Trump would have botched it just as badly, because you know it's not as if he's actually doing logistics or anything himself, and neither is Biden, but the buck stops there and they take the blame.
The biggest difference is Trump's withdrawal plan was drawn up by people who had been in the region and knew what they were doing.
Biden's was drawn up by time punching dick suckers who figured that the Taliban would never dare roll on the US Army.
Guess which one was shit.
You could say the DELAYS from Biden on withdrawal made it more difficult due to the Taliban's advances, but on the flip side of the coin, that gave them even more time to prepare and do things right.
Except they DIDN'T prepare. They didn't destroy the vehicles properly, they didn't start the evacs and cancelled the existing evacs. They also abandoned the major air force base that was supposed to be used under the Trump plan to move out personnel and critical equipment because Milley and the other authors were careerist dick polishers with less tactical and strategic sense than a PFC with a headwound.
It gave them the time but THEY DIDN'T USE IT.
Regardless, we (USA) don't seem to be able to pull these withdrawals off without major fuck-ups. It would be nice if someone with military service could shed some light on this as to why.
We've been able to pull off some major withdrawals, but they went so smoothly that they aren't really even noticed.
But when you fuck up a withdrawal, you fuck it up big time.
The Biden Admin, by believing that the Taliban would go along with their photo-op plans of a September 11th withdrawal WITHOUT CONSULTING THE TALIBAN, fucked up from the get-go.
They didn't take the time to properly destroy classified documents and hardware.
They didn't blow in place or destroy equipment.
They didn't evac people out until the last fucking minute.
They closed their air force base that could have run C5's 24/7 and had a secure perimeter.
They stopped doing Predator drone overwatch on the Taliban advances.
They pulled the CIA and DIA observers from the Afghan army.
They were SHOCKED PIKACHU when the Afghan Army went "Fuck this shit"
In reality, the Biden Administration, just to spite Trump and the previous authors of the withdrawal, junked the plan then sat on their asses smugly thinking that the Taliban would let them have a Sept-11 pullout for the optics just because it was what they wanted.
The Biden Admin's plan went BEYOND criminal negligence and straight into willful retardation.
If you had put in that kind of plan at PLDC, which is where they train the E4 Mafia, you would have been doing pushups in the nearest puddle while the other trainees pissed on your legs.
Because it was the most fucked up faggoty plan ever.
It was WORSE than the Vietnam one.