Really interesting discussion. One thing I find fascinating is the cultural split after 9-11:
I remember a period of time where it was OK and acceptable to openly make fun of Muslims. Because of what they did everyone seemed on board. I remember watching something on comedy central and it was all like "a-la-la-la dynamite vest" jokes.
Then, suddenly, or maybe not so suddenly, depending where you lived, it was not so OK anymore. Not all Muslims are terrorists, it's bigoted to look down on other cultures, make fun of people's religion (except Christians), make fun of people's accent
What seemed to happen to me was like half the country (what would become the current day Right) was like, Fuck no, these guys attacked us and we reserve the right to mock them. And the Left, more urban/"coastal" population saying, no, that is not in fact OK, "muh religion of peace"
The left became anti-American, pro immigrant because of this - in essence, choosing the foreign enemy over American 'patriots,' and looking down on their conservative countrymen. This resentment built on top of already strained relations.
For a while I thought, if both sides can agree to hate Muslims again. Maybe we'll be OK. But then so much more shit got lumped into it and now I think we're just fucked.
The funny thing to me, is I know for a fact so many of these hardcore pro-immigrant leftists were also.openly mocking Islam in the early years, before it became morally wrong. They won't ever admit it and that makes them dishonest to me, and shows they have at large, reduced capacity for individual choice and will parrot whatever they think is morally superior.