Actors/Plot:
While watching this movie, I realized I did not like the core plot of Wicked. There is really no driving force or motivation to the plot other than the disjointed events playing out on screen. Green girl is born, she has powers and is mocked, then she bids farewell to her sister who is going to Shizz (Academy?). These have no connective writing and just start happening, one event after the next. Elphaba is also annoying, as she is constantly talking down to people and hiding her true power level. The whole plot feels like a self insert OC being superior to everyone else, yet being shunned and mocked. It is a particular feminine approach to a "badass" character. A girl who is better than everyone and won't get the recognition she inherently deserves because everyone else is mean and stupid. Did she do anything difficult or meaningful to earn her badass status? No.
So this makes Elphaba unlikeable, she didn't earn her superiority and her condesencion is palpable. Her being a black actress and talking down to stupid whitey also gave a weird racial back sass component to the scenes. What is her motivation? She never states she even likes magic, she is just good at blowing things up when she's mad. A chinese woman with a heavy accent tells Elphaba she can be a great witch, and she suddenly falls in love with the idea via song. Makes more sense when written out, but is very sudden in the movie. Some early backstory or motivation would have helped.
Guhlinda, played by Ariana Grande, is my least favorite part of the movie. Ariana is aparently a huge fan of the musical, but she was wrong for the part. She always strikes me as full of herself and unpleasant, so I get the feeling she strong armed her way into the cast. Visually, she looks anorexic, and her skin is stretched across her face and neck. Mixed with her extremely dark eyes, pale skin, and unnaturally blonde hair, she looks like a skinwalker and scary to me. She is not the stereotypical popular girl that Glinda needs to be. She didn't work, and Glinda has a particular style of humor that a different actress would have done better.
There is a minor plot about animals losing their speech, and being repressed. My ears finally perked up as a plot was being developed, and something to drive the characters was introduced. It quickly ended and became a confusing musical again. I have to reiterate that this movie/musical has nothing driving the scenes. Without a story, you are left confused and have nothing to latch onto. Only after finishing the movie can you say "Oh, so that is what it's about!"
Visuals:
The movie had a gay and feminine look to it. Cinematography was flat and boring, similar to a Marvel or live action Disney movie. The extremely saturated colors and flat shots made it seem like a low effort kids movie to the eye. Extremely racially diverse, as these types of movies are. I noticed every group of people singing or dancing always had one of each race. So, the unnatural college brochure feeling permeated throughout each scene. Every man in the movie was feminine, even the male love interest. I can see how women feel watching an overly masculine movie, I felt the inverse and had no masculine presence to relate to. Everyone seemed alien and sassy or gay. The male love interest is introduced, then in his first song he starts doing homosexual gyrating and shit, I had to look away because it was way too much.
Singing:
The singing seemed "normal" to me. I have heard the musical numbers, and they are catchy. The most fun part of them is the dated instrumentation of their time. In the movie, they do faithful renditions that don't really differentiate themselves. I have no complaints about Elphaba's singing.
Ariana however is a misfire to me. She can hit the high notes, and often does to show off, but while singing at a high note she is incomprehensible. There were a few scenes where her high note was a lyric that overpowered the background singers and shrieked so loud you could not figure out what she was supposed to be singing. This made it a bit confusing.
None of the songs were moving or interesting to me, I hated some because there were just so, so many. I liked the "Defying Gravity" at the end, because it meant the movie was almost over.