Silent Hill

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
I would like a game where the protag is an ACTUAL veteran who relives the horrors of war in silent hill. Essentially a whole trip through PTSD. That’s assuming silent hill will ever be good again though.
Off all things, Death Stranding has some segments that feel like that. Uncharacteristically for the game, there's these segments you find yourself fighting squads of corpses in the trenches of WWI, a bombed out city in WWII, and the jungles of Vietnam.
It's not straight up what a SH would do with the concept, but it's creepy and atmospheric and disorienting enough that it feels like a start.
 
If they did make a Silent Hill game with a veteran as the main character it would probably fucking suck.
It would just boil down to
"White dude killed a little brown child in bakalakadurkastan and can't get over it."
Because the talentless retards in charge of these projects have a grand total of three ideas that they keep recycling.
 
If they did make a Silent Hill game with a veteran as the main character it would probably fucking suck.
It would just boil down to
"White dude killed a little brown child in bakalakadurkastan and can't get over it."
Because the talentless retards in charge of these projects have a grand total of three ideas that they keep recycling.
"White dude returns from war, sees hometown culturally enriched, wants to return to war"

If anything we need a protag who enjoys being in SH because it allows him to act out every desire they want.
 
I feel so... Strange after beating Silent Hill 2 for the first ever time. Very few games have left an impression on me and made me have to process feelings, let alone the kinds of feelings this game gave me.

Shed a few tears, but my good ending I got left me feeling at relative peace, but questioning my own self in relation to James. As I played I felt a mix of being lost, disgusted, confused, worried, and frustrated. I even got a few headaches in crampt, dark spaces where I could barely see with my flashlight. There are beautiful, strange moments in the game.

I understand James's decisions in his life and I view him as a good person ultimately. Some of us are complex people and others are too quick to paint in black and white, so to say.

All of the characters showcase how difficult it is to process fate, free will, change, survival, and a desire for love.
 
Oh yeah the ending made me cry so hard when I heard how miscasted, flat and botched the delivery (and everything really...) was in the demake.
Anyway...
SH2R.jpg
Yeah.
 
People are very sensitive about having not played the original.

If you say anywhere else that the remake was bungled (at least a couple weeks ago), you'll get a barrage of normies confused and angry to see a dissenting opinion. It could be as simple as, "I feel the remake didn't do the original justice" and they'll get so riled up. For one, they act like it's literally impossible to experience the original today. Two, they already think the original's inferior because it's old. They'd rather play something watered down, generic, and disrespectful, as long as it has zero learning curve.

They take simple instructions on how to play the enhanced edition as a threat to their intelligence because they're threatened by the prospect of downloading programs and tinkering with them. I hate niggercattle to death.
 
White dude killed a little brown child in bakalakadurkastan and can't get over it
Funny that you think they'd ever make a new game with a white guy as the lead that isn't a remake of something from the PS2.

But yes, it would be some generic, 'SH is my supernatural therapist I killed somebody and feel bad about it, here is a zombie in a gas mask OoOOOoH~!' type shit.
If you say anywhere else that the remake was bungled (at least a couple weeks ago), you'll get a barrage of normies confused and angry to see a dissenting opinion
They're like this about any remake. Zoomies and late-millenials are really insecure about not getting to experience gaming golden age and get really offended when you tell them their new remake slop is, at best, a disservice to the original and, at worst, makes it actively worse. FF7 Remake and Rebirth are the other two games that get this reaction. It's my favorite way to suss out who is a retard when talking about videogames.
 
They're like this about any remake. Zoomies and late-millenials are really insecure about not getting to experience gaming golden age and get really offended when you tell them their new remake slop is, at best, a disservice to the original and, at worst, makes it actively worse. FF7 Remake and Rebirth are the other two games that get this reaction. It's my favorite way to suss out who is a retard when talking about videogames.
You would think that the generation basically raised by technology would just go "fuck it, we can emulate the games ourselves". Kill 2 birds with one stone
 
You would think that the generation basically raised by technology would just go "fuck it, we can emulate the games ourselves". Kill 2 birds with one stone
Much like how baby boomers are technologically illiterate; the young ones, to their ability, can only experience it if it came pre-loaded as a phone application. Explaining to them how to handle zips, file systems, and torrent old entertainment would be too much for them, as they only knew the apps from their touchscreen bricks doing all the work. As per eDove:
They take simple instructions on how to play the enhanced edition as a threat to their intelligence because they're threatened by the prospect of downloading programs and tinkering with them.
 
You would think that the generation basically raised by technology would just go "fuck it, we can emulate the games ourselves". Kill 2 birds with one stone
SH2 had a very good PC port (which I proudly own and which ran pretty well when I replayed it on W7 a few years ago) so they don't even need to emulate anything.
Problem is, for most zoomers technical know-how starts and ends with using social media.
 
If anything we need a protag who enjoys being in SH because it allows him to act out every desire they want.
That's actually a really interesting idea, and ripe for a genre fakeout with the marketing. It'd be cool to see a character that's like... a less-pathetic version of Eddy. Because Eddy kindov enjoyed the violent release that being in Silent Hill gave him, but it was in response to high school bullying and more average stuff like that. I'd like to see a character that becomes aware of their descent into hell as it's happening, like a crazy fever dream - then it can end on a depressing note like the MC getting killed by the cops (who look like monsters) after they track him down to Silent Hill.

SH3 has this one little scene with extremely interesting (potential) connotations to it. It may be my favorite line in the series, and I don't believe that Vincent is totally joking either.
 
Some of you are being unnecessarily overprotective of the original when I haven't said anything bad about it. I hadn't experienced Silent Hill before the Remake of 2 and it was an opportunity to play it.

I wanted to play the remake first before exploring the original.

There are things I appreciate that the remake does differently with the serious, subtle tones, while there is some clear and better delivery (with occasionally surprising humour) when it comes to the original.

The remake isn't woke slop or done poorly enough to warrant such shit flinging, it deserves a chance. Both versions are great.
 
Some of you are being unnecessarily overprotective of the original when I haven't said anything bad about it. I hadn't experienced Silent Hill before the Remake of 2 and it was an opportunity to play it.

I wanted to play the remake first before exploring the original.

There are things I appreciate that the remake does differently with the serious, subtle tones, while there is some clear and better delivery (with occasionally surprising humour) when it comes to the original.

The remake isn't woke slop or done poorly enough to warrant such shit flinging, it deserves a chance. Both versions are great.
No, you see, the culture war is a great war that needs to be fought to the bitter end. There are no survivors here (except bg3). Since sh2 remake has been deemed woke, it has now been doomed to be called a piece of gigantic shit eternally here and elsewhere. There is no room for nuance anymore.
 
I wanted to play the remake first before exploring the original.
That's the thing most of us are baffled by. It's totally backasswards thinking. Wouldn't you rather want to experience the game that hundreds of thousands of people already have such fond memories of first? To see what makes it so important in the first place that a remake of it is such a big deal, and then check out the new version to find out whether it did the original justice?
 
Back
Top Bottom