Alright, I want to give this show another shot and try not to sound like a sped.
The show is simply put, a half parody, and not some deep look into Harley’s mind. It is a show that is a joke on Batman, yet still retains some level of a coherent narrative. I honestly feel like the show is trying to replicate the success of say, Panty & Stocking, which was a raunchy, South Park lite, parody of magical girls, yet still held a genuine narrative. LEGO Batman is probably a more amp comparison though as many of the characterizations seemed ripped from that film such as Bane and King Shark being more comedic.
I feel that as a one season show, the series worked. It had an end goal of fixing the main character similar to that of LEGO Batman while going through a comedic rendition of the Batman mythos. The trajectory of Harley’s character from being Joker’s bitch, to needing to out due and prove herself to him, to Ivy finally getting it in her thick skull that she needs to stop seeking validation was handled pretty well, or at least, as well as a comedic take like LEGO. Season 2 started out promising, but fell apart due to there not being a real character arc to achieve. At first, it was fine as the premise of No Man’s Land, the popular story that inspired Arkham City, did most of the heavy lifting, but once they lost that it was directionless. Same goes for Season 3, as episodes were just random misadventures with little plot and the jokes getting progressively worse as the ship continued. A big contributor to the rot being the more widespread insertion of the writers’ fetishes. The end to season 3 gave me some hope though. They had a few really good episodes with interesting ideas, a stand out being the one in Bruce’s mind.
The show is an anomaly to me. It is not a completely hopeless series and has high points, but it feels like it never really knows what it wants and seeing the Valentines Day special only makes me think it is going to get bad again. I feel like if half the show was cut out, you would get a serviceable series, but as is, it is just a lot of lost potential. I will take the unpopular opinion of saying I enjoy the series, but I do wish it was better.