Worst Redesigns

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
I'm replaying Plants vs. Zombies: Garden Warfare 2; that reminded me that EA/Popcap released a third entry: Battle for Neighborville.

View attachment 6304449

I like how the W has a silhouette of a zombie soldier. Reminds me of MW2's cover art.

Curious, I looked up Battle for Neighborville:

View attachment 6304459

Okay, that base logo is bland as hell. Where's the color? Where's the character?
Still fucking man about that one by the fucking way.
Every single redesign in this game was shit man it's insane
 
  • Like
Reactions: Juaco
Those players look like Sims in The Sims 3.

View attachment 5236422View attachment 5236423 View attachment 5236424

View attachment 5236419

View attachment 5236416

As if The Sims 4's logo wasn't bad enough, compared to the first 3 Sims games, the new rebranding for The Sims is even worse.

Gonna quote myself, as EA actually did another rebranding for The Sims for the 25th Anniversary, including introducing a new Sims Sans fontface:

1740857664223.webp1740857687157.webp

The game's main menu also got changed, and it now looks shockingly similar to Fortnite's main menu, with even more blatant advertising in your face:

1740857762692.jpeg 1740857773892.webp
 
WARNING: AUTISTIC SPERGING AHEAD

Stumbled across this while browsing. These are supposed to be fanmade redesigns of the pac-man ghosts but they look like shit to be honest.

One of the most noticeable problems is how you feel like your eyes are damn bleeding when you stare at it for too long. another problem is the weird shapes and eyes. It’s like it’s trying too hard to be different in a bad way. For some reason the blue one look like Sans from Undertale, The pink one looks like the artist was trying to draw it as a horny freak. The problem isn’t adding more “complex” details onto what can be considered blobs with eyes because I’m going to provide another example similar but works for different reasons:

As before, these renditions are more cartoonish and wildly different to the official ones, and the artist seemingly knows how to use colors properly. They lean much more into the “bedsheet” look of the OGs while adding distinct features that fit the ghosts’ characters individually if your autistic enough to know what parts of the franchise the artist pulled from, and it doesn’t make the average viewer cringe in comparison. The only questionable thing is the orange one with it’s tiny moobs but iirc the hard-reboot Ghostly Adventures depiction was a fat dumbass so I digress. iirc the blue one was also “chill” in the reboot but it’s done in a much better way then the eyebleeding Sans ghost. Anyways that’s the end of my MATI spergout.
It shouldn't be too hard to make designs that are simple but easy to differentiate:
1740858535931.png
Threw together these quick designs in MSPaint to try and simplify Example A, I have only the barest knowledge of Pacman so excuse me if I got anything wrong.
 
Threw together these quick designs in MSPaint to try and simplify Example A, I have only the barest knowledge of Pacman so excuse me if I got anything wrong.
And if this had a logo in the bottom right from some indie slop studio, there'd already be 4chan generals, tumblr posts and subforums created to goon about "Chonko Splongo" or whatever, simply from the fact it's not from a big studio cause contrarians love that shit.

Also that's literally Sonic I just realized.
 
I saw another live action HTTYD trailer and it made me MATI.
View attachment 7020561View attachment 7020532View attachment 7020533View attachment 7020534

Every single movie after the first dumbs down Toothless' design slightly. He gets slightly blockier, slightly lumpier, slightly grayer, even his pupils get slightly more squarish. In the first movie he was sleek, with a bluish black color and subtle camo markings, now he's a solid gray potato of a dragon.

And that's not even getting into the live action version. That thing looks like a frog with extra chromosomes.
Regarding the animation, consider it the price of dragon gets domesticated. It gets to look more dull the more time it get to spend with a human.
And live action? I don't think I said there before but, you can't simply transfer cartoonish designs into realistic look.
 
Regarding the animation, consider it the price of dragon gets domesticated. It gets to look more dull the more time it get to spend with a human.
And live action? I don't think I said there before but, you can't simply transfer cartoonish designs into realistic look.
Domestication and body changes happen over generations, not to a single animal, especially not in just 6 years, which is apparently how long Hiccup was with Toothless. I get that he'd be affected, but not to the point that his skull structure changes.

About the live action thing, Toothless' design never struck me as too cartoonish in the animated movie, his face is pretty similar to that of geckos and axolotls. They didn't need to change the proportions, just the textures. I found an edit by a furfag (yeah, I know) that looks quite a bit better:
Furfag Redesigns Toothless.png
At least he managed to be the least butchered of all the dragons in the original.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Catboi
And another Worst Korean airline has gone the minimalist route with their logo, and the font change is a downgrade too:

Old:
1745031976958.webp
They probably had to change it because that stylized O looks too close to the Pepsi logo.

Thread tax: Yahoo!

Old:
1745207347238.webp

New:

1745207381855.webp

I like the purple, but the font choice is stale.
 
The 2006 Xbox 360 hit, Gears of War, is getting another remaster entitled Reloaded for its 20th anniversary.

I do not like the new box art redesign.

Here's the original:

1746648998974.webp1746649057932.webp



And here's the (presumably) new box art for the remaster:

1746649210396.webp

The center character, Marcus Fenix, looks off. Almost like the whole thing was AI generated.
 
The 2006 Xbox 360 hit, Gears of War, is getting another remaster entitled Reloaded for its 20th anniversary.

I do not like the new box art redesign.

Here's the original:

View attachment 7331578View attachment 7331583



And here's the (presumably) new box art for the remaster:

View attachment 7331601

The center character, Marcus Fenix, looks off. Almost like the whole thing was AI generated.
It’s because the OG made fenix’s colors light and brighter, nuboxart blends him too much with the background
 
Ratchet & Clank (Future) for the PS3. There were three games with the Future tagline to represent a saga for the franchise.

1748230437924.webp

However, in European countries, they dropped the Future, presumably because of translation issues.

1748230536027.webp

It looks incomplete without the Future in the title. Again, the "future" is supposed to represent another level of storytelling for the franchise. A soft reboot of sorts.
 
Kind of retarded because none of those were cultures that were in the US. why would there be am Arabs team?
The link above the image explains the artistic comparison if it was used for other ethnicities.

Thread tax: Spongebob SquarePants's art direction has been getting uglier with each iteration.

First season:

1753052323436.webp

I think this is season 7 or 8:

1753052395854.webp

Wow, that's ugly.
 
Some people just won't be happy until the world is dull and grey.
Thanks for reminding me that there was a Rainbow Brite reboot in 2015.

There's so much about that I could sperg about (in particular how it basically character assassinates Rainbow herself) but let's talk about her villains, Murky and Lurky:

Murky and Lurky - original.webp

Murky kinda looks like an evil Mario... and it sorta fits. These two had an almost Pinky and the Brain dynamic before P&tB was a thing.

Anyway, here's how Murky looks in the 2015 version:

Murky - modern.webp

YIKES! This guy looks like a bootleg version of Dr. Cortex from Crash Bandicoot more than anything!

And if you're curious what they did to Lurky...

Lurky - new.webp

.... This is just so stupid looking I'm almost convinced it was submitted as a joke and they decided to run with it.
 
Back