Stinkditch Meta Thread

[Blanche]

I'm sure they've already been scouring r/transdiy and other places without fully needing to interview baby troons.

 

[Adrenochrome Dreams]

Can we have an unpopular opinions thread for anything trans or GC related?

 

[Candidate No 7]

Article by James Esses in the Telgraph today:

We must have a public inquiry into the damage caused by gender ideology

Society is, slowly but surely, beginning to wake up to the horrors caused in the name of gender ideology. Children have been harmed. Women have been erased. Free speech has been attacked. Reality has been undermined.

Thankfully, the tide is starting to turn. The Secretary of State for Health, Victoria Atkins, made a landmark statement before Parliament. NHS England has halted the prescription of puberty blockers. Numerous sporting bodies have preserved fair competition for women. Many gender-critical litigants who suffered for speaking out have been vindicated in the Courts.

However, we are not out of the woods yet. Not by a long way.

We still don’t understand why more young people than ever, particularly young girls and those who are same sex attracted, are presenting with a mental health condition causing them to believe they were born in the wrong body.

There are schools that continue to teach children that it is possible to change their sex. State and non-State institutions alike remain signed up to Stonewall’s biased schemes. Corporations continue to promote and glorify medical transitioning in their advertisements, in shameless pursuit of profit.

Therapeutic bodies continue to push a model of “unconditional affirmation” on clinicians. Private gender clinics continue to encourage vulnerable clients to transition. Those who raise concerns continue to be labelled as bigots and silenced, threatened or cancelled.

I know this only too well – I was expelled from my Masters’ degree in Psychotherapy and removed from my role as a counsellor at Childline – all because I expressed concern about child safeguarding.

Equally, there are those out there who seek to keep us shackled to gender ideology. We witnessed this through the number of NHS clinics which withheld material from the ground-breaking Cass Review. Schools are even being advised by activist groups to ignore the government guidance for children questioning their gender within schools. Clearly, guidance and reviews are simply not enough.

That is why I, along with over 130 prominent signatories, have written to the Prime Minister, demanding a public inquiry into the failure of societal institutions to safeguard children from harm. An inquiry that considers these issues holistically is the only answer to an ideology that has managed to infiltrate an entire society. Crucially, a statutory public inquiry will be able to legally compel evidence and make concrete recommendations to ensure real change is brought about.

This letter has been signed by parliamentarians, clinicians, therapists, lawyers, social workers, detransitioners, academics, journalists, campaigners, and commentators.

Reading the full letter, you may be surprised by some of the names who, under normal circumstances, have nothing in common with one another. Our letter has signatures from across the political spectrum, including Conservatives, Labour, Reform, Green, Social Democratic Party and Alba. That is because this issue is not about left or right. It is about right and wrong.

The stakes could not be higher. Children and young people have been left scarred, emotionally and physically, in the name of gender ideology. Some have been left infertile. Others have lost parts of their bodies that they can never get back.

As a society, we have failed in our duty of care towards children. We must secure justice for those who have been harmed. Crucially, we must ensure that no child again suffers the same fate.

Rishi – If you are reading this. Please do the right thing and set up a public inquiry as a matter of urgency. Our children’s wellbeing depends on it.

 

[Peaches the Wonder Cat]

Not sure where else to put this and don’t really wanna start a thread. Apparently the Guardian over in BritBongland is trying to do reporting on the DIY HRT over there and the troons are freaking out about it.

https://infosec.exchange/@molytov/112295995943022360

View attachment 5921772

We have a name for the reporter writing the story: Susanna Rustin. She's "gender critical" so this should be good.

Link | Archive

 

[Candidate No 7]

I don't know if this was discussed here at the time as I was only an occasional lurker then but Vice magazine last year ran a "tribute" piece to the murdered teenager Brianna Ghey. It was authored by Ben Hunte who is a fanatical trans ally.

‘We’re Her Trans Sisters’: Friends Pay Tribute to Stabbing Victim Brianna Ghey

Relevant bits:





Note: not blockers, hormones. Also: younger = < 16.


EDIT: Troons appear to have entirely made up the article about DIY HRT.





They are now naturally lying about their lies.

 

[Not A Cat Person]

I didn't see this posted anywhere, and I don't immediately see anywhere else more valid to post it, so here's a 44-minute video by a lesbian who went through the whole FtM phase and back to identifying as her birth gender, and now is pretty cynical and critical of the whole thing, sharing her experience.

It's broken down into segments. Highlights include the 17-year-old being groomed by her crazy mother and 27-year-old boyfriend, how the support group dynamic was such that the MtFs completely dominated the space and cowed the FtMs by asserting that if any FtM stood up for anything she was abusing her 'male privilege', how the local transgender support group would do everything in their power to destroy therapists that weren't giving trannies total unquestioning affirmation, and how a gay man who was murdered was posthumously 'transed' to bump up the numbers on the transgender murder rate.

Attached is an archive.

 

[cave dwelling faggot]

Can we have a thread that records instances of when troons do something outlandish enough that the even the general populace/normies start dunking on them. Eg. Chris Chan rapes his mom, male powerlifting coach breaks women's record, etc.

 

[Buck Broken Chimp]

So I just found something funny

https://www.reddit.com/r/TERFisafetish/comments/1bsr5fh/v_a_l_i_d_a_transgender_day_of_visiblity_rap/

https://youtu.be/3C-nQvo4f-4

I will try to download the video later I am away from my desktop so I can't download it atm. Also I am not going to bother archiving the reddit post because it has no comments. I got nothing this video is so awful that it speaks for itself.

On a side note have we reached peaked MtF ? I would like that to be the case but I am not convinced. We all know about the incel to transgender pipeline and the transmaxxing movement. I fear that with the incel problem getting worst (I think like half of all gen z men above 18 are incels and it's only going to go up) more of them will just give up and transition so they can date lesbians and "straight men" who are also desperate. I think I speak for everyone here when I say that I would rather go without then date a fucking tranny or even worst chop my dick off but the average zoomer isn't like us, also keep in mind they have been indoctrinated to support trannies since the day they were born.

Another factor is diversity hiring, being trans is interesting in the sense it's one of the few "marginalized groups" that you can opt into. with the rise of diversity hiring and even diversity hiring being subsidized through things like ESG scores and even government contracts. A lot of people might just decide that being financially stable and getting a good job means more to them then being a man or a woman, again I would never do this but a lot of people especially zoomers who were raised on the atomizing individualism of modern day neo liberalism and are financially destitute might go for it.


I do however think that we have reached peak FtM, FtM actually surpassed MtF somewhat recently, however I do not see this lasting. I think everyone on this thread is aware of the rapidly growing detrans movement and how most of it's followers are former FtM transgenders. I think what caused the outgrowth in FtM transgenderism is an ever leftward shifting overton window. The gamer gate era was the peak of feminism and I think we all remember that time for all the cringe on both sides. However post 2016 being a woman especially a white woman was no longer enough to be a victim. As for why more women detransition it's probably because for most women transitioning will hurt their social prospects. A lot of former FtMs are oftentimes women who liked men but got bullied out of it because nowadays you can't just be a woman who likes men (gen z has a term for this it's called being a "pick me girl") so they transition so they can be a "gay man" which to them allows them to love men in a socially acceptable way. It also hurts their standing with other women because especially among gen Z women were raised to fear and on some level hate men.

So where do you see the trans trend going ? Our lord Null said just today

When the troon fad finally dies, remember the names of the people who championed it for profit.

So clearly he thinks that transgenderism is going to join the 41% but what do you think ?

 

[SomeSpook]

Just like the lobotomies of yesteryear, transgenderism will be seen as a blight on psychology and the entirety of the west. Even if such a thing were to occur, there will still be small, if not large, pockets of people championing the beliefs of the transsexual ideology screaming out how the government is killing trans people. These individuals deny the very fabric of reality to suit their ideals, and I hope the public is starting to wake up and smell the ashes.

 

[Ingmar Aspergman]

Here’s my doomer prediction and I hope I’m wrong:

None of these people will ever face any consequences, and gender critical rhetoric will go down in history as correct but bad faith. “Yeah you were right but you were motivated out of hate and just happened to be correct. You’re still on the wrong side of history”. They pushed this way too hard and for too long to ever admit wrongdoing, so it’s going to be forgotten to save them from a scarlet letter for all eternity. Regardless of what happens, I don’t think any sufficient punishment will ever befall them.

 

[Bloo]

I didn't see this posted anywhere, and I don't immediately see anywhere else more valid to post it, so here's a 44-minute video by a lesbian who went through the whole FtM phase and back to identifying as her birth gender, and now is pretty cynical and critical of the whole thing, sharing her experience.

It's broken down into segments. Highlights include the 17-year-old being groomed by her crazy mother and 27-year-old boyfriend, how the support group dynamic was such that the MtFs completely dominated the space and cowed the FtMs by asserting that if any FtM stood up for anything she was abusing her 'male privilege', how the local transgender support group would do everything in their power to destroy therapists that weren't giving trannies total unquestioning affirmation, and how a gay man who was murdered was posthumously 'transed' to bump up the numbers on the transgender murder rate.

Attached is an archive.

That video was bananas. when she said she knew a TIF who would walk around shirtless BEFORE top surgery too. Complete delusion.

 

[Not Dr. Evil]

Autistic male cross dresser tried to "fact check" Colin Wright.

He inadvertently proved Colin correct about the lack of medical evidence for transgenderism.

From the linked paper:

 

[Bloo]

I’ve been reading Helen Joyce’s “Trans” book. So far very interesting. I wasn’t quite aware of just how fucking insane queer theory is until now, no wonder so many of these people think they’re magically changing their actual sex by saying so. I was one of the people who thought the argument was “trans people are simply changing their gender identity/expression” for years which she mentions.

Any other book recommendations? “Irreversible Damage” is also on my list.

 

[Frankenhooker69]

I’ve been reading Helen Joyce’s “Trans” book. So far very interesting. I wasn’t quite aware of just how fucking insane queer theory is until now, no wonder so many of these people think they’re magically changing their actual sex by saying so. I was one of the people who thought the argument was “trans people are simply changing their gender identity/expression” for years which she mentions.

Any other book recommendations? “Irreversible Damage” is also on my list.

irreversible damage is a great reading i advice anyone to read it

Has anyone got any Youtube recommendations for gender critical topics? I have been watching a lot of King Critical recently, he's fantastic.

king critical makes really good videos super recommended

 

[Izdaja Slika]

Has anyone got any Youtube recommendations for gender critical topics? I have been watching a lot of King Critical recently, he's fantastic.

Peak Trans is excellent, especially her 'awful arguments' transgender ideologists make

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ywb42apNOKo&list=PLesY3LxfPFuhqq9bQcr82w2W2HjbDQCA8

Absolutely any interview or panel that has Helen Joyce.

 

[nyymit]

https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/661751

Petition to ban minor hormone disruptors

 

[Bloo]

Peak Trans is excellent, especially her 'awful arguments' transgender ideologists make

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ywb42apNOKo&list=PLesY3LxfPFuhqq9bQcr82w2W2HjbDQCA8

Absolutely any interview or panel that has Helen Joyce.

I love Helen so much. I’ve watched a few interviews with her and I’m getting to the end of her book now.

Thanks for the channel recommendation! I hadn’t come across her yet.

 

[Super-Chevy454]

Here’s my doomer prediction and I hope I’m wrong:

None of these people will ever face any consequences, and gender critical rhetoric will go down in history as correct but bad faith. “Yeah you were right but you were motivated out of hate and just happened to be correct. You’re still on the wrong side of history”. They pushed this way too hard and for too long to ever admit wrongdoing, so it’s going to be forgotten to save them from a scarlet letter for all eternity. Regardless of what happens, I don’t think any sufficient punishment will ever befall them.

Yeah just like lots of people who pushed for the so-called vaxx but that's a story for an other thread.

And no need to guess they'll hate that article.

https://www.americanthinker.com/blog/2024/05/even_as_leftists_relentlessly_push_trans_hard_evidence_shows_how_suicidally_dangerous_it_is.html

https://archive.ph/lvrXP

May 19, 2024

Even as leftists relentlessly push ‘trans,’ hard evidence shows how suicidally dangerous it is​

By Andrea Widburg


America’s cultural controllers, the ones in political circles, the news media, entertainment, and Hollywood, are relentless in their insistence that so-called “transgenderism” is real and that the way to improve so-called “transgender” people’s lives is to give them hormones that are opposed to their biological sex and to engage in mutilating slice-and-dice surgery. However, as more data arrive, it’s clear that the whole “transgender” push is a Big Lie—and the problem with a Big Lie is that, eventually, usually long after lots of damage is already done, the truth starts to leak out.

Disney, of course, is one of the leaders in the LGBTQ+ grooming vanguard, but it’s not just Disney. NBC is now promoting a nature show that is also an exercise in LGBTQ+ grooming.
If you’re like me, you remember watching the wonderful “Mutual of Omaha’s Wild Kingdom,” a nature documentary that ran from 1963-1988 and was rebooted from 2002-2011.

I was a toddler when it started, but probably watched it regularly through about 1975. Those were the Marlin Perkins years when he’d recount with breathless enthusiasm the wild and wonderful things animals would do.
We’d see their hunts but not their kills or, at least, the kills would be shown from a carefully bloodless distance. We also got to see their mating rituals but never saw the animals actually having sex. We’d learn about their migrations and their habitat building. It was real information but very family-friendly.

In the nature shows of that more innocent era (a time when Disney was also in the nature show biz), the most risqué it ever got was seeing animals getting drunk on ripened marula fruits, as in this famous footage:

 

[Candidate No 7]

I’ve been reading Helen Joyce’s “Trans” book. So far very interesting. I wasn’t quite aware of just how fucking insane queer theory is until now, no wonder so many of these people think they’re magically changing their actual sex by saying so. I was one of the people who thought the argument was “trans people are simply changing their gender identity/expression” for years which she mentions.

Any other book recommendations? “Irreversible Damage” is also on my list.

Helen Joyce is very, very courageous: she has moved on from a successful journalism career in a different field to become a full-time writer and campaigner on this, and unlike others AFAIK the mob didn't even come after her in the first place to force her hand. Like JKR, she simply couldn't look away. She has shrugged off colossal amounts of gross abuse, not just online but in some occasions to her face.

Kathleen Stock's book Material Girls (which has a rather odd cover) is interesting too. Much more cerebral as it's analytical philosophy, but it's very good at unraveling the mental mind games trans activism has imposed on society.

Jane Clare Jones' Annals of the Terf War is the funniest thing written on the whole topic that I know of.

 

[Lmfao123]

I recently had discovered a subreddit called /r/nestofeggs. It's a subreddit for trannies to vent about their 'dysphoric struggles'. The funny thing is that if you've read one thread, then you have pretty much have read all of them as most of them are identical to one another (kms this, kms that... same old self-hating tranny behavior). Quite a lot of the users in that subreddit seem to be underage as well, which saddens me. These kids are setting up themselves for a life's worth of mental anguish all because they got caught up in rapid onset dysphoria, and are now fixating on it.

God forbid you give actual advice to a person with a thread asking 'how to not be trans'. You'll get banned for "encouraging repression".