Thé vast majority of trans crimes are hoaxes or vastly exaggerated, anti-trans and homophobes are far more antisocial and still commit more crimes than any trans person does.
There's a strong pressure in mainstream media to suppress reports of trans crimes.
Like for example, with the Wi Spa incident, you had highly respected, mainstream media outlets outright calling it a hoax. Then, of course, when it was confirmed accurate, there was no response from them, no correction. They just went silent.
By the data, trans people commit sex crimes much more often than cis people. So for example, 48% of federal inmates who identify as trans are sex offenders. This is much higher than the 4.7% baseline number for the total population.
The idea of Trans people literally just coming to existence in the 20th century is ludicrous, societies knowledge of its existence would have have been made more mainstream then certainly, due to the sexual revolution of the 60s and societies slow but steady lean towards tolerance towards LGBT people by the end of the 1900’s. But it doesn’t mean that there were no trans people in history before 1900 and gender dysphoria existed as a condition from then on.
No, mental illnesses and mindsets have existed all throughout history, our acknowledgment of their existence emerges only when science progresses and cultural forces dictate our perceptions of what ideology are acceptable and accessible through the changing social standards of each period in history. Our accepting or ignorance of a condition has no bearing in its existence. Just because something hasn’t been proven to yet exist doesn’t mean it doesn’t, there are untold millions of things humans haven’t discovered about the world yet Just we don’t know of their existence doesn’t mean they don’t exist. It is just simply currently out of our grasp. Just like transpeople.
Just because we didn’t know or understand what they were didn’t mean they hadn’t existed up until when we discovered them. Same for any illness or scientific discovery throughout history, use your brain please and thing about how long modern society has been around for , this is a far more deep and long running social phenomenon than you may have previously thought to be.
No, again, transgenderism is a modern concept. It's an ideological belief.
It's like saying that schizos who believe they're Napoleon is an ancient phenomena, and we just didn't notice until Napoleon Bonaparte came along.
It's important to distinguish what transgenderism actually is. Transgenderism isn't gender non-conformity. A woman wearing men's clothes isn't trans. It's not just crossdressing or homosexuality. It's a more profound belief, and that belief is a modern invention, not some kind of psychological symptom like nervous tics.
It's specifically an ideological belief that man/woman refer to a nebulous gender identity and this gender identity is factually true, not a spiritual concept or anything of that nature.
Past cultures had people who didn't fit into social gender roles, but they never had this kind of literalism where they are factually the other sex in some sense. That kind of literalism is a modern concept, in the same way that the Scientology concept of a thetan is a modern concept. We also haven't always had Scientology.
If you want to talk about gender dysphoria, that might've had a longer history that's worth discussing, but that's not the same thing as transgenderism. (Although to be honest, gender dysphoria also seems to be a culture bound phenomenon, in the same way that modern western culture exacerbates female insecurity and thus we have a much higher rate of psychological issues like anorexia and bulemia than they did in, say, the 1800's.)
