RWBY - The Hindenburg on which Rooster Teeth rests its hopes, dreams and future

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
How are they even doing these? Who is paying them? Shouldn’t they all be busy submitting their job applications for McDonald’s?

They failed. It’s over. Time for a reboot (Preferably In 2 years or so).
They had found the funds for it when they initially announced it, about a month or so before RT imploded, so I assume they are just using said funds
 
Yeah, these things were probably already in the works for a while. Cutting them now would be a bigger loss than just letting them be uploaded and finished.

Still no announcement on the IP being sold? Wonder if WB is just going to sit on it forever.
 
I think you could very easily retool what's there into something that works. It really isn't that hard. RWBY's premise and central conflict is perfectly functional, even a solid idea. The monsters and the huntsmen are proxies in an age-old shadow war between two immortal but diametrically opposed beings. That could very easily be made into a compelling conflict if handled, not even differently, but consistently.

Retooling what already exists is fine. I think ripping everything out by the roots and turning it into a completely different idea is not a good idea because the core is what makes RWBY interesting to begin with.
The whole "shadow war between two immortals" thing isn't the core of RWBY. That shit didn't come till later, and almost certainly wasn't planned from the beginning. The core of RWBY is "Cute girls doing cute things fighting monsters", which can be done, and has been done, a hundred thousand different ways than RWBY has done it, and much better at that.

All you really need for any reboot/retool is Team RWBY, fighting...anything really. It doesn't even have to be Grimm. If it is Grimm they are fighting, the Grimm can be retooled and rewritten any number of ways, such as removing the whole "attracted to negative emotions" part. The story could be set in a school setting, like the original and every anime set in a high school ever, or you could forego the school setting entirely. Everything outside the core "four girls fight some kind of monsters" bit is malleable.
 
and almost certainly wasn't planned from the beginning
Eh, maybe not in the form we got it, but Salem and Ozpin doing illuminati shit was almost certainly a very early idea.
The core of RWBY is "Cute girls doing cute things fighting monsters",
That's certainly the core appeal. I meant that the central plot of the current show is fine and that if you were to reboot it, turning it into a completely unrelated IP with entirely different concepts/core plot elements is not a good idea.

You could very easily retool the broad strokes of what is there now and make a fine show. Which is why I am flabbergasted most people fuck it up.
 
I don't understand why there are unironic RWBY fans on this website that should know better.
The core of RWBY is "Cute girls fighting monsters"
That initial premise got shunted hard into the background as early as the second season and only got worse as it went. They also gave Ruby a power that immediately defeats monsters because that's how little they cared. In practice RWBY's always cared more about inventing human OCs and having them fight each other. You should be ashamed for thinking this description was accurate.
 
Last edited:
I don't understand why there are unironic RWBY fans on this website that should know better.
To be fair this show did have potential to become something great. People are in love for what it could have been. Not what it ended up being.

Execept RT fanboys. They are still in denial, and think the latest filler season was a masterpiece of philosophy, mythology and psychology instead of the pandering waste of time it really was. Those people have no hope.

I don’t think the majority here unironically likes what RWBY is. I see people more in love with what it could be or what it could have been. I don’t think anyone loves everything RT did without any objections.
 
Eh, maybe not in the form we got it, but Salem and Ozpin doing illuminati shit was almost certainly a very early idea.
There’s really no proof of that. Before Volume 5, the only role Salem played was being the narrator voice in the first episode.
I don't understand why there are unironic RWBY fans on this website that should know better.
“Noooooooo, Stalker! You are on Kiwi Farms!!!!! You aren’t allowed to like things here! Enjoy prison!”
 
There’s really no proof of that. Before Volume 5, the only role Salem played was being the narrator voice in the first episode.
Salem and Ozpin's narration in seasons 1-3 is a conversation, episode 1's opening narration ends with Ozpin addressing Salem. It's not super well written, but the opening narrator was always going to be some kind of big bad and Ozpin was always opposing her behind the scenes.
The core of RWBY is "Cute girls doing cute things fighting monsters"
If that was the core, there'd be a lot more fights against monsters. RWBY was about Monty playing with his cool OCs. That's why the first 2 seasons meander so much and it's why no one can nail down what the show was actually about.
 
If that was the core, there'd be a lot more fights against monsters. RWBY was about Monty playing with his cool OCs.
And that was the selling point: Monty having his OCs instead of action figures of existing characters.



That's why the first 2 seasons meander so much and it's why no one can nail down what the show was actually about.

I think the show made it clear it was about Ruby and her friends going to school to learn how to fight Grimm.

If memory serves, a lot of the promos mentioned the school aspect, like “It’s time to learn how to fight Grimm, and Ruby, Weiss Blake, and Yang are ready for their first day of class.” Or talking about how Ruby always dreamed of going to Beacon Academy.


Salem and Ozpin's narration in seasons 1-3 is a conversation, episode 1's opening narration ends with Ozpin addressing Salem. It's not super well written, but the opening narrator was always going to be some kind of big bad and Ozpin was always opposing her behind the scenes.
And if you ask me, V5 fucked that up super hard and super badly.
 
Last edited:
And if you ask me, V5 fucked that up super hard and super badly.
It could have been done well if the show had focused on episodic content with a larger background arc of the forever war between Salem and Ozpin, but they let their scope get too big and ended up trying to turn it into a fully serialized world spanning epic. Keep the setting to Beacon or maybe some of the surrounding country of Vale and Patch and make it so that all the major conflict revolves around there. There's absolutely nothing wrong with making this into a typical magical girl show, especially since you already have three groups of baddies each split into three to four tiers of threat level so you can have your episodes where they're just fighting jobbers and then episodes where the more serious threats appear for mid-season multiparters or season finales. And then you've got your Ace who is Salem, and she's the final Big Bad for your series finale where she's such a huge threat that like, everyone has to band together to beat her, so you've got your heroes and fan favorite villains banding together to save the world.
 
Back
Top Bottom