I want to read it. Join me in posting autistically long diatribes that are only on topic because a vtuber mentioned it.
I don't listen to or like 99% of rap, so most of Calli's stuff never gets listened to more than once by me, but I have to say I disagree completely with this kind of thing. How is that legitimate criticism in any meaningful way? Criticism like that is based solely on feelings without any substance to prove that it's true. He's just stating his feelings as a fact and hoping people won't give it one iota of thought even if they disagree with him. When exactly do the lyrics transition from 'cringe and edgy' to 'fun and genuine'? Can he prove it to me? No, you can never know because those are just feelings you get and everyone experiences them in differing ways. Just to be clear I also feel this way about her stuff, even as Mori, but I could never defend my position as a legit criticism because it means nothing to anyone but me, or people that have similar taste as me and just inherently trust my judgement, but even then it certainly wouldn't be useful criticism. I'd say that every single person I have seen who has 'critiqued' Karen's stuff, positive or negative, has only ever gone on about how it feels rather than anything tangible. I'd love to see someone who can actually articulate a point without it devolving into feelings. It's much harder with music than other mediums, but I'm sure it can be done.