"I could be the tenth person to say roughly the same thing on a liberal show, or I could literally be the first time somebody heard a certain idea if I’m in a more conservative space," he added, noting the party should be reaching out to people who are "not always looking for politics."
This would be a good thought except mainstream Democrats haven't had to seriously contest their ideas with people on the right in decades. People like Charlie Kirk spent
years sharpening the presentation of their ideas and thoughts by duking it out on left wing platforms, campuses, shows, etc. The left has only ever had to fight with people
further to the left. It's going to take years for their best and brightest to even whet their blades, much less strike deeply.
I've followed his podcast via YouTube, Spotify, and RSS for years and while I don't listen to every episode, Rogan is never one to outright denigrate perceived wrongthink. If anything, he's open to giving people a voice and openly fact-checking them by having Jamie look shit up on the fly.
Rogan also can do something that the left can't—approach non-political topics without patently trying to transform the topic into supporting the Democrats politically. I can listen to Rogan talk about mushrooms, hunting, sports, history, etc. without politics ever popping up in the discussion. The left literally does not know how to do this. Every single topic is either subtly or ham-fistedly (usually the latter) turned into a pro-left advocacy hour. Until they realize that the best advocates are normal, credible people who are not always trying to get you to vote in a certain way, they'll never win over the platform.
That's one of the reasons why alternative media has
always been heavily conservative. Talk radio was filled with people who were artificially shut out of mainstream platforms by the institutional left. The Internet and podcasts are that way, too (or were more so in the past, until YouTube and co. began obviously and openly manipulating how content appeared to suppress anyone on the right). They don't seem to understand that there's no reason for a left wing Rogan to succeed when that hypothetical audience would get their fill just by turning on literally any major news channel, talk show, comedy show, etc. There's no niche to fill. It's so obvious but they don't seem to ever understand it.