"Zero Punctuation" and "Dev Diary" by Ben "Yahtzee" Croshaw - The only thing worth watching on The Escapist

  • Want to keep track of this thread?
    Accounts can bookmark posts, watch threads for updates, and jump back to where you stopped reading.
    Create account
Best, worst and blandest of 2025 is up:

BEST
5. Promise Mascot Agency
4. The Rogue Prince of Persia
3. Blue Prince
2. Hades II
1. The Alters

BLANDEST
5. Metroid Prime 4: Beyond
4. Doom: The Dark Ages
3. Little Nightmares III
2. Assassin's Creed: Shadows
1. Borderlands 4

WORST
5. Tales of the Shire: A The Lord of the Rings Game
4. Split Fiction
3. Vampire: The Masquerade – Bloodlines 2
2. Call of Duty: Black Ops 7
1. MindsEye

HONORABLE MENTIONS (from credits):

Expedition 33 was excluded because it already won a lot at the game awards.
Games I have heard of: 7
Games I hadn't heard of: 8, including his #1 best, and #1 worst
Games I actually played: 0
Games on that list that sounded intriguing: 0

I think 2025 was the first year I didn't bother watching a single one of Yahtzee's videos.
 
It's cute that he's still seething about Ghosts 12 years later. Funny how he is surprised by Alex Mason living in a cabin when you see this in BO2(the game this is supposed to be a remake of) about half an hour in, after the first mission or so. Then again, that would require him to actually play the game, as you recall his entire BO2 review was just him crying about the poor, oppressed brown people and how racist whites are. He didn't even mention Menendez appearing in this game, when he was also the big bad of BO2, so it's telling how little he actually remembers about either game.

If he could just say the franchise is stale? That'd be fine, but, yeah, he has to step in and gently "remind" you that he is also a lot more morally pure than you because he gets enraged when simulated digital people get abused in a game where the objective is to SHOOT THE OPPOSITION.

The maxim goes like "find a job you love and you'll never work for the rest of your life," but seeing all the burnout and bullshit happening with streamers, musicians, and other 'creatives' (liberal usage of the term, I know) makes me never wanna mix business with pleasure ever. No matter how much you love something, it can become a chore if you're forced to do it over and over again to keep the lights on.
I think the entire YouTube ecosystem is suffering from this right now... massive concurrent burnout.

Every streamer and content creator over time trends towards their niche interests and gets louder and more in-your-face to try and keep their initial hype up.

The end result? Dozens of channels I used to watch that I don't anymore because I know exactly what they're going to say, they add nothing of value.

This guy's gonna bash woke Disney, and THIS one is gonna blame Trump, and THIS one is gonna say the NFL officiating sucks and is rigged and on and on and on, when their channels should be talking about a whole lot more if they really like what they say they like.

And as they have all reduced themselves to one, singular, drumbeat that they play over and over and over again. And to ensure theirs stands out in a sea of similar beating drums? They turn up the inflamatory language.

Every single suggested vid on my feed now features unappealing AI slop title pages and overly-serious and blackpill titles - "X" Cooked! "X" is over! "X" ruins industry forever! Just stop it.

I look down my list of subscribes and can only think, for every singe one, "Man, I remember when I looked forward to them, now they just take up space between me and what I want to see"
 
Every single suggested vid on my feed now features unappealing AI slop title pages and overly-serious and blackpill titles - "X" Cooked! "X" is over! "X" ruins industry forever! Just stop it.
2024 December I noticed how much drudgery it was and deleted like 90% of my you tube subscriptions through external software. I keep forgetting ben even exists anymore.
>"X" Cooked!
They are even doing this with religious debate channels now. Even using AI to make fake pictures of the people involved.
I guess the opposite of love really is apathy.
 
If he could just say the franchise is stale? That'd be fine, but, yeah, he has to step in and gently "remind" you that he is also a lot more morally pure than you because he gets enraged when simulated digital people get abused in a game where the objective is to SHOOT THE OPPOSITION.
What Yahtzee fails to recall about the Call of Duty franchise is that it was not the US government or the white man who destabilized the Middle East, but 50 Cent, in his 50 Cent Blood on the Sand Review.

Also, pretty wild to re-watch some of his really old stuff, because I'm pretty sure, "Maybe if the world was a little less prejudiced and a little more accepting then people might have see that we all have the potential to be so much more, and then we could all work together to build a better world for everyone! Not that they'd know anything about work, the lazy nig--" would no longer fly.
 
How can someone this old, whose job it is to play video games, be so bad at video games?
There's a lot of evidence in this thread, derived from his older videos, that he isn't good at video games, not even easier ones, and some of the games he claims he finished were watched on YouTube instead.

It shouldn't be a surprise he gravitates towards games like Euro Truck Simulator, Undertale, and Night in the Woods.
 
How can someone this old, whose job it is to play video games, be so bad at video games?
Like game journos he cared more about talking about writing in games than the small thing called "gameplay", so he never wanted to improve and stayed bad, with the added age and social media dependency probably making him even worse than he was when he started.
 
He didn't review that one. I don't actually think he'd like it.

When I accidentally parachuted into a crevice I couldn't escape from because there's no fucking jump button, I was confronted by yet another opportunity for player choice: I could choose to fast-travel somewhere and start the journey again, or I could quit and play Night in the Woods instead. Have you played Night in the Woods? It's this indie game about a cat girl who drops out of college and comes back to her hometown to find some things changed and some things the same, and there's an undercurrent of lurking intrigue. It reminded me of Gone Home somewhat, 'cos it eschews core gameplay in favor of storytelling; it takes a while to figure out what it's going for, and the supernatural horror stuff feels a bit at odds with the rest of the overall tone, but I respect the game for drawing a line under itself design-wise and not getting bogged down shoving in standard gameplay bullshit until it ultimately forgets to add anything new and the bullshit is all there is.

So in summary, Night in the Woods is a solid "Worth Checking Out!" if strong writing is enough to make you forgive the very slow pacing and gameplay taking a back seat. Wait, was I talking about something else? Ah, it can't have been important.

Bonus points for venerating Gone Homo like a true game journoscum would
source
 
Bonus points for venerating Gone Homo like a true game journoscum would
source
Huh. Well, that is interesting.
I mean... NitW isn't just "by the numbers" cartilage that scoots by without a word. NitW is violently stupid and self-absorbed.
Keep in mind that this is the game where the protagonist assaults someone "because we're all literally just shapes and atoms" and this is taken completely seriously.
 
I don't think he ever was particularly good at any video games, even when he was young. He's a writer who found a niche that would allow him to not just be stuck in the endless torrent of Kindle trash.
He also thinks that his repertoire of mediocre point-and-click adventure games qualifies him to speak as a game developer in his criticism, when he really doesn't seem to get game design in other genres.
 
He also thinks that his repertoire of mediocre point-and-click adventure games qualifies him to speak as a game developer in his criticism, when he really doesn't seem to get game design in other genres.
Even Yahtzee barely remembers Five Days a Fedora or whatever. I'm sure he'll bitch about it being "problematic" in one way or another.
 
He also thinks that his repertoire of mediocre point-and-click adventure games qualifies him to speak as a game developer in his criticism, when he really doesn't seem to get game design in other genres.
His video about AAA really exemplified how out of touch he is. Actual game devs have people they work with, financial and time limits, and bank massive amount of their lives on the game breaking even. Not a wife that funds your life.

His knowledge of video game development is elementary, as in literal elementary school children have developed games of the same technological level as he did.
 
Keep in mind that this is the game where the protagonist assaults someone "because we're all literally just shapes and atoms" and this is taken completely seriously.
No, she assaulted someone because she was having a psychotic break and imagined the person as just shapes.
 
No, she assaulted someone because she was having a psychotic break and imagined the person as just shapes.
Do you know why I beat down Andy Cullen 6 years ago? I was playing this video game. You were like dating ghosts or something. And I was really into it. Played it like 24-7. Until this one afternoon, and suddenly, like, something broke. It was just like... pixels. the characters onscreen… I felt like I knew them; they weren't people anymore. They were just shapes. And their lines were just things someone had written: they never existed, they never had feelings. They never would exist, either. And it felt so sad, like I’d just lost these real people, and this whole thing we had, it was just… me. Alone. And like that realization like dumped out of the screen and into real life went outside and the tree out front, I looked at it every day, it was like a friend outside the window. Now it was just a thing... just a thing that was there, growing and eating and just being there, like all the stuff I felt about the tree was just in my head, and there was some guy walking by, and he was just shapes, just like this moving bulk of... stuff. And I cried, because nothing was there for me anymore. It was all just stuff. Stuff in the universe, just... dead.
...
And the next day was that softball game, and Andy was the pitcher when I was up, and he was just shapes too; just lines someone wrote, like nothing in there. And I was so scared and angry and just... I dunno. Before I knew it I was on top of him, smashing his face in with the bat; just shapes, red shapes all over the grass. After it happened they made me go to therapy, with Dr. Hank, and he made me start a journal... he kinda just said it would help to be able to get my thoughts down. But since this whole thing happened, when I'm alone in a new place, it's all shapes, like back at the softball game. I was doing fine at college for a while, but I couldn't make friends, I was just afraid of being outside or around people alone. And there was this statue of like the founder of something. A really shitty statue, like all rusty metal, and it was these shapes, and he was pointing down at me, and I was so... scared... I didn't leave my dorm room, I either didn't eat or I ate entire pizzas at once. I downed cough syrup just to sleep all the time, and finally I got up the courage to leave. And I came home. Where everything was fine. Where I knew everyone, and it wasn't just... dead shapes. Watching me. Something broke. In my head. In my life.
I'm going to make you look in the mirror and have a long segment where you pick parts of your body to whine about.
 
That's not the point. The point is that the actual dialogue is just so stupidly written.
How is anyone supposed to relate to this big obnoxious baby?
I don't see where's she's being obnoxious? Like in the context of the game, she basically explains to her friend why she beat up that kid when she was six or why she left college.
 
Back
Top Bottom