I last had hope for the series when I thought they had a chance of learning lessons after The Room wasn't so great, you can imagine my disappointment.
I can give credit to The Room for at least having some interesting ideas (the titular room is one of my favorite things in the series), crazy ass art direction for the nightmare worlds, a pretty out there story that still tied itself to the lore and just not being another Silent Hill 2 "I'm guilty of something and forgot what it was" plot.
I wasn't too hard on Origins initially because of the novelty of having a rather okay Silent Hill on a portable system even if the characterizations of Lisa and Kaufman was just dumb.
Homecomings logic falls a part immediately. "IM A TRAINED SOLDIER WITH MILITARY ABILITIES" doesn't make a lot of sense when what's his nuts was in an asylum the whole time, even if his daddy was a vet. The idea of a second cult wasn't the worst but when it goes Hostel at the end and you're killing miners from the movie I wrote it off. Doesn't help the gameplay feels unbalanced and janky, plus this is the first time Pyramid Head got pimped out like a battered whore.
After that it was just a big headed producer and friends circle jerk in full force.
I think from this era it was Shattered Memories I really did not like the most. It isn't Silent Hill 1. It isn't even a "reimagining" of Silent Hill 1 like they would keep saying. It has nothing to do with Silent Hill 1 or even SH in general.
Sure you got people named Harry and Dahlia, but they weren't the same character or even had anything in common other than Harry looking for his kid. Dahlia the cult leader? Now she's some burnt out goth slut with her tits named Sid and Nancy. Lisa is just there or something, had no real bearing on the plot other to just inexplicably start bleeding out like she did in the original but there was no reason to since she wasn't just some puppet for Alyssa anymore in this "reimagining."
Oh and Alyssa, the most important character and cause of the whole series, is just gone now.
Same with the locations. Superficially you kind of go to similar where. locations from SH1 in sort of the same order. But now instead of a creepy as fuck elementary school its some bland high school. The Balkan Church is now the Balkan nightclub. Hospital is just a lobby area.
Gameplay wise it's just a glorified game of tag with bland naked pink things. Its better at being a tech demo for some nice flashlight effects (I'll give the game credit for looking pretty fantastic on the wii of all things).
Shattered Memories was Tom Hulettes attempt to rewrite Silent Hill 1 and completely misses the point of Silent Hill in general. Makes sense since he and the Downpour director had stated they quite didn't understand the plot to SH1 iirc.
Having said all that, maybe if said title was its own thing and didn't have the SH name and what not I'd be nicer to it but the autistic fan in me loathed it and what it stood for.
Only thing worse would be the IDW comics which are so fucking unbearable and bad. Least Shattered Memories didn't have writing that felt like something an edgy 13 year old would write.