TGWTG "Nostalgia Critic" / Doug Walker, Rob Walker, Mike Michaud, Mike Ellis, Holly Christine Brown, et al - The Incompetent Predator-Protecting Upper Management of Channel Awesome, Doug Still Not That Funny

  • 🔧 Actively working on site again.
I just enjoy watching Doug’s stuff. I don’t think of him as some esteemed critic who’s word is law or anything,
I'll be fair to the guy that the video isn't really a hate video on Doug and is pretty gracious for a Breadtube-adjacent channel.

But it's funny how some of Doug's detractors prop up Linkara as a better critic when Linkara is even worse than Doug at reviewing things, and has remained pretty dormant in not growing.
 
1734371198804.jpeg
Did channel awesome officially surpass RLM? An hour later the last starfighter review is still the lowest video viewed in Red Letter Media history. Any random Disney December video gets 60K views easy.
 
I'll be fair to the guy that the video isn't really a hate video on Doug and is pretty gracious for a Breadtube-adjacent channel.

But it's funny how some of Doug's detractors prop up Linkara as a better critic when Linkara is even worse than Doug at reviewing things, and has remained pretty dormant in not growing.
I believe it can be argued Linkara is pretty much what everyone claims Doug is doing with his videos, with the caveat that Linkara is doing those things even worse.
 
The Based Angry reviewer vs The Cringe Video Essayist. Who wins.
But fucking Linkara as an improved talented critic?! The guy whose content is just him reading a comic book but making snarky comments here and there, and preaching on a non-existent soapbox.
The guy is infamous on twitter for being one of the smugest douchebags ever.
Doug Walker still a Donald Trump level boogeyman to the tranny left. Anthony Gramuglia is the breadtuber faggot who said the rocky horror picture is a rightwing transphobic dog Whistle and Velma was conservative propaganda.
 
Did channel awesome officially surpass RLM? An hour later the last starfighter review is still the lowest video viewed in Red Letter Media history. Any random Disney December video gets 60K views easy.
I mean using a RLM video without Mike, Jay, or Rich is like using a Channel Awesome video that doesn't have Doug in it
 
Doug Walker still a Donald Trump level boogeyman to the tranny left. Anthony Gramuglia is the breadtuber faggot who said the rocky horror picture is a rightwing transphobic dog Whistle and Velma was conservative propaganda.
Not only is he a smug bastard but he's just wrong.

In his video on "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" he says Dr. Frank N Furter is from the galaxy Transexual and the planet Transvestite. No. He's from the planet Transylvania. Or the name of the galaxy is Transylvania and the planet is Transsexual. It's not overly clear and there's more than one source for these things. Regardless of that he's wrong. And he's viewing this from the lens of today's world and not the one that existed when it was written in the 1970's.

Also Ranma 1/2 is not about being bi or trans. It's a gender bender comedy with lots of martial arts. It's actually very Japanese. And Velma is written, and acted, by a woman who is quite liberal. She's spoken at the 2024 DNC. She's said she's not a Republican and is confused by how many people think she is.

Long story short he's full of shit.
 
In his video on "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" he says Dr. Frank N Furter is from the galaxy Transexual and the planet Transvestite. No. He's from the planet Transylvania. Or the name of the galaxy is Transylvania and the planet is Transsexual. It's not overly clear and there's more than one source for these things. Regardless of that he's wrong. And he's viewing this from the lens of today's world and not the one that existed when it was written in the 1970's.
He's probably only mad because the composer of the musical, Richard O'Brien,--who identifies as non-binary--said that trans women will never be women:
"I think anybody who decides to take the huge step with a sex change deserves encouragement and a thumbs-up. As long as they're happy and fulfilled, I applaud them to my very last day. But you can't ever become a natural woman"
 
In his video on "The Rocky Horror Picture Show" he says Dr. Frank N Furter is from the galaxy Transexual and the planet Transvestite. No. He's from the planet Transylvania. Or the name of the galaxy is Transylvania and the planet is Transsexual. It's not overly clear and there's more than one source for these things. Regardless of that he's wrong. And he's viewing this from the lens of today's world and not the one that existed when it was written in the 1970's.
Yeah like when analyzing past media, it is important to think about the time they were written at. The thing is, this guy clearly knows that when he discussed 80s slashers movies, but didn't do that same diligence to Rocky Horror.

Also Ranma 1/2 is not about being bi or trans. It's a gender bender comedy with lots of martial arts. It's actually very Japanese. And Velma is written, and acted, by a woman who is quite liberal. She's spoken at the 2024 DNC. She's said she's not a Republican and is confused by how many people think she is.
Ranma 1/2 is kind of tricky especially with some of the minor changes the remake does, it doesn't help that like it or not, Ranma does resonate with trans people, even if that was not the intent. It's like saying Night of the Living Dead intended to show police brutality on black people even when Romero admitted that wasn't his intent. It's a whole death of the author thing where you can interpret something differently, and its cool, but don't put intent where there really isn't.

As for Velma, saw his bit on Velma, and Mindy Kaling did not do much of the writing of Velma to be fair, but he got mad at the show for its attempts at edgy humor. Though it says more on how bad of a show Velma is where it is too woke and too anti-woke at the same time but ultimately just a big pile of shit.

I believe it can be argued Linkara is pretty much what everyone claims Doug is doing with his videos, with the caveat that Linkara is doing those things even worse.
Yeah like Doug admittedly was accused of those things, it was true since his ego was extremely high between when he did the anniversary films to The Wall, so it is fine to trash Doug during that period since it took awhile for him to get humbled.

Linkara on the other hand never was humbled. Since Linkara is still an egotistical narcissist who can't handle negative memes or critiques about him, and tries to make sure that he is always the big man on top. He also desparately tries to control the conversation but he really can't, like he needs to admit he's in the wrong or laugh at himself more.

As for Doug, his content isn't getting as many views as before (doesn't help all the content dumped on the Channel Awesome channel is getting it buried in the algorithm), but man his Disneycember series really just became him talking about any random property that is under the Disney umbrella.
 
He's probably only mad because the composer of the musical, Richard O'Brien,--who identifies as non-binary--said that trans women will never be women:
"I think anybody who decides to take the huge step with a sex change deserves encouragement and a thumbs-up. As long as they're happy and fulfilled, I applaud them to my very last day. But you can't ever become a natural woman"
Richard O'Brien is also multi-talented and based.

Ranma 1/2 is kind of tricky especially with some of the minor changes the remake does,
... there's a remake? I might have to check it out but I'm pretty sure I'll be disappointed. While I loved that series as youngster I find nostalgia rarely strikes twice.

Regardless whether it resonates with trannies and troons it was never intended to but then these people have a tendency to see every fictional character as being one.

As for Velma, saw his bit on Velma, and Mindy Kaling did not do much of the writing of Velma to be fair, but he got mad at the show for its attempts at edgy humor. Though it says more on how bad of a show Velma is where it is too woke and too anti-woke at the same time but ultimately just a big pile of shit.
It was a shit show and not so much edgy as just mean spirited and totally shit on the original. To call Velma abrasive is to devalue the word abrasive. Those on the left hated it. Those on the right hated it. Fans of the original show hated it. Everybody seemingly hated it yet... it got two seasons. I don't get it.
 
Everybody seemingly hated it yet... it got two seasons. I don't get it.
Typically, streaming shows will be greenlit for one season, or 24 episodes, no matter what. Animated shows will typically split these episodes into two chunch and claim each one is a separate season, both to give themselves more time to animate all the episodes and to make people think it’s more popular than it is. Velma was never given more episodes or anything like that, it was only ever approved for the amount of episodes it got from the start. Despite what some people like it claim, “hate-watching” didn’t do anything to extend the show’s lifetime.
 
But it's funny how some of Doug's detractors prop up Linkara as a better critic when Linkara is even worse than Doug at reviewing things, and has remained pretty dormant in not growing.
Linkara pays a lot more lipservice to breadtube and his kinkiness is not secret, so is a total cope for the former CA fans to still engage in the critic culture and make lore sketches even if Linkara has and will never graduate to breadtube proper. Every Linkara 'fan' with a Angry Nostalgia Kid channel is a Quinton level scorned fan of Doug.
 
View attachment 6758162
Did channel awesome officially surpass RLM? An hour later the last starfighter review is still the lowest video viewed in Red Letter Media history. Any random Disney December video gets 60K views easy.
I like Josh and Jim just fine, but they're not exactly the best RLM has to offer.
 
That breadtube video is so bizarre because it's essentially Beatlemania getting mad at the Beatles. The only reason any of you people have a career is ripping off Doug Walker. You have the same level of autism, same blindness to critique that isnt commenting on tropes youve read about and you cant make anything actually worth a damn so just critique tentpole blockbusters and kiddy capeshit cartoons
 
Back