- Joined
- Aug 22, 2024
truly, its insidiousThe key underlying problem the Federation has in regards to other nations is their perceived hypocrisy. Somewhere in this thread, I talked about the Federation's irresponsible colonization policy as the means of the government getting rid of their undesirables like the Bringloidi, the Navajo, or the Maquis. After all, it's better to dare people who don't agree with Fed policy to go off and create their own colonies than to imprison them. There are so many colonists that the Feds don't keep track of them all. However, to other nations, colonists are not private citizens homesteading free real estate, but Fed citizens constantly expanding their sphere of influence. It also doesn't help that the colonists are frontiers people at best, grifters like Jason Vigo, Cyrano jones, and Harry Mudd at medium, and at worst gang members like Turkana IV. Thus, the Federation often leaves a bad impression to the Shelliak Corporate, the Tzenkethi, the Gorn, the Talarians, the Tholians, and the Cardassians, to say nothing about the other major powers.
So, the Federation talks a lot about its ideals to liberal democracy and the Prime Directive while also constantly expanding its territory using private citizens, whom are often defended by Starfleet. The colonies themselves may become hubs of criminal activity like Turkana IV and then the Fed's reaction is to say it's not their responsibility. The Prime directive is disregarded mostly by Kirk, for moral reasons, but the more exceptions are made to a rule, the less of a rule it actually is.
I think thats the best way to portray a utopian society from the outside.


