Andy also showed an uncharacteristic amount of contrition and self-reflection, and is, by his own admission much less responsible than Nick. Andy is a 30+ year old who lived off his parents, he's not proud of it, or judgmental of other people for how they live their lives. And crucially, he's not responsible for anyone else in his life like Nick is.
By contrast, Rekieta had been much less willing to admit any kind of missteps in his life and actively hostile to anyone that tries to call him on it, if the Dear John stream is any indication. I don't really believe he's gonna turn a new leaf now, especially if his posts on locals post-bail are anything to go off of