I think that initially it wouldn't have been so bad. His high school years would probably have been idyllic, galpals all fawning over him and full of awards and honors. I don't think that he'd have made one of them a girlfriend because that's not how Chris thought back then. Past that? He'd have his heartsweet, that's for certain. It'd probably have all gone wrong with Sarah- Chris would have wished for her to leave her boyfriend for him. Wes would probably have gone after her, but would have been driven off by Chris. I don't think he'd have wished death on Wes, but he'd probably have been maimed. I think that Chris would have lost interest in Sarah and pick up another girl, only for Sarah to follow him around like a stalker. Chris would probably say something like "I wish you'd drop dead" and she would. Bob would help him bury the body in the backyard, under the doghouse. He'd insist that Chris stay at home, just to keep him safe.
Lonely and scared, Chris would turn to Sonichu hard-core and then the inevitable discovery would come about. However what would make things different is that Sonichu and company would actually exist and Chris would send them out to kill the bullies, only for more to keep popping up because Sonichu would become the newest creepypasta to hit the net. Everyone would want to see if they'd really die if they shooped a dick onto Rosechu. The news would report on how people are suddenly dropping like flies of a mysterious electric shock. Chris would remain anonymous because he'd wish to not be found. Bob would watch horrified as his son keeps murdering people left and right with his creatures. Barb would go catatonic, talking about how Chris is such a good boy, a sweet boy. One day she'd snap and make a sudden move that the Sonichu would interpret as hostile and they'd tear her to pieces in front of a horrified Chris and Bob. Eventually Bob would take Chris out for a picnic and tell Chris how they were going to move away to a more remote place. He'd ask Chris to describe how he wanted the place to be decorated while he'd load a shotgun behind his back. Shaking with emotion, Bob would fire the gun into Chris's head in the hopes that it would make the Sonichu disappear. As he watched his son's twitching body, Bob gets evicerated by the Sonichu- ensuring that despite Chris's death, the horror will never end.