Civ6 was at its most intresting with the illuminati zombie apocalypse vampire society dlcs all installed for this reason.
The New Frontier Pass season DLC overall was very well received, but I'd argue that the fantasy themed game modes weren't well liked at all.
The Zombie mode was really half-baked. I recall Potato McWhiskey and the Yogscast shitting on it after release.
The defensive improvements like fences and traps were useless because A) they robbed your tiles of yields and B) zombies randomly spawn behind your defenses anyway, making a "last stand" defensive setup moot.
Zombies ignored civilian units like Builders and Settlers (but were obsessed with Traders, making land Trade Routes untenable), so a hack was simply to make walls of Builders around anything important.
It also simply was tedious and not fun. There was no way to kill zombies without simply spawning more zombies, which negated pretty much all strategies the Mode introduced.
I don't know anyone that like Apocalypse mode beyond the memes about entire cities being randomly fragged by meteors in the end game.
The Secret Society modes were more popular, but were also really limited in choice, on rails and promoted more min/maxing. It also made an already overmatched AI even easier to snowball against for opponents who couldn't use the new systems.
The Heroes mode was probably the most egregious. It gave ridiculously overpowered fantasy units to the player where the devs never bothered to program the AI to use the Heroes unique abilities.
The thing about the civ games is it has a really dedicated fanbase of oldfags that will happily buy the new one and put thousands of hours in it because that's just what they like. I think Firaxis really shot themselves in the foot by trying to innovate too much as it completely alienated this oldfag fanbase, as they're just going to go back to playing the older games. Stumbled upon this Steam review and I feel like it says it
If you go into the YT comments of any streamer even the mildly critical of VII, you'll find dozens of these "
I've bought every Civ since Civ I..." boomer types declaring they are taking their ball and going home.
Seeing as the Pirate Republic existed for, like, a few years, shit choice.
I like Pirates and I'd unironically prefer to play as Pennsylvania as a civ than that shit.
I enjoyed AC IV: Black Flag BITD and researched some of the characters like Edward Teach, Sted Bonnett, Ann Bonnie, etc.
For even the most famous pirates, their story structure almost always goes
> normie has a change of fate turning to the dark side
> sail around for a year bumbling around doing buccaneer stuff
> die in battle/get hung just as things are getting good