skykiii
kiwifarms.net
- Joined
- Jun 17, 2018
I was gonna make a new topic, but I decided to search and see if one existed.
Full disclosure, I never actually played the games. Until recently they weren't available on a platform I owned (and one of them--Ultra Despair Girls--still isn't).
So I know the series via Lets Plays. For Dangan 1 and 2 I watched MangaMinx's Lets Plays. For V3 I went with CinammonToastKen because all the other LPs I saw were like a hundred videos long, whereas Ken's was more reasonable. (Mangaminx didn't do an LP of v3, but she did post a video explaining that she wasn't going to).
Funny thing is I later learned Ken's LP is controversial among fans.... because he criticizes the game. Which I think says a lot about the fanbase.
..........................
Anyway.
for me Dangan is a series that is weirdly.... broken and yet endearing. It's like, its fun, but its also fun-damentally retarded.
Like take the core conceit of the games: There is this super high school that recruits people for having Ultimate/Super High School Level "talents." But these talents can be anything from just having a position of power (Ultimate Biker Gang Leader), to basically Autism Superpowers like Ultimate Housekeeper, to actual superpowers like Nagito's luck or Junko's Ultimate Analysis abilities.
Like, besides the millions of logical questions this raises (like how they even find all these people, whether these "talents" are just a naturally occuring thing in Dangan's world or if they only became a thing after Hope's Peak was founded, how the fuck do you decide that one guy in particular is the "Ultimate Fanfic Writer" or one girl is the "Ultimate Gamer", etc.) one problem I have is the series seems very wishy-washy with this concept.
What I mean is, the series keeps bringing up the talents but they rarely ever actually play into the story. Like just for example, there's one murderer who actually used his talent as part of his crime... and he's literally the only one in the entire series. Other than that and cases like Nagito, basically the talents don't amount to anything.
Another weird thing for me though is.... well, I got into Dangan because I like murder mysteries. But Dangan is one of those franchises where it doesn't always stick to the murder mystery premise and seems to think you care about the world its building. I legit don't understand the point of things like a lot of the spinoff light novels that are just "here's an adventure one of the characters had outside the game." They remind me of those Detective Conan OVAs where its just Conan having some silly side-adventure with his friends. Look, nobody plays Clue and says "wouldn't this game be more fun if we rearranged the books on this shelves and ignored the whole murder thing?" Nobody plays Simcity wanting the city to be already built and for the player to actually control a hot dog vendor on a street corner.
That said, recently I have thought of giving Ultra Despair Girls a shot (in Lets Play form since that's the only one not on the Nintendo Switch) since some aspects of the setting are kinda cool... even if the reason the world is corrupted is kinda... you know... retarded.
So somehow, a stupid bear (wording vaguely so I won't have to remember to spoiler mark everything) somehow caused "The Most Despair-Inducing Event in Human History." I'm sure we've all made the stock joke: Oh, so Velma caused the apocalypse. [replace "Velma" with bad media or event of your choice]
Actually, its funny... every time a novel or an anime tries to explain what the Event was, its always something that's not far off from that joke. I almost feel like its best to only play the games and ignore the other media entirely as they always come off like bad fanfiction (even though apparently the game's creator had a hand in a lot of it).
While I liked the games, one thing that did always bother me was the whole Hope vs Despair thing and basically, how everyone has a retarded attitude about it. I just watched the anime Danganronpa 3 and there's a guy who wants to literally kill anyone who is "tainted by despair."
It reminds me of something the Nostalgia Critic said with regards to Care Bears: what exactly constitutes "caring?" Do you get a visit from the Bears if you say you don't care what your friend decides to buy you for lunch?
By the same token, is the guy in the DR3 anime saying he'll kill anyone who lets out a melancholy sigh?
Like... it's just an emotion. You can't be despairing 100% of the time, and you can't be hopeful 100% of the time. Having generally optimistic or pessimistic personalities is a thing, but the stupidity reminds me of the movie The Happening where just having your survival instinct removed means people immediately commit suicide.... except here its apparently Despair Makes You Evil (although you can apparently conveniently control it when the narrative calls for it).
I've also never jived with the villain saying they want everyone to feel despair because its so wonderful. To me that makes about as much sense as saying "I want to live in a world where you always feel that sense of relief you get after eating when you've been hungry for hours, but you feel that relief all the time." Like, if the villain was just crazy and people said as much, that would be one thing... but the problem is everyone else in the setting acts very similarly.
Granted... this is a thing I can forgive when I keep in mind this game was made for teens and pre-teens. When you're at that age, this shit might legitimately be deep and thought-provoking for you. If you're a grown-ass adult though, yeah it sounds stupid, and you just keep wanting someone to show up and point out to the characters how fucking autistic they all sound.
And yet....
..... This is the series that gave us the legendary Gundham Tanaka and his Dark Divas of Destruction. So I can never hate it.
Full disclosure, I never actually played the games. Until recently they weren't available on a platform I owned (and one of them--Ultra Despair Girls--still isn't).
So I know the series via Lets Plays. For Dangan 1 and 2 I watched MangaMinx's Lets Plays. For V3 I went with CinammonToastKen because all the other LPs I saw were like a hundred videos long, whereas Ken's was more reasonable. (Mangaminx didn't do an LP of v3, but she did post a video explaining that she wasn't going to).
Funny thing is I later learned Ken's LP is controversial among fans.... because he criticizes the game. Which I think says a lot about the fanbase.
..........................
Anyway.
for me Dangan is a series that is weirdly.... broken and yet endearing. It's like, its fun, but its also fun-damentally retarded.
Like take the core conceit of the games: There is this super high school that recruits people for having Ultimate/Super High School Level "talents." But these talents can be anything from just having a position of power (Ultimate Biker Gang Leader), to basically Autism Superpowers like Ultimate Housekeeper, to actual superpowers like Nagito's luck or Junko's Ultimate Analysis abilities.
Like, besides the millions of logical questions this raises (like how they even find all these people, whether these "talents" are just a naturally occuring thing in Dangan's world or if they only became a thing after Hope's Peak was founded, how the fuck do you decide that one guy in particular is the "Ultimate Fanfic Writer" or one girl is the "Ultimate Gamer", etc.) one problem I have is the series seems very wishy-washy with this concept.
What I mean is, the series keeps bringing up the talents but they rarely ever actually play into the story. Like just for example, there's one murderer who actually used his talent as part of his crime... and he's literally the only one in the entire series. Other than that and cases like Nagito, basically the talents don't amount to anything.
Another weird thing for me though is.... well, I got into Dangan because I like murder mysteries. But Dangan is one of those franchises where it doesn't always stick to the murder mystery premise and seems to think you care about the world its building. I legit don't understand the point of things like a lot of the spinoff light novels that are just "here's an adventure one of the characters had outside the game." They remind me of those Detective Conan OVAs where its just Conan having some silly side-adventure with his friends. Look, nobody plays Clue and says "wouldn't this game be more fun if we rearranged the books on this shelves and ignored the whole murder thing?" Nobody plays Simcity wanting the city to be already built and for the player to actually control a hot dog vendor on a street corner.
That said, recently I have thought of giving Ultra Despair Girls a shot (in Lets Play form since that's the only one not on the Nintendo Switch) since some aspects of the setting are kinda cool... even if the reason the world is corrupted is kinda... you know... retarded.
So somehow, a stupid bear (wording vaguely so I won't have to remember to spoiler mark everything) somehow caused "The Most Despair-Inducing Event in Human History." I'm sure we've all made the stock joke: Oh, so Velma caused the apocalypse. [replace "Velma" with bad media or event of your choice]
Actually, its funny... every time a novel or an anime tries to explain what the Event was, its always something that's not far off from that joke. I almost feel like its best to only play the games and ignore the other media entirely as they always come off like bad fanfiction (even though apparently the game's creator had a hand in a lot of it).
While I liked the games, one thing that did always bother me was the whole Hope vs Despair thing and basically, how everyone has a retarded attitude about it. I just watched the anime Danganronpa 3 and there's a guy who wants to literally kill anyone who is "tainted by despair."
It reminds me of something the Nostalgia Critic said with regards to Care Bears: what exactly constitutes "caring?" Do you get a visit from the Bears if you say you don't care what your friend decides to buy you for lunch?
By the same token, is the guy in the DR3 anime saying he'll kill anyone who lets out a melancholy sigh?
Like... it's just an emotion. You can't be despairing 100% of the time, and you can't be hopeful 100% of the time. Having generally optimistic or pessimistic personalities is a thing, but the stupidity reminds me of the movie The Happening where just having your survival instinct removed means people immediately commit suicide.... except here its apparently Despair Makes You Evil (although you can apparently conveniently control it when the narrative calls for it).
I've also never jived with the villain saying they want everyone to feel despair because its so wonderful. To me that makes about as much sense as saying "I want to live in a world where you always feel that sense of relief you get after eating when you've been hungry for hours, but you feel that relief all the time." Like, if the villain was just crazy and people said as much, that would be one thing... but the problem is everyone else in the setting acts very similarly.
Granted... this is a thing I can forgive when I keep in mind this game was made for teens and pre-teens. When you're at that age, this shit might legitimately be deep and thought-provoking for you. If you're a grown-ass adult though, yeah it sounds stupid, and you just keep wanting someone to show up and point out to the characters how fucking autistic they all sound.
And yet....
..... This is the series that gave us the legendary Gundham Tanaka and his Dark Divas of Destruction. So I can never hate it.