Cultcow Russell Greer / @ just_some_dude_named_russell29 / A Safer Nevada PAC - Swift-Obsessed Sex Pest, Convicted of E-Stalking, "Eggshell Skull Plaintiff" Pro Se Litigant, Homeless, aspiring brothel owner

[Rotollo 2]

Russell is too powerful, if I was Taylor Swift RN, I would be running in fear

 

[mindlessobserver]

Please stop talking about legal shit like this aaa, the only have to accept relevant facts as true, things like 'Jersh made a troon commit suicide' are not relevant facts to the lawsuit and should be disregarded.

Fair enough. I'm more annoyed that the defamation should have been challenged before it got to this point and the situation is sticky. There are no good options if we are being brutally honest. But novel legal arguments are not "dumb" and would certainly not get someone "disbarred". If that was the case nobody would ever argue anything.

Based solely on the brutal fact Null probably should not have talked about the case at all, even if it was his right to do so. Because that seems to be the thread the judges clung too.

 

[S.C.U.D.]

I feel for @Useful_Mistake right now, it must be annoying dealing with retards who see a feature and immediately post without reading anything.

 

[Wuhan Wet Market]

They state a bit higher their reasoning:
View attachment 5419558

They also state in there we caused a school shooting now too?
"Mr. Moon and Kiwi Farms users have been implicated in three suicides, a school shooting in New Mexico, and a clash with New Zealand authorities over information about terrorist attacks at mosques in Christchurch."

How are we responsible? Last time I checked, we can't control the actions of others. American courts are a total joke.

 

[TherapyMan]

Many posts with cogent, grounded analysis

Good to see some pushback to the idiots in the thread. Courts liberally construing a pro se Plaintiff's complaint to state a claim happens thousands of times a day in this country, and the only thing that makes it newsworthy is that KiwiFarms is involved. Any practicing lawyer will be able to tell you that Courts are pretty damn generous when it comes to allowing pro se complaints to avoid a motion to dismiss.

I feel for @Useful_Mistake right now, it must be annoying dealing with retards who see a feature and immediately post without reading anything.

The fan fiction persecution complex conspiracy theories written here, while entertaining, are mighty embarrassing. Some people might need a reality check that the world does not revolve around KiwiFarms.

 

[HodgePodgeRogerDodger]

@mindlessobserver @Useful_Mistake

I’m retarded. Is it so over or are we so fucking back?

All I get is that the court is basically just waving it through because somewhat retarded reasons and Russell literally taped together so much shit in his appeal.

 

[FILTH Tourist]

Oh... I don't know about you... but I think Josh is gonna need to sell a few more T-shirts to pay back 300k. Holy fuck.

Is it too late to add a "Damn it, Null. We lost the case." To the line up?

 

[Tetragrammaton]

this will be interesting to watch unfold. i could be wrong but it seems to me that this mainly happened because one judge felt differently than another. so all null really has to do is fight it and things should be ok. i do not really see why they would not be.

 

[LikeAStone 2.0]

Because, as we know, there is nothing more trustworthy than mainstream media.

 

[Eydallur]

Golly gee whiz I guess TSwift owes Greer a table for two at olive garden now. Someone get the fucking breadsticks.

 

[Molag Bal]

Anyway, here's where the Appeals court disagreed with the district court,

They also wanted all user data.

They specifically were gearing up to charge every NZ resident who viewed the christchurch footage with child porn possession and had mouthpieces brag about this on their behalf. The fact that they're deliberately citing the wrong charge just to have some excuse to throw the book at people for watching a video is the main reason Jersh cited for insulting them.

It’s strange to me that they highlight Null’s persistent mockery of Greer, because as far as I understand, that’s the reason for the fair use of his content. Null and other users are offering critique of something they think sucks.

Am I interpreting this correctly: Because Null more or less said "lol get fuckt retard" that somehow impacts the legality of the situation?

Their rationale is that Josh reposting Greer's takedown requests and making fun of them in public encouraged other people to infringe on his copyright and therefore the case is remanded.

 

[Kalsarikännit]

"We find Kiwi Farms to be a bunch of meanypants, therefore we reverse our ruling not based on merit or legalities, but because we are unable to operate as professionals and instead are purely driven by emotional manipulation and baseless conjecture while incessantly needing to feel morally superior."

Welcome to Current Year + 8!

 

[Useful_Mistake]

Is it so over or are we so fucking back?

This is not good, but it's not the end either. I remember @AnOminous was not very optimistic about Null's chances if this exact thing happened, though.

because one judge felt differently than another

Not a single judge dissented.

 

[Punished Brent]

This suicide shit is retarded. We just talk shit here. It’s not being forced down their throats like a feminine penis. These people have to actively search for what we are saying here amongst ourselves. I think it would be pretty cool if all the weird trannies were forced to read KF but unfortunately that’s just reality and you will never be able to prevent everyone everywhere from hurting someone’s feelings.

 

[Historical Strelkov]

What does judging the character of the website have to do with copyright infringement?

 

[I'm Retarded?]

lol. I don't see how this case being reopened could be anything for Greer but yet another embarassment in a long career of cringe. every other case of his has ended in total loss due to his own comical incompetence but I'm sure this one will be different. I know we're all doompilled about the integrity of the court system and our societal justice framework and all that but no judge is going to instantly torpedo their legal career by firing the shot that turns the internet censorship cold war hot. even if a judge was retarded enough to flout every reasonable course of action in favor of blind political activism, the chances of it surviving appeal are even lower. realistically he's just doing what he does best: being a noxious but ultimately harmless scourge in the lives of every unfortunate soul that has to deal with him and his flaming dumpster of a personality.

 

[Useful_Mistake]

What does judging the character of the website have to do with copyright infringement?

They have to fill in the background section of the parties and what led to the case in action. To do so they must rely on the operating complaint. Aside from that, nothing.

 

[WelperHelper99]

lol. I don't see how this case being reopened could be anything for Greer but yet another embarassment in a long career of cringe. every other case of his has ended in total loss due to his own comical incompetence but I'm sure this one will be different. I know we're all doompilled about the integrity of the court system and our societal justice framework and all that but no judge is going to instantly torpedo their legal career by firing the shot that turns the internet censorship cold war hot. even if a judge was retarded enough to flout every reasonable course of action in favor of blind political activism, the chances of it surviving appeal are even lower. realistically he's just doing what he does best: being a noxious but ultimately harmless scourge in the lives of every unfortunate soul that has to deal with him and his flaming dumpster of a personality.

You mentioned appeal and now I'm wondering that if this keeps going, Josh will end up before the Supreme Court. Because this isn't even really the end, not yet

 

[PyrrhicRustle]

Make the judges have to have an in-depth conversation with Mr. Greer.

 

[joebobmurphy]

I feel like there is a more-than-zero chance the "Judge" is a literal retard that stole his mom's favorite muu muu and somehow bumbled his way into a court. I can't really think of another explanation for why Null telling Greer his copyright claims are bunkum in a rude manner suddenly makes them not bunkum.