The Legend of Heroes Series - Possibly The Most Underrated JRPG Series

terry fan 67 said:
really enjoyed the the sky and crossbell games but wasn't a fan of cold steel at all, finished cold steel 3 and kinda left it there. you think it's worthwhile to pick up and play cs 4 even if i didn't enjoy the previous entries?
Click to expand...
I'm surprised you didn't like cold steel series. Its genuinely the best jrpg out there but no contest to the YS games.
 
BananaSplit said:
Your sole option at this point would be to learn moonrunes (which is technically the smart thing to do in case you care about japanese media as a whole without relying on a middleman). We've gotten as far trusting even fan-translators is not 100% possible these days.
Click to expand...
Yes learn moonrunes which is what all these currently existing translators also did.

Unless you're actually living or doing business in Japan and need it on a daily basis, learning Japanese for anime and games is the quickest way to being a tard or a transexual (or both) on the internet. It's a very slippery slope.

and yes it's why XSeed lost the rights to Trails and Ys, because they got people who only learned Japanese to watch anime and play games.


No fan translation has ever worked because there's a billion fucking Jet, Aeon, and Nova fags who are all "experts" in Japanese and none of them can ever come to an agreement on what's accurate. Especially when shit constantly involves comedy or heavy sarcasm and wit like a Terry Pratchett adaptation. Accuracy with Comedy always fucks things up for translators because jokes(especially ones that rely on word play or quick witted puns) get lost when it turns out the accurate translation isn't actually funny at all. And if you fucked up the Comedy by making it not funny, you fucked up the translation.

And speaking of comedy, most of these people only can identify comedy if they can go LOL LEWD.
 
Last edited:
  • Dumb
Reactions: BlazikenLover and BananaSplit
Marissa Moira said:
Unless you're actually living or doing business in Japan and need it on a daily basis, learning Japanese for anime and games is the quickest way to being a tard or a transexual (or both) on the internet. It's a very slippery slope.
Click to expand...
As opposed to learn english (or any other language) for the main reason of interacting with any media and other personal hobbies, and not necessarily for professional purposes or living overseas? バカことを言うな

And don't try to defend translators putting memes in script lines that were originally normal.

Edit: I'm also not fan of localization rewrites that change the personality of characters, such as making them more of a cunt for no reason
 

Attachments

  • Sky.png
    Sky.png
    128.8 KB · Views: 110
  • Sky2.png
    Sky2.png
    39.5 KB · Views: 114
Last edited:
BananaSplit said:
As opposed to learn english (or any other language) for the main reason of interacting with any media and other personal hobbies, and not necessarily for professional purposes or living overseas? バカことを言うな

And don't try to defend translators putting memes in script lines that were originally normal.

Edit: I'm also not fan of localization rewrites that change the personality of characters, such as making them more of a cunt for no reason
Click to expand...
Learning English isn't the same way because English is primarily used by businesses the world over, Japanese doesn't have the same widespread and generalized use.

Also translators putting jokes in where there isn't any isn't something that's exclusive to the west, China and Korea do the same. Sometimes translations walk the line between gag translations and a serious attempt, but people still wind up liking them.

What matters first and foremost for a game translation isn't the accuracy to the rules of the original language, because games are Show Don't Tell. The translation just needs to be up to par so players can understand the generalized context context of what's happening on screen. Because Ys 8 sold the best out of any of previous games including 6 on the PS2, and they redid the translation post launch and most parts were clearly made by a machine. Tales of Berseria was the same way, once you get to the post game there are quite a few errors where the machine made a mistake and misheard words due to Eizen's and Rokurou's accents. But that didn't stop it from becoming one of the more popular Tales games.
 
Last edited:
  • Dumb
Reactions: BlazikenLover and BananaSplit
Marissa Moira said:
Learning English isn't the same way because English is primarily used by businesses the world over, Japanese doesn't have the same widespread and generalized use.

Also translators putting jokes in where there isn't any isn't something that's exclusive to the west, China and Korea do the same. Sometimes translations walk the line between gag translations and a serious attempt, but people still wind up liking them.

What matters first and foremost for a game translation isn't the accuracy to the rules of the original language, because games are Show Don't Tell. The translation just needs to be up to par so players can understand the generalized context context of what's happening on screen. Because Ys 8 sold the best out of any of previous games including 6 on the PS2, and they redid the translation post launch and most parts were clearly made by a machine. Tales of Berseria was the same way, once you get to the post game there are quite a few errors where the machine made a mistake and misheard words due to Eizen's and Rokurou's accents. But that didn't stop it from becoming one of the more popular Tales games.
Click to expand...
Again, the reasoning you cannot learn a foreign language unless it is absolutely used in the context of business work/living overseas is the most stupid normalfag thing to say. And just because the average consumer may not give a shit (or is simply not aware too) about the accuracy of a translation do not make entire rewrites, inserting memes, and even censorship a right thing either. This is not respecting the medium whatsoever. You exactly sound like the shitty translators throwing a hissy fit when they face criticism by claiming that "who cares as long as it's understandable" and other ad populum fallacies to pretend that kind of ethic work is acceptable.

And JRPGs are games where the story and characters do actually matter a lot. There are people who want to play those games as the creators originally intended, not some "extra flavored" fanfiction from the mongoloid in charge of translating who clearly doesn't care about the job and medium he works for. It's a sad and unfortunate reality to learn a foreign language in order to escape western game translators who are sharing many similarities with game journalists now.

geofront.jpg
 
Have they announced anything new? The pink haired nun's game? That ps4 port of Ao no Kiseki, hajimari no kiseki, etc?
 
BananaSplit said:
Again, the reasoning you cannot learn a foreign language unless it is absolutely used in the context of business work/living overseas is the most stupid normalfag thing to say. And just because the average consumer may not give a shit (or is simply not aware too) about the accuracy of a translation do not make entire rewrites, inserting memes, and even censorship a right thing either. This is not respecting the medium whatsoever. You exactly sound like the shitty translators throwing a hissy fit when they face criticism by claiming that "who cares as long as it's understandable" and other ad populum fallacies to pretend that kind of ethic work is acceptable.

And JRPGs are games where the story and characters do actually matter a lot. There are people who want to play those games as the creators originally intended, not some "extra flavored" fanfiction from the mongoloid in charge of translating who clearly doesn't care about the job and medium he works for. It's a sad and unfortunate reality to learn a foreign language in order to escape western game translators who are sharing many similarities with game journalists now.

View attachment 2213621
Click to expand...
Fan translations usually never ever intended to respect any medium. They're pissing contests on who's a bigger worshipper of Japan and how everyone else on the team is a heretic gaijin. Which is why many fan translation efforts fall apart, they tear each other up.

In JRPGs everything is secondary to gameplay, they're all heavily mechanics based. It's why they take very long to develop, everything else is a very very very distant second or third.

People really just need the basic jist of what's going on in order to enjoy the game. Obsessing over lore or intercharacter relationships to the point where one single word could change everything and putting that as the primary focus is what dragged down studios like bioware in to the bucket of crabs that it's currently in.

And going YOU HAVE TO LEARN JAPANESE TO ESCAPE THE WRATH OF THE SJWs is a tad bit of a comical extreme, in any scenario. Especially since linguistic purity has never worked like that even back in the 80's and 90's.
 
Last edited:
  • Agree
Reactions: Trollblade69
Scarlett Johansson said:
Have they announced anything new? The pink haired nun's game? That ps4 port of Ao no Kiseki, hajimari no kiseki, etc?
Click to expand...
Kuro news has been dropping. Launches September, 30 in Japan.

Search Results for “kuro no kiseki” - Gematsu

www.gematsu.com www.gematsu.com

No news on Hajimari or Crossbell localizations, and the prospects of any Kiseki game coming west this year are basically nil at this point unless NISA decides do something at or around E3, which would be way out of character.
 
ForgedBlades said:
Kuro news has been dropping. Launches September, 30 in Japan.

Search Results for “kuro no kiseki” - Gematsu

www.gematsu.com www.gematsu.com

No news on Hajimari or Crossbell localizations, and the prospects of any Kiseki game coming west this year are basically nil at this point unless NISA decides do something at or around E3, which would be way out of character.
Click to expand...
Azure and Blue got gigafucked by Corona, they were supposed to come out soon after 4.

They had shit in the works prior but there's no progress report on what they had translated. However they're also switching over to PS5 dev kits so, that's also adding time to things. They could be PS5 timed exclusives.

Crossbell has still got XSeed tied to it. Their chinese parent company has other ideas so it's up to that. They don't seem interested in a series where they only own 3 out of the 10 titles. Ys was lucky that it got MoC released on PS4.


Also look who's back, I was at least expecting them to hold off for the sequel before they reintroduced major characters.
fie.png
 
I finally finished trails of cold steel 4 and I enjoyed it, it did lag a bit in a few parts and it was a very long game, but overall I think it was a good finale to the series. Are there other similar games that people would recommend? Are the Legend of heroes games the same quality?
 
caonima said:
I finally finished trails of cold steel 4 and I enjoyed it, it did lag a bit in a few parts and it was a very long game, but overall I think it was a good finale to the series. Are there other similar games that people would recommend? Are the Legend of heroes games the same quality?
Click to expand...
You could try Falcom's other series like Ys 8 and YS 9, but that's more action rpg than turn based.
 
  • Like
Reactions: caonima
NISA has sent out emails promising "new announcements", Kondo, new merch, and more during a livestream next week.


Based on the time it's likely aimed at the Japanese market as well, but I doubt NISA would be pimping it if there wasn't something big to announce.

EDIT: Gematsu story
www.gematsu.com

NIS America to host Falcom 40th anniversary live stream on June 24 - Gematsu

NIS America will host a Falcom 40th anniversary celebration on June 24 at 10:00 p.m. PT / June 25 at 1:00 a.m. ET, the publisher announced. You will be able to watch it on YouTube and Twitch.
www.gematsu.com www.gematsu.com
 
Last edited:
ForgedBlades said:
NISA has sent out emails promising "new announcements", Kondo, new merch, and more during a livestream next week.


Based on the time it's likely aimed at the Japanese market as well, but I doubt NISA would be pimping it if there wasn't something big to announce.
Click to expand...
Well it's going to take a couple months to manufacture shit so it probably will be the two Trails of Azure games and they'll be out by November.
 
Ah the trails of franchise, how I come to first love you and then come to find you extremely retarded and annoying.

I can understand why people like it for it's intimate attention to world building and characters. But the Ouroboros global conspiracy shit and weird magic bullshit that compels people to rape and pillage completely ruins it for me. Why the fuck couldn't this series just stay relatively mundane? I could totally go for three games of Estelle becoming a badass high-fantasy cop who stops crims who are bad people because humanity is full of assholes. That shit is interesting alone and absorbs me into this wonderful world. But instead the franchise has to have some dumb illuminate who is secretly behind everything wrong with the world and is full of retarded villain sues with retarded backstories and powers more fitting in a 80s cartoon like Captain Planet or He-Man or a shitty shonen anime like Naruto.
 
CisnaHet Scumale said:
Ah the trails of franchise, how I come to first love you and then come to find you extremely retarded and annoying.

I can understand why people like it for it's intimate attention to world building and characters. But the Ouroboros global conspiracy shit and weird magic bullshit that compels people to rape and pillage completely ruins it for me. Why the fuck couldn't this series just stay relatively mundane? I could totally go for three games of Estelle becoming a badass high-fantasy cop who stops crims who are bad people because humanity is full of assholes. That shit is interesting alone and absorbs me into this wonderful world. But instead the franchise has to have some dumb illuminate who is secretly behind everything wrong with the world and is full of retarded villain sues with retarded backstories and powers more fitting in a 80s cartoon like Captain Planet or He-Man or a shitty shonen anime like Naruto.
Click to expand...
Because you're supposed to go into dungeons and kill things.

The games have a phonebook of missable items and the primary thing you're supposed to be doing outside the main campaign is cataloguing the monsters, journal entries, and finding all the treasure chests while also completing side quests. That takes the most bulk of time. There's also a shitload of different builds you can do in Cold steel compared to Sky.

You can rush through the main campaign in 5 hours but it will take you 80-100 to do the other activities. It's way more exploration focused than Sky is.
 
Marissa Moira said:
Because you're supposed to go into dungeons and kill things.

The games have a phonebook of missable items and the primary thing you're supposed to be doing outside the main campaign is cataloguing the monsters, journal entries, and finding all the treasure chests while also completing side quests. That takes the most bulk of time. There's also a shitload of different builds you can do in Cold steel compared to Sky.

You can rush through the main campaign in 5 hours but it will take you 80-100 to do the other activities. It's way more exploration focused than Sky is.
Click to expand...
I think you completely misread my post.

Although I am intrigued that there is more customization in cold steel, but fuck if I'll play it for the story. I just wish they actually give these games a good sale. I'm not buying Sky 3rd or Cold Steel for anything less than 50% discount and yet the company never lower the price at this range.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back