Star Trek - Space: The Final Frontier

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Just once I would have liked to see a reasonable authority figure from the USP side who didn't turn out to be a space worm infestee/colony droop genocider/drumhead court enthusiast/paramilitary supremacist/changeling infiltrator all along.
Best we get is the highly personable but ultimately soft and weak Jaresh-Inyo, strong federalism never ever.
Problem is that the feddies have the best ships, smartest nerds, boldest captains, and even god (Q) on their side. So if they have a reasonable admiral the story would just be:
"The Cardassians are causing issues."
'Hmmm, send a Galaxy class and watch them shit themselves for a couple of weeks, then we'll negotiate.'
"What if they start a fight?"
'...Why would they kill themselves? Dumb question,'
 
Just once I would have liked to see a reasonable authority figure from the USP side who didn't turn out to be a space worm infestee/colony droop genocider/drumhead court enthusiast/paramilitary supremacist/changeling infiltrator all along.
Best we get is the highly personable but ultimately soft and weak Jaresh-Inyo, strong federalism never ever.
Spock. The word you're looking for is Spock.
 
The Federation is a big ass interstellar organization of a whole bunch of places and the maquis are complete niggers in their eyes for endangering a hard won peace.
It's easy to sympathize with their plight, muh homes all that, but there's a bigger picture beyond the badlands and that's what High Command cares about not some colonial backwaters.
DS9 best trek but it really fell short portraying the Federation's actual animus, Cardies have Dukat/Klingons get gowron/even the Dominion get a mantled representative in the female changeling, what does the Federation get? Captain Sicko? He's a commander of some border post, the only higher ups we ever see are asshole admirals.
To use a real-world analogy, the Federation agreed to a Skyes-Picot treaty where arbitrary lines were drawn regardless of which citizens lived where. Of course it was going to lead to proxy war sooner or later. One which the Navajo lost.
I mean...it is Trek. If one thing about the Federation has remained consistent, it's that their admirals seem universally batshit insane; or infested with alien parasites, or are themselves spies, or are running cover black ops divisions, or are time displaced Hitler clones.
The Admiralty in TNG times has a selection bias against bold risk takers and people of vision. All those Black Ops types like Pressman and Leyton are punished for having foresight. The Feds want bureaucratic middlemen between the Council and the Captains out in the field. Had they listened to Leyton during the Dominion War, they probably would have been able to contain the Dominion at the Wormhole because he would have assigned a fleet of advanced ships to defend DS9 a year or two earlier than they did.
 
This was about the fan film recently, that one that covers the original series. It ends with Kirk and Spock holding hands and looking off into the sunset. It's considered the original slash ship of fandom, and many were overjoyed to see it.
As I understood it, Spock is on his death bed and the 2 are holding hands because they're old friends, and both are about to ascend to heaven or some shit. Of course the faggots have to make it weird.
 
As I understood it, Spock is on his death bed and the 2 are holding hands because they're old friends, and both are about to ascend to heaven or some shit. Of course the faggots have to make it weird.
It's very clearly a deathbed comfort scene. Its just very open ended exactly how Kirk is there. If he's a spirit or physically there from say the shatnerverse ( my favorite)
 
As I understood it, Spock is on his death bed and the 2 are holding hands because they're old friends, and both are about to ascend to heaven or some shit. Of course the faggots have to make it weird.
Indeed, and a similar thing happened in Arcane, albeit at least Kirk and Spock had a proper ending. As I've heard it, holding hands is considered very intimate to Vulcans?
 
All those Black Ops types like Pressman and Leyton are punished for having foresight.
Don't forget Mawell. He knew the spoon heads were up to bullshit and a lot of it.
As I understood it, Spock is on his death bed and the 2 are holding hands because they're old friends, and both are about to ascend to heaven or some shit. Of course the faggots have to make it weird.
Nope, you can't comfort your dying friend with which you gone through hell and back. The deviants will immediately claim that as a sign they were right all along and must ruin the moment for everyone else.
 
The more I watch DS9, the more I think Robert Hewitt Wolfe is the reason why it's good and not Behr. Behr is responsible for the Jewishness of the show.
He's also responsible for the better half of Andromeda. (Not that it's a fantastic show, but the seasons after he left are quite a dive in quality).
 
I just had a random thought.
I know it wouldn't have been planned this way, but in retrospect, do you think that Q could tell Sisko was wormhole alien Jesus (and probably a demigod), and that's the real reason why he fucked off and never came back?
 
I think that's the official justification. He probably felt something in that punch that scared him deeply.
I know it's probably technically a retcon, but I wonder why I never put that together before tonight haha.
 
The more I watch DS9, the more I think Robert Hewitt Wolfe is the reason why it's good and not Behr. Behr is responsible for the Jewishness of the show.
I quite seriously believe it was a 1-in-a-million shot at the combination of all the main writers with each one helping to cover the weaknesses of the other. Take any one of them out and the show tanks in quality.
 
I just had a random thought.
https://youtube.com/watch?v=Etc8qdqiR5kI know it wouldn't have been planned this way, but in retrospect, do you think that Q could tell Sisko was wormhole alien Jesus (and probably a demigod), and that's the real reason why he fucked off and never came back?
I mean...

The later revelation that Sisko is a literal demigod adds new layers to that moment.

Like now you can fan-edit into the subtext that Q felt more of Sisko's punch than he thought he should have and it clued him into the fact there was more than there seemed to this human. The Q and the Prophets probably have some non-compete treaties between them so Q decided it wasn't worth the possibility of riling them up and left their little child alone.

That was over 2 years ago now.
 
I still like it. One episode with one weird coupling does not make a show bad.
It doesn't help that it was a badly paced episode in general. Too many sub-plots crowding out the main story.

The two-pip Kim betrayal arc was poorly signalled. They had a couple of shots of him looking grumpy about how things were, but they never really developed it enough to justify his sudden decision to kidnap all the Kims. They should have given a scene of him convincing at least one of them to work with him to explain the way some of them seemed to cooperate on the ship.

It was clear, to me at least, that they wanted to imply that parts of the multiverse were chronologically different from the part "we" know, which is how we get Lilly Sloan, T'Pol, and Curzon around at the same time. A single line of dialogue could have fixed that one. The script may well have had that line, only for it to be cut to allow more time for the bashir/garak shipping.

They should have had Curzon be Odo with Curzon's personality mingled in from that one DS9 episode. If we're going to do memberberries, then we really need to lean into it, instead of just referencing Voyager again.

The worst crime is that whoever wrote Garak had absolutely no idea what they were doing. Plain, Simple Garak should be far more obsequious and scheming.
 
Back
Top Bottom