I played Sea of Thieves for the first time with a friend... and God, what an utterly pointless game. Thank goodness I was accessing it via a Steam family copy and didn't actually have to pay for it. Just starting up the game was nonsense of another stripe, I wanted to have a specific name but you can't just make a character you have to use your Xbox tag which for me has a big string of numbers which looks stupid so I figured since I never ever use my Xbox account I'd just change the gamertag to the name I wanted... and then Microsoft has the nerve the apparently charge you for doing so and fuck them if they thought I would ever do that. So shitty name, but I can at least make my pirate look how I want. lol. They seriously don't have a character creator and just make you shuffle randomized appearances until one is good enough. The game hasn't even started and I've been annoyed on several points.
Getting into the game and all the activities serve no purpose. The fact there is no progression at all and it's just an endless grind for cosmetics you don't care about, and even if you do you get the ones you want and are now out of incentive, is insane. I started the game with 50k money, got like 70k from one activity and that was all the customization I wanted done. From the start, I actually knew this was the case and never expected to play long, just a time or two since my friend was interested but there was one thing I thought would be fun and my primary motivation. I wanted to be in character as a crazy pirate and interact with other players. This was already heavily degraded by not having a pirate name but a stupid gamertag with numbers, but I still wanted to at least try. Turns out even that is harder than I thought.
The number of players on their little limited servers is already quite small, but damn if people are not interested in goofy interactions. Pretty much everybody just runs or tries to kill you no matter benign you are being. I can understand it in some cases if you've just put in a lot of work and don't want to lose your stuff... but at the same time your loot just buys cosmetics that won't be seen if you're not gonna interact outside of combat. I feel like they might be so paranoid because the game is so pointless ruining other people's day by sinking them is probably the only activity that really brings any entertainment as something emergent. After hours of trying, we managed to shipjack an anchored ship, sail it way off before they realized and interact with 2 of the 3 man crew who didn't want to leave their loot behind which they would have if they all teleported to their ship, including fighting a ghost ship with them on our ship, as the single guy who returned drove it back a long way. They didn't even realized we where the ones who shipjacked them until I said so as we were parting and giving them all our treasure because it was worthless to me. It took like 4 hours to have that interaction and that's like a 1 in 20 human encounter that isn't just wordless fight or flight and that felt like the best way to end my involvement with the game.
It's seriously like the scientifically designed least appealing game to me. I really thought goofy interactions was the primary point of the game, but with the larger playerbase not seeming too interested it's just grinding without the progression that makes grinding have purpose. I don't understand it's continued existence or why a sustainable number of people would want to play it in the slightest.