Star Trek - Space: The Final Frontier

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Dave did say it would be on Amazon too IIRC.
Will it be also on Pluto TV or other international streaming services, or exclusively on Paramount+ and Amazon Prime?
 
Dave did say it would be on Amazon too IIRC.
I'm curious but I also don't want to contribute to their watch stats. Star Trek is unfortunately moving into the same category as Star Wars for me, completely raped, dead, and gone.
 
Good or bad, it is an obligation to pirate this show.

It's the final season, so don't use the "if we watch it, they'll make the next season like this" argument. They are pandering now after years of insulting the fanbase.
 
I don't for a second belive that this last season will be a significant improvment apart from the fact it features the old TNG cast, regardless of what some youtube shills have to say about it. The preview material just looks like the same shit from the previous 2 seasons but now they have characters we know to make the emotional manupulation even more effective. Also, in my experience at least, people who are shown exclusive previews are generally much more positive about the product. I don't know why this is, might be the exculsivity or might just be that what they're shown is being heavily curated but either way its no assurance to me.

If I'm wrong about this come back and rate me MATI and if you're still going to watch it, pirate that shit.
 
I don't for a second belive that this last season will be a significant improvment apart from the fact it features the old TNG cast, regardless of what some youtube shills have to say about it. The preview material just looks like the same shit from the previous 2 seasons but now they have characters we know to make the emotional manupulation even more effective. Also, in my experience at least, people who are shown exclusive previews are generally much more positive about the product. I don't know why this is, might be the exculsivity or might just be that what they're shown is being heavily curated but either way its no assurance to me.

If I'm wrong about this come back and rate me MATI and if you're still going to watch it, pirate that shit.
I got the distinct feeling Robert Meyer Burnett was selling me something, not giving an honest review. It doesn't make me angry, but it's because I'm apathetic now.
 
I don't for a second belive that this last season will be a significant improvment apart from the fact it features the old TNG cast, regardless of what some youtube shills have to say about it. The preview material just looks like the same shit from the previous 2 seasons but now they have characters we know to make the emotional manupulation even more effective. Also, in my experience at least, people who are shown exclusive previews are generally much more positive about the product. I don't know why this is, might be the exculsivity or might just be that what they're shown is being heavily curated but either way its no assurance to me.

If I'm wrong about this come back and rate me MATI and if you're still
going to watch it, pirate that shit.
But that's the thing.Dave Cullen is not a current year shill. He is a super conservative guy that is outspoken against migrants and woke shit.

So they either gave him a lot of money, or the show is actually good. It would be very out of character for him to suddenly start shilling current Star Trek otherwise. I agree they don't deserve our money, but if it ends up being good then that's just more damming imho. That is, the fact that they would have done a good show,and still chose to make crap.
 
Last edited:
My personal theory is that these studios are waking up to the fact that woke shit isn't making any money and that the major investors are getting pissed. Disney is facing a hostile take over, is laying off thousands of people to cut over $5 billion from it's budget and lost something like 2.5 million Disney+ subscribers last year. Blackrock is losing money as well as being under investigation by several states attorney generals which means they can't hand out mountains of cash to companies with a good ESG score anymore. Even Bill Maher is calling out woketards comparing them to Mao's Cultural Revolution. Is the Day of the Rope coming? No, but there is hope that groomers and other degenerates are losing their hold on power.
 
But that's the thing.Dave Cullen is not a current year shill. He is a super conservative guy that is outspoken against migrants and woke shit.

So they either gave him a lot of money, or the show is actually good. It would be very our of character for him to suddenly start shilling current Star Trek. I agree they don't deserve our money, but if it ends up being good then that's just more damming imho. That is, the fact that they would have done a good show,and still chose to do make crap.
picard isn't outright woke tho - just outright shit, and not at all star trek. it's like drinker liking an episode of TLOU because he doesn't know and care about the source material, and sees it only through a specific lens.
 
But that's the thing.Dave Cullen is not a current year shill. He is a super conservative guy that is outspoken against migrants and woke shit.

So they either gave him a lot of money, or the show is actually good. It would be very out of character for him to suddenly start shilling current Star Trek otherwise. I agree they don't deserve our money, but if it ends up being good then that's just more damming imho. That is, the fact that they would have done a good show,and still chose to make crap.
The biggest problem with Picard (and all of nutrek for that matter) isn't that it's too "woke", it's just shit writing with nonsense plot lines and bland annoying characters. If you replaced every character on discovery with a 30yo white male it would still be a garbage show. The people working on these things have no passion for writing interesting scifi and their idea of being "groundbreaking" is adding a nonbinary character to the cast. The wokeness is a symptom, not the cause. Also let's be honest here it's fucking star trek, It's always had unusually diverse casts but no one gave a shit back then because the shows were actually good.

It's a lot easier to blame wokeness and culture war shit because it seems like a simple fix, the real problem is the quality of tv screenwriters has gone massively downhill in recent times and these shows especially are known for hiring tons of cheap freelancers to cut costs. The current game plan of star trek is quantity > quality, they make these shows to be generic and inoffensive to cast the widest possible net in the market and fill a slot on Paramount+. People like to say that SNW is better than Discovery, but the bad writing is the same. The only thing that's different about them is the tone and the format. The people who write these don't intentionally set out to make these shows crap they are just untalented hacks and/or don't care.

As for your second point, I have a more likely explanation, Cullen is just wrong. I can't say for sure because I don't watch this guys videos, but I guarantee you a lot of people are going to like this last season simply because they got rid of the stupid new characters and brought back the old cast. Doesn't matter if the writing is still garbage, the power of nostalgia bait is strong and it's not hard to make something slightly better than the first 2 seasons of Picard.

One more thing I'd like to mention, season 2 and 3 of Picard were shot back to back, so don't think that they've been listening to any criticism of season 2 and working to do better. Season 3 was already written and filmed before 2 was airing, so why would it be any different?
 
The biggest problem with Picard (and all of nutrek for that matter) isn't that it's too "woke", it's just shit writing with nonsense plot lines and bland annoying characters. If you replaced every character on discovery with a 30yo white male it would still be a garbage show. The people working on these things have no passion for writing interesting scifi and their idea of being "groundbreaking" is adding a nonbinary character to the cast. The wokeness is a symptom, not the cause. Also let's be honest here it's fucking star trek, It's always had unusually diverse casts but no one gave a shit back then because the shows were actually good.

It's a lot easier to blame wokeness and culture war shit because it seems like a simple fix, the real problem is the quality of tv screenwriters has gone massively downhill in recent times and these shows especially are known for hiring tons of cheap freelancers to cut costs. The current game plan of star trek is quantity > quality, they make these shows to be generic and inoffensive to cast the widest possible net in the market and fill a slot on Paramount+. People like to say that SNW is better than Discovery, but the bad writing is the same. The only thing that's different about them is the tone and the format. The people who write these don't intentionally set out to make these shows crap they are just untalented hacks and/or don't care.

As for your second point, I have a more likely explanation, Cullen is just wrong. I can't say for sure because I don't watch this guys videos, but I guarantee you a lot of people are going to like this last season simply because they got rid of the stupid new characters and brought back the old cast. Doesn't matter if the writing is still garbage, the power of nostalgia bait is strong and it's not hard to make something slightly better than the first 2 seasons of Picard.

One more thing I'd like to mention, season 2 and 3 of Picard were shot back to back, so don't think that they've been listening to any criticism of season 2 and working to do better. Season 3 was already written and filmed before 2 was airing, so why would it be any different?
I agree with you that, as much as I like to bitch about woke shit, it’s poor writing, what’s ruining modern entertainment.

As for Dave Cullen I have seen many of his videos. I am not defending Picard because it is indeed shit. I am just saying that it would be extremely out of character of him to shill it if it was bad. Like it would be the end of his reputation levels of risk.

He is not your average soyface shill is my point

Dave has been shitting on Discovery and Picard for a while. They are so confident this is good they allowed of him, one of the biggest and more outspoken critics of Nu-Trek to review it.

That‘s what makes me intrigued. But like you, I am not giving them my money. I am just curious not endorsing them.
 
Last edited:
Dave did say it would be on Amazon too IIRC.
It's being promoted for Paramount+ and Amazon Prime so yeah. No need to pirate for me, I guess.

Also, in my experience at least, people who are shown exclusive previews are generally much more positive about the product.
I got the impression from RMB that he wasn't given a screener, nor would he, but he somehow acquired it. He does know people. Also, he claims to have seen the entire 10-episode season while Cullen has only seen a few episodes. However...

I got the distinct feeling Robert Meyer Burnett was selling me something, not giving an honest review.
Robert Meyer Burnett is a fucking weasel and permanent barnacle on the Star Trek franchise who is only on YouTube being chummy with a bunch of people who have right-of-center views because he can't get work anymore. He basically showed-up, sucked the Fandom Menace's ass for a few months and now does 4-hour livestreams reading long fan letters like he's a Z-list celeb with a public access TV show (as-if reading superchats wasn't bad enough). That said, he does have pretty decent takes on Star Trek generally (despite being annoying and phony) and while I wouldn't put it past him to lie or exaggerate, Cullen backing him up adds more credence to it being decent.

I could see RMB having some gambit at play with the showrunner Terry Matalas, maybe thinking about the future of the franchise, but I don't see why Dave Cullen would lie. This is a guy who got catfished essentially by Strange New Worlds and abruptly quit his reviews in a huff when he found out the little minx femme fatale in the catsuit was played by a dude. He has every reason to give zero shits for a played-out Picard on it's last season, all things being equal.

I wasn't blown-away by the trailer. It looks like more of the same. But as a best-possible nuTrek take on the TNG crew, I can remain hopeful just based on Paramount showing the fleeting ability to, if not make good Star Trek, at least make decent TV occasionally. I thought parts of SNW were ok and Capt. Rios on Picard wasn't a bad character. Maybe if we squint we'll get a few decent scenes. I dunno. I have no delusions that this will be a return to form, though. I mean, this is still what we're dealing with:

 
Cullen can be a nutjob about politics, but his reviews of media have been moderate and fair. Rather than mad, he sounds frustrated when he's reviewed modern Star Trek because he honestly likes good Star Trek.

Now, if he's shilling for S3 in exchange for watching them in advance? Perhaps. I don't know the guy, I don't know his morals, but I honestly doubt it. He's not saying it's "omg! GOOD! ST IS BACK!", he's saying it's an improvement from past seasons (I know, not a high bar) and I think he might be correct considering Paramount is so optimist about it that they're giving it to their harshest critics.
 
It's being promoted for Paramount+ and Amazon Prime so yeah. No need to pirate for me, I guess.


I got the impression from RMB that he wasn't given a screener, nor would he, but he somehow acquired it. He does know people. Also, he claims to have seen the entire 10-episode season while Cullen has only seen a few episodes. However...


Robert Meyer Burnett is a fucking weasel and permanent barnacle on the Star Trek franchise who is only on YouTube being chummy with a bunch of people who have right-of-center views because he can't get work anymore. He basically showed-up, sucked the Fandom Menace's ass for a few months and now does 4-hour livestreams reading long fan letters like he's a Z-list celeb with a public access TV show (as-if reading superchats wasn't bad enough). That said, he does have pretty decent takes on Star Trek generally (despite being annoying and phony) and while I wouldn't put it past him to lie or exaggerate, Cullen backing him up adds more credence to it being decent.

I could see RMB having some gambit at play with the showrunner Terry Matalas, maybe thinking about the future of the franchise, but I don't see why Dave Cullen would lie. This is a guy who got catfished essentially by Strange New Worlds and abruptly quit his reviews in a huff when he found out the little minx femme fatale in the catsuit was played by a dude. He has every reason to give zero shits for a played-out Picard on it's last season, all things being equal.

I wasn't blown-away by the trailer. It looks like more of the same. But as a best-possible nuTrek take on the TNG crew, I can remain hopeful just based on Paramount showing the fleeting ability to, if not make good Star Trek, at least make decent TV occasionally. I thought parts of SNW were ok and Capt. Rios on Picard wasn't a bad character. Maybe if we squint we'll get a few decent scenes. I dunno. I have no delusions that this will be a return to form, though. I mean, this is still what we're dealing with:

https://youtube.com/watch?v=Ke95ILu4X5A
Paramount's coverage is pretty much like EA's 2017 E3 coverage. Both doing great jobs at doing Jeb Bush impressions.
 
But that's the thing.Dave Cullen is not a current year shill. He is a super conservative guy that is outspoken against migrants and woke shit.

So they either gave him a lot of money, or the show is actually good. It would be very out of character for him to suddenly start shilling current Star Trek otherwise. I agree they don't deserve our money, but if it ends up being good then that's just more damming imho. That is, the fact that they would have done a good show,and still chose to make crap.

I'm leaning toward money. The reviewer might be a journo but it sounds pretty par for the course and like season 3 is going to be utter shit

and before anyone defends cullen lets not forget his real interesting history with the likes of based mama and lending his name to the killroy shit
 

I'm leaning toward money. The reviewer might be a journo but it sounds pretty par for the course and like season 3 is going to be utter shit

and before anyone defends cullen lets not forget his real interesting history with the likes of based mama and lending his name to the killroy shit

I had no idea about those incidents. Like most people, I was just a casual viewer that found him after being fed up with woke shit.

Well, if he is indeed a sellout, and he is lying to shill Picard , then he has lost all respect I had of him. I could let slide some of his iffy political takes, but being a sell out would make him even lower than the people making current trek for me.
 
Last edited:

I'm leaning toward money. The reviewer might be a journo but it sounds pretty par for the course and like season 3 is going to be utter shit

and before anyone defends cullen lets not forget his real interesting history with the likes of based mama and lending his name to the killroy shit
Now if you'll excuse me, I'll be riding my high horse by dancing on the show's grave.
 
Back
Top Bottom