Baseball Thread

  • 🐕 I am attempting to get the site runnning as fast as possible. If you are experiencing slow page load times, please report it.
Reflections on Barry Bonds

I'd been meaning to do a piece on Bonds for while and was reminded of it due to all of the recent tributes and adulation that he's been getting from the Giants. I also remember hearing that they were going to put up a statue for the guy. I wanted to do a little bit of a deep dive/reflection on different aspects of Bonds the player and Bonds the person.

The player

A common cope by Bonds apologists is the assertion that you could split his career into 2 halves and you would get 2 Hall of Famers. This is absolutely asinine, as the 2nd half of his career was obviously heavily aided by PED abuse.

I also reject the notion that his steroid abuse was "balanced out" by the fact that many pitchers were juicing as well. I also think that pitchers benefit from steroids more by being able to recover quicker from injuries and in-between starts. In contrast, a hitter is going to benefit in all kinds of ways from these steroids.

To give you an idea of how roided up to the fucking gills Barry was, his hat size grew 2 sizes, his jersey went from Size 42 to Size 52 and his shoe size went from 10.5 to 13. He gained 55 lbs. from his time in Pittsburgh. I have never, ever heard of some shit like this.

I would contend that while Bonds was already a stupendous player before steroids, the magnitude of his use (again, the head size increase, etc.) as well as perhaps the type of steroids that he was doing artificially put him in a completely different stratosphere. We have to essentially throw out his steroid year if we're doing a fair appraisal of the guy vs. all of the other great players who have played this game.

I've done quite a bit of number crunching and if you take the 11 year period between 1989 and 1999 (includes a healthy portion of his Giants career and also before the steroids started to kick in), he was basically a 35 homer / 35 steals per year guy slashing 0.296/0.425/0.587 with a OPS of 1.012 and a OPS+ of 174. He also generated an average of 8 WAR / year during this stretch and also won his 8 Golden Gloves.

In his prime, he was a 4 tool player and basically a much better version of Juan Soto (more power, much better fielder, much better baserunner although Soto has been more clutch in the playoffs).


Now if you add in his first 3 years before the 11 year prime above and also account for steady decline in his last 8 years (throwing out his steroid-influenced stats and replacing them with a more "natural" curve) post the prime, then I think he ends up with 600 + homers and a career WAR of around 110 or so. Again, these would be first ballot Hall of Fame numbers on their own so even adjusting for steroids there is no question that he had a Hall-worthy career.

One last point, Bonds was objectively a horrible player in the playoffs (other than 1 of the steroid years) and very likely caused the Pirates to miss out on going to the World Series with his repeated slumps and fuckups in the field (see below).

The person

I had always heard that that Bonds was known as an asshole off the field, but holy shit was I not prepared for how abjectly terrible a nigger he was and continues to be.

In college at Arizona, he once ran off the field in the middle of the game and caused a 10 minute delay because he had to go take a shit.

When he and his team-mates missed curfews, they were all expected to do running drills as punishment. Upon hearing this, Bonds told the team captain "Fuck you, I'm not doing shit". When Jim Brock, the Manager, heard about this he asked the team to vote on whether or not they wanted Bonds on the team.

If it wasn't for 2 idiots voting against there would have been a unanimous vote to kick him off the team. Brock didn't have the balls to do it (as he obviously should have done with such a majority being for it). Instead, Brock lowered his penalty to just a 10 mile run. Upon hearing this, Bobby Bonds apparently drove his truck onto the fucking diamond, parked it in front of the dugout and confronted Brock (mind you, this was during a closed practice). The apple doesn't fall far from the tree.

Early on in his Pirates career, even though he was playing exceptionally well, his team-mates absolutely hated him. A great example is as follows: Bonds got into a heated confrontation with Andy Van Slyke which resulted in a scuffle...normally you would expect team-mates to quickly break up the fight right?

Well...Van Slyke was pulled off of Bonds, but then 5-6 of his team-mates proceed to pummel the motherfucking shit out of Bonds. I have never, in my decades and decades of following sports heard of such a thing happening in a locker room.

He once shoved a pizza into a team-mate's face during a heated argument and during contract arbitration, Bonds tried to jump across the table and physically fight the Pirates' GM.

The infamous confrontation with Jim Leyland is absolutely hilarious in retrospect but really shows you who Bonds is.

Against the Braves that one year, it was Game 7 and the 9th inning. The Pirates were up 2 runs and when Van Slyke told Barry to play shallow, Bonds gave him the finger and refused. The result? A hit to Barry which scored the winning run because Bond's weak throw wasn't in time to get the runner at home plate.

In SF, he and Jeff Kent fought at least a half dozen times.

A longtime photographer for the Pirates, Pete Diana, had over the years given Barry tons of photos for free. There was an accident at the Pirates stadium where 2 members of the staff tragically died. Diana started a very nice effort to try and raise some money for the families: whenever opposing players would come to Pittsburgh, he would ask them to sign memorabilia which would then be auctioned off and the proceeds would be given to the families.

Pretty much every star player you can think of from that era signed a bunch of stuff. So then, the Giants come to town and Diana (who obviously knew Barry well) asked him to sign some stuff. Barry's response? "Fuck you, fuck them, I'm not signing shit".

Pete Diana then told Jeff Pearlman when interviewed, "I hope Barry Bonds dies". Jesus Christ.

The Giants enabled a lot of Bonds' nigger behavior. He had an entire wall of the locker room to himself, including a leather recliner and a flat screen TV in front of his chair. While everyone else had to use the team publicist, Bonds had his own 2 publicists. He had his own massage therapist and even his own photographer.

This is only a sampling of all the insane confrontations that he had with players and press. If we include his horrific behavior with the press then I'd have to make about 10 more posts of this length. He was objectively cruel and seemed almost sadistic in how he treated pretty much any member of the press. Jesus I haven't even gotten into how he used to beat his wife to a pulp (even when she was 8 months pregnant).

I'm also not going to go into the debacle that was his stint as the Marlins' hitting coach, but it just goes to show that even so many years after retiring, he was still the same old asshole. You guys can look it up, but it's all the typical uppity nigger shit: a necessity to get paid the most and getting unheard of perks, not doing shit to help players improve, clashing with other coaches and management...

Final thoughts

For so many years, all I had known was that Bonds had a terrible relationship with the press...after I started compiling all of the stories I was just shocked at how many of his team-mates hated him. I also had no idea about how cruel he was to basically everyone. If ever there has been a player in any sports league who was a detriment to his team from a leadership and example setting perspective, it was absolutely Bonds.

His stats make for a clear Hall of Fame case, however given how much of a negative influence he was, I really can't blame anyone for Bonds being left off of ballots (and this is even if he never took steroids). He's quite possibly the worst person who has ever played a sport professionally.

As I was writing this, I kept thinking about how the richest nigger neighborhoods have more crime than the most impoverished white towns in places like rural Appalachia or even your random trailer park which is half meth labs.

Whether it's some gang-banging porch monkey on a school bus beating up other kids, some hoodrat bitch fighting another heifer on a cruise or the son of a famous ball player who grew up in affluence and received every aspect of a proper upbringing, one noble truth remains: a nigger will always be a nigger.

They're the worst scum on the face of the planet and can only defile and destroy anything that they come in touch with.

In the film "48 hours", Nick Nolte's character remarks to Eddie Murphy's that "Class isn't something you buy. Look at you, you've got on a 500-dollar suit and you're still a low-life."

Sums up the career and life of Bonds rather nicely I'd say.
 
Sums up the career and life of Bonds rather nicely I'd say.

My lasting memory of Barry Bonds was the collusion to keep him out of baseball and force him to retire in 2008.

Now maybe his personality and burning too many bridges finally caught up with him.

I'd also forgotten that he was 43 at the time!!!

But this wasn't like a David Ortiz, career year victory lap, going out on his own terms.

No one would sign the man after he just had an OPS above 1.000, 132 walks and was 69% better than league average offensively.

I'm kind of surprised that he was only worth 3.4 bWAR in his final year, but that's still valuable and he wasn't taking the field.

It's another example of leaguewide and commissioner-initiated collusion like Trevor Bauer to keep a player out of the game.
 
My lasting memory of Barry Bonds was the collusion to keep him out of baseball and force him to retire in 2008.

Now maybe his personality and burning too many bridges finally caught up with him.

I'd also forgotten that he was 43 at the time!!!

But this wasn't like a David Ortiz, career year victory lap, going out on his own terms.

No one would sign the man after he just had an OPS above 1.000, 132 walks and was 69% better than league average offensively.

I'm kind of surprised that he was only worth 3.4 bWAR in his final year, but that's still valuable and he wasn't taking the field.

It's another example of leaguewide and commissioner-initiated collusion like Trevor Bauer to keep a player out of the game.
Since we are sharing "Bonds is a massive piece of shit" stories I got one. I remember in 2004 Bonds did an interview for the Boston Globe in which he went off on the city of Boston calling it a racist shithole and how he would never play for them even if they were the only team to offer him a deal due to city's history with racism, of course he never gives examples of him getting racial slurs thrown his way when the Giants played at Fenway for interleague, he's only going off of what other black players told him (His father being one of them). This lead to Pedro Martinez calling Bonds out on his bullshit saying he never experienced any racism while playing for Boston. Of course, this didn't stop some in the soy addled press to run with Barry's claims, you got your typical Reddit tier articles like "Bostons dark history with racism" and shit like that. I found it extremely funny that some in the press went to bat for Bonds despite Bonds having a history of treating the press like utter shit. I guess they are willing to look the other way to Barry's antics cause we can't have heckin racism guys!
 
Last edited:
Since we are sharing "Bonds is a massive piece of shit" stories I got one. I remember in 2004 Bonds did an interview for the Boston Globe in which he went off on the city of Boston calling it a racist shithole and how he would never play for them even if they were the only team to offer him a deal due to city's history with racism, of course he never gives examples of him getting racial slurs thrown his way when the Giants played at Fenway for interleague, he's only going off of what other black players told him (His father being on of them). This lead to Pedro Martinez calling Bonds out on his bullshit saying he never experienced any racism while playing for Boston. Of course, this didn't stop some in the soy addled press to run with Barry's claims, you got your typical Reddit tier articles like "Bostons dark history with racism" and shit like that. I found it extremely funny that some in the press went to bat for Bonds despite Bonds having a history of treating the press like utter shit. I guess they are willing to look the other way to Barry's antics cause we can't have heckin racism guys!

As an aside, I've been sick of the Boston is uniquely racist horseshit since I first started seeing it when posting on other forums that had a sports section starting in the late 00's/early 2010's. It's always been bullshit and a myth. Boston has never been any more or less "racist" than any other city throughout America over the course of history. Not liking niggers at points in history was just common place, and it's retarded to act like a progressive bug hive like Boston has this dark and sordid history with racism that no other city has. Progressivism is its own form of racism, but not the sort of racism the people moaning about Boston claim or want it to be. It's no different than modern negros/white guilt mayo people crying about how some blacks were whipped and made to work in fields 300 years ago so there's some sort of imagined residual pain that we must continue to treat like a dead horse. Bill Russell was racially abused when Long Tall Sally was a brand new bitchin' hit on the pop charts so we have to continue to pretend Boston is virulently racist 40-60 years later. Tbh these claims always just smacked of jealousy of Boston's unprecedented success in sports.
 
The 2025 draft started about an hour ago. So far:

  • the Nationals take high school shortstop Eli Willits with the top pick
  • the Angels take righty Tyler Bremner #2 from UC Santa Barbara
  • Seattle takes lefty Kade Anderson from LSU with pick #3
  • the Rockies take high school shortstop Ethan Holliday, another son of Matt Holliday and brother of Jackson (#1 overall pick in 2022) at #4
  • St. Louis takes lefty Liam Doyle at #5 from Tennessee
  • Pittsburgh goes with a high school righty, Seth Hernandez at #6
  • Miami (Aiva Arquette,) Toronto (JoJo Parker,) Cincinnati (Steele Hall,) and the White Sox (Billy Carlson, teammate of Hernandez) all take shortstops at #7, #8, #9 and #10
Bremner looks like a bit of a surprise by the Angels. He was ranked to be around a top 15-20 pick.

Edit: 27 picks in and the run on shortstops has continued with the following teams selecting one.

Rangers #12
Giants #13
Rays #14
Twins #16
Diamondbacks #18
Astros #21
Braves #22
Tigers #24

So far all of the shortstops have been high schoolers except the #7, #13 and #16 picks.
 
Last edited:
t's always been bullshit and a myth. Boston has never been any more or less "racist" than any other city throughout America over the course of history.
Boston got that reputation because the bleeding hearts insisted on busing during the height of the Civil Rights bullshit. Busing wasn't any more popular in Boston than it was anywhere else, but the potato niggers were willing to get violent over it, so the press was shocked, shocked that some whites weren't goodwhites and just doing peaceful protests like elsewhere. As we've seen in recent years, if you keep telling badwhites they're bad because they're racist, eventually, they'll just say "Hey, maybe you have a point."

I agree that modern Boston is no more racist than any other Deep Blue urban bughive, but the niggers and the press will never forgive those uppity micks who didn't get with the program and decided to voice their displeasure with baseball bats and chains instead of strongly-worded letters.
 
I think the Angels went the poverty route with their pick and picked a guy who would sign pretty well under slot value so they could spend more on other picks in the draft.
Minasian's MO since his first year as the Angels GM has always been college guys who can get to the Majors fast (Bachman, Neto, Schanuel and Moore), and then spend on high school guys at the 10 or 11 round. He's been consistent on high floor, low ceiling guys, but what is mildly infuriating is that this is the first time in nearly 30 years they've had a top 5 five pick (last was Troy Glaus in 97 at 3rd), they could've gone with someone more exciting than a potential mid rotation starter.
 
Minasian's MO since his first year as the Angels GM has always been college guys who can get to the Majors fast (Bachman, Neto, Schanuel and Moore), and then spend on high school guys at the 10 or 11 round. He's been consistent on high floor, low ceiling guys, but what is mildly infuriating is that this is the first time in nearly 30 years they've had a top 5 five pick (last was Troy Glaus in 97 at 3rd), they could've gone with someone more exciting than a potential mid rotation starter.

Kind of interesting because Minasian was an Alex Anthopoulos disciple in Toronto.

Anthopoulos was Assistant GM to JP Ricciardi with the Jays in the aughts. Ricciardi was hired early in the aughts as a Billy Beane acolyte who promised a cheap Jays ownership that he could repeat the Moneyball magic and win on the cheap by drafting high-floor college position players like Russ Adams and Aaron Hill that would sign cheap and rise fast. Along with going cheap and building a bullpen off the waiver wire.

Halfway through the aughts, the Jays were no closer to catching the Yanks or the Red Sox, so ownership and Ricciardi shifted gears and tried to buy a playoff team by signing AJ Burnett, BJ Ryan and Frank Thomas & trading for Lyle Overbay & Troy Glaus.

The investment in payroll also failed with the Jays never finishing closer than a distant third (or not being close to the WC at all).

Ricciardi would get canned around 2010-11 and Anthopoulos would get hired as the young, cheap internal Canadian boy from Montreal.

AA's draft philosophy shifted to almost drafting exclusively high-risk HS pitchers early that the org had previously avoided completely for fear of bonus demands and avoidance of angering Selig by surpassing league bonus slot recommendations, to keep revenue sharing money flowing to offset the weak loonie.

Anthopoulos would amass extra picks and would draft the likes of Noah Syndergaard, Aaron Sanchez, Joe Musgrove, Tyler Beede, Phil Bickford, Daniel Norris, etc.

The org had a philosophy to draft almost exclusively pitchers because the thinking was that position players were easier to buy as FAs and trades.

AA also showed a willingness to draft HS pitchers with big demands then walking away if they wouldn't meet his cutoff, in the likes of Tyler Beede and Phil Bickford in quick succession.

Like the Angels more recently, AA would also use monies left over from 1st rounders who didn't sign by signing difficult signs after the 10th round in Rowdy Tellez and Jake Brentz. He'd also raise money for high round expensive signs by drafting & low-balling college senior pitchers with no leverage in the 8th-10th rounds. Some that actually had great careers like Matt Boyd & Kendall Graveman.
 
  • Informative
Reactions: SlavSquater
It's another example of leaguewide and commissioner-initiated collusion like Trevor Bauer to keep a player out of the game.

It's absurd what they're doing to Bauer because he had the gall to defend himself against the allegations. They're mad at him even though Bauer proved the woman going after him was intentionally setting him up.
 
As an old man HRD doesn't matter to me but nice to see SEA get a nod to W.

Now let me also sober up and reply to Bonds. I have mad props for him but I just can't put into words right now. Next year All Star Game will be in my home town (well locally) and I'm amped. Being a very hitter park it'll be spicy.

The best HRD was in Pittsburg, balls kept going into the water and people jumped off boats to grab one. Also Ryan Howard did well but aside that was just so cool. Everyone hit one past the park!

Judge fastest EVER to 350 HR. He's a monster.

Thank you for draft post, but BB draft doesn't grab me too much no offense to your work or following. I saw this girl the other day had a phillies shirt on it said Bohm, and the B was lower case and in the Phillies P just upside down.
I gotta say love illegal merch. On that note, who's your fav city conect?
 
The all-star game has ended in a 6-6 tie. This is the first time there is a tie with the new "Home Run Swing Off" tie-breaker rules if you want to watch.

Edit:
National League wins, with a 3/3 performance by Kyle Schwarber. The AL selection for Homerun hitters was pretty bad so it must have been based on volunteers or rather most of the players really didn't want to do it so they took who they could.
 
Last edited:
The guys of American Thinker posted a rant about the all-star game that wasn't and Stacy Abrams that might be worth to check.

July 15, 2025

The All-Star Game That Wasn’t: Stacey Abrams, MLB, and the $100 Million Strikeout​

By Charlton Allen

Tonight, the 2025 Major League Baseball All-Star Game will be played at Truist Park in metro Atlanta. It’s a celebratory event—four years overdue—but few in the media or the commissioner’s office want to talk about what happened last time.

In 2021, Commissioner Rob Manfred yanked this very event out of Georgia over a so-called voting rights controversy fueled by Stacey Abrams and her political machine.

The justification? Georgia’s election law, Senate Bill 202, was labeled “Jim Crow 2.0.” The damage? Nearly $100 million in lost revenue for local businesses. Yet, this story started long before SB 202.

The punchline? SB 202 is still the law—intact, enforced, and functional.

Abrams’s group, Fair Fight Action, launched its high-profile legal crusade after her 2018 loss to Brian Kemp, claiming Georgia’s voting laws were racist and suppressive.

Fair Fight selected Abrams’s campaign chair and close friend, Allegra Lawrence-Hardy, to serve as lead counsel, paying her firm over $20.2 million in legal fees over five years, according to a bombshell RealClearInvestigations exposé.
 
This is the first time there is a tie with the new "Home Run Swing Off" tie-breaker rules if you want to watch.
If they were gonna make it a HR Derby tie-breaker to reduce injury, they should have 1 through 9 have a swing each (subbing in and prioritizing position players present who have not yet gotten an AB) while keeping the alternating format to add possible tension/clutch moments.
I hate the timed format, 10 outs format was so much better.
The fuck are they doing? This isn't a game that averages 3 hours pre-pitch clock, it's the fucking HR Derby where the guys should be allowed to chug beers in between swings (I kid but it would be very funny if they let them do that).
 
- said he picked Curt Schilling to be the ASG SP in Seattle and Randy Johnson pouted and "Don't come back to me asking to play".
Johnson's notorious for being a sourpuss and Schilling got too based and turned into a borderline lolcow.
accused Joe Torre in the AL of being a spineless pussy filling the roster with all his Yankee guys because he was too scared to have them mad at him by picking others
I remember in the voting for the 2015 ASG, a bunch of us Royals fans did a 4chan-style raid where we spammed the ballots with all Royals. Other fanbases got mad, so we doubled down and voted in even mediocre players until the league put a stop to it.

Good times.
Since we are sharing "Bonds is a massive piece of shit" stories I got one.
I recall Jim Rome once reporting that a former player (I wanna say Ron Kittle?) asked him to sign a jersey for a sick kid. Bonds responded "I don't sign for white people".

Not sure if that happened or if I'm getting details wrong, but compared to the other anecdotes, it tracks.
 
His stats make for a clear Hall of Fame case, however given how much of a negative influence he was, I really can't blame anyone for Bonds being left off of ballots (and this is even if he never took steroids). He's quite possibly the worst person who has ever played a sport professionally.

The only thing that should matter for the HOF is stats. If people want a separate museum to honor the truly nice guys of the game, then do that. Maybe build it in Silvertown or something.
 
It's another example of leaguewide and commissioner-initiated collusion like Trevor Bauer to keep a player out of the game.

I sympathize with Bauer because I think that he's an exceptional talent. The problem is that whether we like it or not, his inability to just shut the fuck up and stop being so terminally online has basically made him radioactive to locker rooms that just don't want to deal with such issues.

Of course, this didn't stop some in the soy addled press to run with Barry's claims, you got your typical Reddit tier articles like "Bostons dark history with racism" and shit like that.

As an aside, I've been sick of the Boston is uniquely racist horseshit since I first started seeing it when posting on other forums that had a sports section starting in the late 00's/early 2010's. It's always been bullshit and a myth. Boston has never been any more or less "racist" than any other city throughout America over the course of history.

I agree that modern Boston is no more racist than any other Deep Blue urban bughive, but the niggers and the press will never forgive those uppity micks who didn't get with the program and decided to voice their displeasure with baseball bats and chains instead of strongly-worded letters.

The idea that Boston is somewhat uniquely racist is laughable. Chicago for example, is segregated as fuck. The niggers don't dare go to the Latin areas and the Slavs/Whites are in other areas of the city. I remember during the summer of peaceful protests how Latin Kings were hunting down any niggers who got anywhere close to their turf.

Another example would be Baltimore. While most people automatically assume that it's a nigger-infested shithole (which it totally is), just try walking through the jew areas of Baltimore as a non-kike. They have their own neighborhood patrol which straight up starts whacking motherfuckers with billy clubs or some shit with absolutely no recourse from real law enforcement.

The only thing that should matter for the HOF is stats. If people want a separate museum to honor the truly nice guys of the game, then do that. Maybe build it in Silvertown or something.

You should go back and read all of the incidents that I've compiled. His own team-mates beat the dog shit out of him on several occasions because he was so fucking insufferable.

The nigger was exceptional as a hitter (although most of his achievements are rendered moot due to steroids) but there's a reason why he never won. You can't win with a locker room that wants to fucking kill its best player because he's on some Ethan Ralph tier nigger shit at all times.

If he was just a wife beater or some shit then you may have a point, but this nigger was something else. Mind you that this isn't even the tip of the iceberg when it comes to Bonds stories. I literally got tired of reading through all of the material that's out there.
 
Mind you that this isn't even the tip of the iceberg when it comes to Bonds stories. I literally got tired of reading through all of the material that's out there.

The dude was one of the best to ever play, on and off of steroids. And the hypocritical sports writers who pretend to care now about steroids didn't say shit when it was happening, nor did the commissioner at the time who is also in the HOF.

there's a reason why he never won.

Ted Williams never won a World Series, should he not be in the HOF? For that matter, Tony Gwynn, Ichiro, Griffey Jr and on an on - tons of great players never won. Shit Mike Trout had one of the greatest stretches in history and will no doubt be a 1st ballot HOF'er but he could barely drag his team to the playoffs, and won nothing. Baseball is one sport that a great player simply can't take over and drag his team to victory, so I don't get this point.

Also, Ty Cobb was not only one of the greatest hitters ever, but an ornery prick to a lot of people especially in the press. He never won, should he not be in the HOF?

Sorry dude, your logic is flawed and inconsistent. This sort of just comes off as you having an unhealthy autistic obsession with a specific player.
 
Back