- Joined
- Sep 7, 2016
While I know nobody here really plays Nancy Drew, and I'll probably get a few Autistic ratings for this, but...
I feel like Midnight in Salem isn't one of the better ones? But at the same time, it's not one of the absolute worst. Very dialogue heavy, and not enough puzzles would be my main complaint. It just feels... short, for what it costs. At least it's not Ransom of the Seven Ships, which was the worst one out of the ones I've played. I've also heard that Creature of Kapu Cave is really bad, but I haven't played it yet.
Kotaku actually had a decent article about the Nancy Drew games, "The Case of the Disappearing Nancy Drew Video Games". Shocking, I know.

An adjacent game(girl games or as they also can be called, "games sold in bookstores") would be The Legacy of Rosemond Hill, a well regarded horse training mystery adventure, made by DICE pre-Battlefield. I've been curious about that one but the ripped and cracked versions available on the internet all have trojans in them.