomet’ for three hours because muh separation of Church and state”, the point of the book is ”if you find the thought of a state religion being enforced by forced conversions and women being forced to wear a veil abhorrent, then do something about that happening in Iran and Saudi Arabia instead of whining about how banning degeneracy will lead to women becoming baby-making machines”.
It's also important to note that in both the book and the film, Catholics were persecuted by the Sons of Jacob and their regime (for instance, nuns were given a choice between apostasising and becoming sex slaves or being sent to death camps, Catholic priests were hanged on the wall in Boston, and Cardinal Newman's books were burnt) making Bob's insistence that the Catholic Church wants to bring about a world like The Handmaid's Tale doubly stupid.