Astronauts stranded in space due to multiple issues with Boeing's Starliner — and the window for a return flight is closing

Archive/Sauce

Astronauts stranded in space due to multiple issues with Boeing's Starliner — and the window for a return flight is closing​


Two NASA astronauts who rode to orbit on Boeing's Starliner are currently stranded in space aboard the International Space Station (ISS) after engineers discovered numerous issues with the Boeing spacecraft. Teams on the ground are now racing to assess Starliner's status.

Astronauts Butch Wilmore and Suni Williams were originally scheduled to return to Earth on June 13 after a week on the ISS, but their stay has been extended for a second time due to the ongoing issues. The astronauts will now return home no sooner than June 26th, according to NASA.

IMG_9459.jpeg

After years of delays, Boeing's Starliner capsule successfully blasted offon its inaugural crewed flight from Florida's Cape Canaveral Space Force Station at 10:52 a.m. EDT on June 5. But during the 25-hour flight, engineers discovered five separate helium leaks to the spacecraft's thruster system.

Now, to give engineers time to troubleshoot the faults, NASA has announced it will push back the perilous return flight, extending the crew's stay on the space station to at least three weeks.

"We've learned that our helium system is not performing as designed," Mark Nappi, Boeing's Starliner program manager, said at a news conference on June 18. "Albeit manageable, it's still not working like we designed it. So we've got to go figure that out."

The return module of the Starliner spacecraft is currently docked to the ISS's Harmony module as NASA and Boeing engineers assess the vital hardware issues aboard the vessel, including five helium leaks to the system that pressurizes the spacecraft's propulsion system, and five thruster failures to its reaction-control system.

After powering the thrusters up on June 15, engineers found that most of these issues appeared to be at least partially resolved, but their exact causes remain unknown.

However, the Harmony module's limited fuel means Starliner can only stay docked for 45 days, so the window for a safe return flight is narrowing.

The issues are the latest in a long list of setbacks and headaches for Boeing's spacecraft. The company built the Starliner capsule as a part of NASA's Commercial Crew Program, a partnership between the agency and private companies to ferry astronauts into low Earth orbit following the retirement of NASA's space shuttles in 2011. SpaceX's Crew Dragon also came from this initiative and has racked up 12 crewed flights since it began operating in 2020.

But Starliner's first uncrewed test flight in 2019 was scuppered by a software fault that placed it in the wrong orbit, and a second attempt was held back by issues with a fuel valve. After more reviews last year, the company had to fix issues with the capsule's parachutes and remove around a mile (1.6 kilometers) of tape that was found to be flammable.

The current mission is Boeing's third attempt to take the crew to the ISS. The previous two were scrubbed by a vibrating oxygen valve on the United Launch Alliance's Atlas V rocket on which Starliner was mounted (and which was developed by Lockheed Martin) and a computer glitch in a ground launch sequencer, respectively.
 
I was thinking about these poor fuckers yesterday. What a shitshow, just send a Soyuz capsule to get them home. Nobody wants to see them cooked and then atomised when their Boeing space-coffin burns up in the atmosphere.
Imagine being up on the ISS and knowing that they thing designed to take you back home is busted and a bunch of DEi hires are in charge of getting is back in shape. They must be shitting themselves. Can they hitch a ride back down on one of the other transports?
Imagine the PR disaster for Biden's NASA if they:
  • Spent 4.2 billion (while awarding SpaceX 2.6) to ship goods and passengers to the ISS to Boeing and it couldn't do 1 fucking safe crewed flight
  • In current year, having to beg the Russians for a emergency landing in their own capsule, a 1960s design, the PR disaster would be as big if they died in reentry in a American™ capsule, and they likely couldn't even be fitted because their space suits are probably incompatible anyway (Soyuz uses custom individual seating because it's that fucking tiny to maximize space)
  • Or beg Elon musk, the most evil person on the left today, to get a dragon up there, the blowback would be slightly better, but Boeing would probably chapter 11th anyway after wasting 4.2 billion dollars of NASA money and 10+ years of work for nothing, after it's last product, the space shuttle, managed to blow up twice and kill 14 astronauts

Ground control must have told them "if it's not Boeing you're not going."
Pretty much.
 
Yes, a ton of cosmonauts burned up and only a few of their deaths were ever made public. Yuri Gagarin almost went up in the total deathtrap that was Soyuz 1, which ended up being manned by a guy who didn't want a national hero like Gagarin to be killed by it. He told people he wanted an open casket after so people could see what the Soviets had allowed to happen to him. He crashed full-speed into the ground so here's the remains:

That's not the remains of Gagarin though. That's Vladimir Komarov.

Gagarin died in a fighter jet, not in space.
 
The entire board of directors at Boeing should be kicked to the curb immediately.

The absolute unremitting greed of these people is astonishing. To wreck one of the crown jewels of American industry is unforgivable.
It is insane. 10 years ago I'd have had no issue flying on a Boeing aircraft and have done so countless times. I will now not fly on anything not fully designed and built by Whites and maybe one or two Japanese. That means nothing newer than a 777-300.
 
The entire board of directors at Boeing should be kicked to the curb immediately.

The absolute unremitting greed of these people is astonishing. To wreck one of the crown jewels of American industry is unforgivable.
Boeing should have been broken up half a decade ago or, at the very least, forced to rebrand to "McConnell Douglas" again because it's the idiots who wrecked that airline that are somehow running the company post-merger.
 
They're still trying to fix that fucking thing?
If I was one of those astronauts I'd be refusing to leave until they sent up a non Boeing tin can. Soyuz, SpaceX, even that shady ESA thing would be better.

Or rip off a chunk of metal and surf down, a la Dark Star.
 
I didn't say Gargarin's remains were in there. I said it "ended up being manned by a guy who didn't want a national hero like Gagarin to be killed by it."

Said guy was Komarov. He explicitly did what he did to save Yuri from his (Komarov's) fate. Incredible man. Imagine having that kind of fortitude. If he hadn't been that courageous, that lava rock looking thing would have been the most famous cosmonaut of all time.
 
Does anyone know the food situation? A 3 day trip turning into 50 can easily lead to starvation if they don’t have a system to deliver supplies. It doesn’t seem like Boeing built an airlock to facilitate this supply transfer. They’re essentially trapped in a metal prison in space.
The spacecraft consists of a reusable capsule and an expendable service module and is designed for missions to low Earth orbit. The capsule accommodates seven passengers, or a mix of crew and cargo. For NASA missions to the ISS it will carry four passengers and a small amount of cargo. The Starliner capsule uses a weldless, spun-formed structure and is reusable up to 10 times with a six-month turnaround time. Boeingplans to alternate between two reusable crew modules for all planned Starliner missions. Each flight uses a new service module, which provides propulsion and power-generation capacity for the spacecraft. Starliner features wireless Internet and tablet technology for crew interfaces.

Starliner uses the NASA Docking System. Boeing modified the design of the Starliner docking system prior to OFT-2, adding a re-entry cover below the expendable nosecone for additional protection during atmospheric entry, similar to the one used in the SpaceX Dragon 2nosecone. This was tested on the OFT-2 mission. As in the SpaceX design, this re-entry cover is hinged.

The capsule uses the Boeing Lightweight Ablator for its re-entry heat shield.

Solar cells provided by Boeing subsidiary Spectrolab are installed onto the aft face of the service module, providing 2.9 kW of electricity.The service module includes four Rocketdyne RS-88 engines burning hypergolic propellants, which will be used for launch escape capability in the event of an abort.

In addition to the capsule and service module, a 1.78 m-long (5 ft 10 in) structure called an aeroskirt is integrated into the launch vehicle adapter of Atlas V. The aeroskirt provides aerodynamic stability and dampens the shock waves that come from the front of the rocket.
 
Does anyone know the food situation? A 3 day trip turning into 50 can easily lead to starvation if they don’t have a system to deliver supplies. It doesn’t seem like Boeing built an airlock to facilitate this supply transfer. They’re essentially trapped in a metal prison in space.
As always, the answer is 'it depends'. How much safety factor did the logistics crew build into food supplies on the ISS, and could they get an unmanned craft up with supplies? Even if the craft couldn't dock directly, it could match orbits and transfer supplies via spacewalk -- risky, but beats starving.

I'm getting definite vibes of The Martian here though.
 
In Sir John Hackett's "The Third World War" there is a chapter about warfare in space. Basically, the crew of an american space craft gets stranded up there during the four weeks the war on the ground lasts after they were hit by a Soviet laser weapon. Since everyone was busy with the war in Europe and the fact that spy satelites needed to be replaced nearly daily due to intensive anti-sat warfare conducted by the Soviet Union, NASA had no spare resources to conduct a resuce operation. Thus, the three or four astronauts became the first to die in space combat ever.

I never would have imagined this has a slight chance of ever happening, in particular not in the cool way during a war. Oh no, this is clownworld. It will happen in the most hilarious way possible, under the most incompetent and embarrassing circumstances imaginable.
 
As always, the answer is 'it depends'. How much safety factor did the logistics crew build into food supplies on the ISS, and could they get an unmanned craft up with supplies? Even if the craft couldn't dock directly, it could match orbits and transfer supplies via spacewalk -- risky, but beats starving.

I'm getting definite vibes of The Martian here though.
McDonnell Douglas are salivating at the thought of cost cutting basic necessities. Soon they’ll tell the astronauts to fuck off and die by puncturing their suit and using the pressure to actually fly toward a defunct ISS and hopefully not spin off into the deep cold black abyss.

Look on the bright side. If they die you don’t have to pay them anymore. Same with test pilots.
 
McDonnell Douglas are salivating at the thought of cost cutting basic necessities. Soon they’ll tell the astronauts to fuck off and die by puncturing their suit and using the pressure to actually fly toward a defunct ISS and hopefully not spin off into the deep cold black abyss.

Look on the bright side. If they die you don’t have to pay them anymore. Same with test pilots.
Hyperbole, but I strongly suspect there's a whole lot of panic going on behind closed doors at Boeing as they desperately try to find some way to get those astronauts back without having to beg a ride from the Russians or worse, Elon Musk.
 
Hyperbole, but I strongly suspect there's a whole lot of panic going on behind closed doors at Boeing as they desperately try to find some way to get those astronauts back without having to beg a ride from the Russians or worse, Elon Musk.
Through personal and work experience I’m going to tell you you’re right. But not just because of Starliner. Boeing’s entire corporate structure has been an infernal shitshow since being brought under the limelight by the House investigation committee. Honestly if they weren’t busy firing everyone and moving money offshore before they get hit with the gavel I’m sure Starliner would be in the back of their minds. But really it’s probably been forgotten by many at Boeing already.
 
Back