- Joined
- Apr 13, 2021
Was reading fat ricks twitter and saw this shit:
I really loved The Expanse shame about them being retarded
I really loved The Expanse shame about them being retarded
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
I know I shill for them a lot... but tell them to give a look at Baen Books. The last trad publisher not only dedicated to classic scifi and fantasy, but openly and proudly has refused to bow at the alter of wokeness as the other trad publishers have done. And several of their authors, most famously Larry Correia have been openly combating this rising tide for years.
Plus, they put out damned good stuff. Are apparently shit at marketing it though given how often I see the old "there are no right wing publishers" or "they don't make books for boys" chestnuts get trotted out.
I can't remember the last time I saw an ad for a book from any publisher, and I read all the time. Then again, I haven't turned on my television in half a decade and use adblockers when I browse the web, so that's not that surprising.
Generally when I'm looking for something new to read, I pick a series at random that I enjoyed, go to wherever that fandom is, and ask "hey what else do you guys like reading" and go from there.
So you're saying they won't read a book with a female protagonist? And how is a focus on female readers a bad thing if they're the only ones buying the books? I'm not the biggest fans of YA but I know why it's so popular and I can't blame a publisher for focusing on readers that will actually buy a book from them over those that won't.I've known a number of young male readers who'd like to read more but they don't and their reasons are usually some mixture of the following when it concerns what they think is being 'pushed':
Inevitably, it's like they settle on eating from one of those troughs but everything they say is often appended with how they want something better or less immature or deeper without getting into what I imagine some would call the "art is revolution" SFWA crowd. And as someone in the industry, hell, I agree with these kids. I think there's a lot of people out there who want to read, they just don't want to read what's being thrust in their faces when it's overhyped diversity quota stuff from the industry or lowest common denominator algo junk from overseas or Amazon. And it's not just men, I know plenty of women who find the YA genre just a joke these days.
- They don't want to read YA due to its focus on female protagonists and female readers
- They don't want to read Sanderson much as they got bored with his work after one or two books
- They don't want to read translated Eastern stuff, whether manga or light novels
- They don't want to trawl through Amazon's wasteland of gamelit and harem and harem gamelit for what gems might be there
Honestly, it sounds like American trad publishers need to learn more how the Japanese and Koreans publishers work. If you think the anime and manga stuffs are only marketed to otaku or nerds, you're wrong. More and more their advertising are geared towards the normies market, hence why they spend a lot of money for advertising in public spaces like train station or in the train itself.Generally, that's because so much of the advertising budget for publishers is spent advertising INTERNALLY, not EXTERNALLY - ie, Tor gets a bunch of lefty bloggers to simp for their latest woke garbage fire, lots of ads for genre magazines and the like. Hell, Baen is once again an odd duck because occasionally you'll see advertisements for their books in gun magazines and military news outlets. That's the closest thing any trad publisher does for external marketing outside of existing fandom. No small thing when you remember Baen doesn't have a full press and marketing team in the Flatiron Building like Tor does, so no wonder they occasionally have to think outside the box.
I keep saying one of the trad publishers... and lets be real, that probably means Baen or one of the larger indies... needs to make a hard push towards groups like gamers, the Fandom Menace types, hell, even right wing news outlets. All the people burnt by the fact so much of pop culture is more interested in lefty messaging than escapism and fun, or visions of the future. I wouldn't even know where to begin - there's a reason I work in editorial and not marketing - but one thing I desperately wish I could sell my own publisher on is you are never going to outdo Tor at being Tor. You don't need 5-7 trad publishers all selling various shades of the same damned product, be different, stand out, focus on different demos and markets for crying out loud, there are only so many lonely cat ladies and balding virgins you can sell your quirky Joss Whedon-esque fanfic tier light scifi where every other character is gay whom you can sell six versions of the same book to.
Of course, part of that needs to be that crowd of people sick of lefty control over pop culture needs to actually put up or shut up, and support the authors and publishers who don't hate them. Tor can count on childless librarians around the country to pad their sales numbers, SFWA can snap their fingers and have a digital lynch mob. So far, right wingers are great about kvetching on the Daily Wire or making angry Star Wars videos, but shitty about say, pre-ordering the new book Timothy Zahn took that Disney contract so he could afford to write it, or backing Larry Correia up when lefty loons once again try to force a convention to not invite him as a guest, instead of the usual doom and gloom over how everything sucks.
"I wish there was non loony lefty pop culture." Wish granted, it exists and has existed for years. People are just utter shit at supporting it.
They sure as hell will pay to see the next Marvel movie though. Even if it means putting money in the pockets of a corporation literally working toward castrating your kids.
OMG, bloggers are almost like the be-and-end-all in YA/SpecFic marketing now , and there are the companies that will organise book tours with curated "Bookstagram" bloggers who have big followers. It becomes a bit of a circle jerk as ... I suspect ... acquisitions are being made as to what will appeal most to Mary Jo Instablogger, and Mary Jo Instablogger wants to keep getting ARC's so she will pretend to like every milquetoast book that gets sent to her by Payola Book Tours on behalf of Rando Publisher even if they are shit. And so the cyclic death spiral continues.Generally, that's because so much of the advertising budget for publishers is spent advertising INTERNALLY, not EXTERNALLY - ie, Tor gets a bunch of lefty bloggers to simp for their latest woke garbage fire, lots of ads for genre magazines and the like. Hell, Baen is once again an odd duck because occasionally you'll see advertisements for their books in gun magazines and military news outlets. That's the closest thing any trad publisher does for external marketing outside of existing fandom. No small thing when you remember Baen doesn't have a full press and marketing team in the Flatiron Building like Tor does, so no wonder they occasionally have to think outside the box.
I keep saying one of the trad publishers... and lets be real, that probably means Baen or one of the larger indies... needs to make a hard push towards groups like gamers, the Fandom Menace types, hell, even right wing news outlets. All the people burnt by the fact so much of pop culture is more interested in lefty messaging than escapism and fun, or visions of the future. I wouldn't even know where to begin - there's a reason I work in editorial and not marketing - but one thing I desperately wish I could sell my own publisher on is you are never going to outdo Tor at being Tor. You don't need 5-7 trad publishers all selling various shades of the same damned product, be different, stand out, focus on different demos and markets for crying out loud, there are only so many lonely cat ladies and balding virgins you can sell your quirky Joss Whedon-esque fanfic tier light scifi where every other character is gay whom you can sell six versions of the same book to.
Of course, part of that needs to be that crowd of people sick of lefty control over pop culture needs to actually put up or shut up, and support the authors and publishers who don't hate them. Tor can count on childless librarians around the country to pad their sales numbers, SFWA can snap their fingers and have a digital lynch mob. So far, right wingers are great about kvetching on the Daily Wire or making angry Star Wars videos, but shitty about say, pre-ordering the new book Timothy Zahn took that Disney contract so he could afford to write it, or backing Larry Correia up when lefty loons once again try to force a convention to not invite him as a guest, instead of the usual doom and gloom over how everything sucks.
"I wish there was non loony lefty pop culture." Wish granted, it exists and has existed for years. People are just utter shit at supporting it.
They sure as hell will pay to see the next Marvel movie though. Even if it means putting money in the pockets of a corporation literally working toward castrating your kids.
Tell me more or point me to a blog post, senpai.Emp1re 0f The Vamp1re kerfuffle
Yeah the only right-wing "literary" guy I read is Vox Day and his ego is really out of control. For a guy who has multiple things going on which are Good For The Right he sure doesn't know how to focus on them.On the lefty control: Yeah I've noticed that right-leaning fans are not as loudly supportive. The noisy people in right-leaning fandom who could mobilise large amounts of fans also dance with Lolcow Behaviour a little too intimately - public slapfights are exhausting. The Puppy saga was exhausting.
This reminds me of when I see those dumb romance novels about an "idle rich" guy who's fabulously wealthy but never has to devote any - you know - time to work at it and can focus on the self-insert heroine. I mean you want someone with a following, which means they need to do something to grab people's attention. But then any effort made to get attention is "exhausting" and "lolcowish".On the lefty control: Yeah I've noticed that right-leaning fans are not as loudly supportive. The noisy people in right-leaning fandom who could mobilise large amounts of fans also dance with Lolcow Behaviour a little too intimately - public slapfights are exhausting. The Puppy saga was exhausting. But you'll be talking to people quietly and they'll discuss how they like certain Librorum Prohibitorum books that you'd never see added to the Best Of lists.
Wait, that "genre" is also big in the west? Fuck me, that's literally half of the web novels in my language, with the readers being composed only of lonely women or moms with incredibly rabid toxicity. Never knew that kind of thing is also popular elsewhereThis reminds me of when I see those dumb romance novels about an "idle rich" guy who's fabulously wealthy but never has to devote any - you know - time to work at it and can focus on the self-insert heroine. I mean you want someone with a following, which means they need to do something to grab people's attention. But then any effort made to get attention is "exhausting" and "lolcowish".
You may as well say that what we are in need of is some dry water.
Yep. It's why Harlequin novels and 50 shades of gray are so popular among sexually frustrated soccer moms in America. Sexually frustrated middle aged women love fortune 500 hunks that do nothing so he can spend all his time being rapey towards the self-insert heroine.Wait, that "genre" is also big in the west? Fuck me, that's literally half of the web novels in my language, with the readers being composed only of lonely women or moms with incredibly rabid toxicity. Never knew that kind of thing is also popular elsewhere
"Yes all women."Wait, that "genre" is also big in the west? Fuck me, that's literally half of the web novels in my language, with the readers being composed only of lonely women or moms with incredibly rabid toxicity. Never knew that kind of thing is also popular elsewhere
I have had the luck NOT to meet him as I was preoccupied with IRL shit when he made his entry into the community, but as much as I liked the vampire book (it was better than the other freebie I got - a boring fantasy brick part seven) I have sadly identified the man as a douche-canoe of the highest order. What is the reason for such degeneracy?Empire of the Vampire, huh. I've had the misfortune of meeting Jay Kristoff in the flesh a few times over the years and that guy is exactly the kind of person you might think he is based on his books. Just the most boredom inducing guy you might meet, and with zero sense of humor on top of that. He's also rather lucky that he got his first book out there so early. You know, the book where he bragged about doing his East Asian research by watching anime and eating pocky. If only cancel culture had gotten off the ground a few years earlier...
Tell me more or point me to a blog post, senpai.
To be fair the people I'm referring to actually have individual threads in the Lolcow section so its not entirely a personal observation!I mean you want someone with a following, which means they need to do something to grab people's attention. But then any effort made to get attention is "exhausting" and "lolcowish".
Sometimes authors write books.Empire of the Vampire
Yeah and since it's trash fiction you don't even have to justify the title. What a scam, wish I'd thought of it. Actually I think of titles all the time I'm just too lazy to write novels. You can say that about Jay Kristoff - at least he has work ethic. Plus it sounds like his detractors are even worse than him so you know what I'm starting to like the guy. Still won't read his books, fuck vampires.Sometimes authors write books.
Sometimes titles write books.
OMG, bloggers are almost like the be-and-end-all in YA/SpecFic marketing now , and there are the companies that will organise book tours with curated "Bookstagram" bloggers who have big followers. It becomes a bit of a circle jerk as ... I suspect ... acquisitions are being made as to what will appeal most to Mary Jo Instablogger, and Mary Jo Instablogger wants to keep getting ARC's so she will pretend to like every milquetoast book that gets sent to her by Payola Book Tours on behalf of Rando Publisher even if they are shit. And so the cyclic death spiral continues.
This is I believe adjacent how the Emp1re 0f The Vamp1re kerfuffle came to pass last year - this book had FIVE advanced reader copy editions. These volumes are ONLY for bloggers and reviewers. Many books don't even get a physical ARC. Every author in Christendom was pissed.
(It's a bit of a shame that the as I enjoyed EOTV - I got a free copy - but my god St Martins Press pushed the beejesus out of it, and the author didn't have a special gender or ethnicity to use as a shield. The same publisher/imprint does Lindsay Ellis' book too, big difference in the marketing push there....)
On the lefty control: Yeah I've noticed that right-leaning fans are not as loudly supportive. The noisy people in right-leaning fandom who could mobilise large amounts of fans also dance with Lolcow Behaviour a little too intimately - public slapfights are exhausting. The Puppy saga was exhausting. But you'll be talking to people quietly and they'll discuss how they like certain Librorum Prohibitorum books that you'd never see added to the Best Of lists.
Tell me more or point me to a blog post, senpai.
Yeah the only right-wing "literary" guy I read is Vox Day and his ego is really out of control. For a guy who has multiple things going on which are Good For The Right he sure doesn't know how to focus on them.
This reminds me of when I see those dumb romance novels about an "idle rich" guy who's fabulously wealthy but never has to devote any - you know - time to work at it and can focus on the self-insert heroine. I mean you want someone with a following, which means they need to do something to grab people's attention. But then any effort made to get attention is "exhausting" and "lolcowish".
You may as well say that what we are in need of is some dry water.
Wait, that "genre" is also big in the west? Fuck me, that's literally half of the web novels in my language, with the readers being composed only of lonely women or moms with incredibly rabid toxicity. Never knew that kind of thing is also popular elsewhere
Yep. It's why Harlequin novels and 50 shades of gray are so popular among sexually frustrated soccer moms in America. Sexually frustrated middle aged women love fortune 500 hunks that do nothing so he can spend all his time being rapey towards the self-insert heroine.
Empire of the Vampire, huh. I've had the misfortune of meeting Jay Kristoff in the flesh a few times over the years and that guy is exactly the kind of person you might think he is based on his books. Just the most boredom inducing guy you might meet, and with zero sense of humor on top of that. He's also rather lucky that he got his first book out there so early. You know, the book where he bragged about doing his East Asian research by watching anime and eating pocky. If only cancel culture had gotten off the ground a few years earlier...
I have had the luck NOT to meet him as I was preoccupied with IRL shit when he made his entry into the community, but as much as I liked the vampire book (it was better than the other freebie I got - a boring fantasy brick part seven) I have sadly identified the man as a douche-canoe of the highest order. What is the reason for such degeneracy?
ARC GATE: (longer than I expected)
It all began in 2012 with the infamous "Pocky Research" interview...
View attachment 3157058
So obviously this was not the end of it, but I can't be bothered listing sins as they're very boring.
As for ARC-Gate: A lot has been memory-holed but:
https://file770.com/the-weaponization-of-the-arc
Firstly the caveat being that Kristoff would have had no input in to the marketing side of this, but showed possibly a supreme lack of grace as most writers were not getting an ARC - particularly in 2021, Year of Our Lord Covid
View attachment 3157034
The thing played out a lot on Twitter, but a lot of links and main players are hard to find now. But it was pretty huge and there would have been many sweaty meetings in the publishing office about how to handle the bad press. It was so bad I've not seen a multi-ARC strategy by a publisher since.
After that, gloves were off. .
He got a roasting on the Mary Sue for having a sook about his book not being nominated for the 2021 Goodreads awards, always a winning strategy
Basically its a combo of audience mismanagement, edgelord behaviour from a prior decade and brand creep. If JK was a purely adult fiction writer things would not have been so HEATED but he's hitched his wagon to Young Adult Fiction and what 80 pages of this thread has shown us, YA is not a thing to be trifled with.
You should start a thread about it. I don't read much fiction. I'd love to read more. It's hard to find the good stuff.there are some genuinely great rightwing authors out there, by the dozens
I don't know who I dislike more, the douchebag edgelord or the article author for touting how "diverse" the author list is and then writing it's "comprised mainly of women authors" a few lines later. No one should be surprised, the population of Goodreads is mainly teen girls and 30-something femcels, so of course they'll nominate mostly female authors... but I still laughed. Not as much as I laughed at the linked article about how merit and colorblindness are code words for white supremacy, though.