Eddington calling Sisko Javert was retarded. The hologram on the bridge as a communication method was retarded.
I don’t know how you’re supposed to judge Eddington because every time the Maquis show up they are just libertarians with phasers.
And Sisko can’t decide if he hates them or not. At the end he’s like,
I hope they’re still alive somewhere.
Why? Sisko’s like,
I love underdogs, and then immediately puts the dog down.
The whole Maquis arc is so dumb. At first they're like
We just want our land back. Okay. Then it’s
Let’s break the ceasefire until Cardassia gets mad and starts a war. Eddington then pivots into Joe Rogan wellness influencer.
We only eat non-replicated food. We want to live off the grid. You can live off the grid anywhere. He’s like
The Federation is oppressing me because I can’t homestead in active war territory.
This is kind of Ron Moore’s stock and trade: he likes to push buttons and make the audience uncomfortable, which can be great, but sometimes the dilemma collapses under mild scrutiny. You have the designated “Federation Critic” giving a speech about cultural imperialism while benefiting from Federation warp drives, medicine, and not living under a fascist lizard regime.
The holo-communicator is the funniest part though, I agree. It looks like Emperor Palpatine, but worse, because
Star Trek holograms are always super clean, so they can’t even make it look fuzzy. It’s just a guy under a spooky light.
And Sisko has to rotate his chair 180 degrees every time. He’s just spinning around to yell at Ghost Zoom.