Sopranos is still the best TV show ever: Appreciation Thread - or maybe the wire

How did Phil compromise to being a house?
It's a TV progrum, a movie.
i fucking love the shield badass show with a killer ending
Fantastic show and underrated for sure, I just wish half of it wasn't a police procedural with those two other detectives (which did have good cases, don't get me wrong) and focused solely on the main plot drama.
 
Mmmn, true dat, I can concede.

What is also emphasized is the culture shock the Jersey boys feel when in the motherland. They go on and on throughout the series about being proud Italians, but when they go to Italy, they are essentially disrespected and sneak-dissed most of the time. Even when people like Furio are smiling at simpletons like Paulie, if you read between the lines you know they're thinking "these American idiots are impressed by anything."

Paulie Commendatori! like a commander! that's respect!
Furio: this guy's an idiot lmao

Tony: me despiacce, Nino. I meant no disrespect.
Nino (in italian): fuck off

Paulie: ...can I just get some macaroni and gravy?
Italian dude: Americans are such uncultured assholes.

Many such cases.

Paulie when back in America: I felt right at home!
Tbf, it's not like the glorified crew did any homework. They act like complete retards and earn the disrespect.
 
Tbf, it's not like the glorified crew did any homework. They act like complete retards and earn the disrespect.
A lot of descendants who've never been to their "homeland" are like that. Like the children of Indian immigrants who are convinced it's a glittering paradise because of the way it's described to them. Or black people who think Wakanda is a real country.

And the Dimeo crew didn't even realize what was really happening, Paulie genuinely believed he was welcomed. Tony really thought he'd impressed them. And they walked away happy because ignorance is bliss.
 
And the Dimeo crew didn't even realize what was really happening, Paulie genuinely believed he was welcomed. Tony really thought he'd impressed them. And they walked away happy because ignorance is bliss.
I am pretty sure they were just putting on airs for the other guys because going to the "homeland" is supposed to be this big important experience for anyone in the Italian American Mob. Saying you had a bad time would reflect badly on this collective idea and rather than the rest of the mobsters realizing the Italian mob simply isn't capable of truly experiencing Italy the way their forefathers did, they would probably deflect by thinking something was wrong with Tony and Paulie (like they weren't real Italians or something like that).

So Paulie and Tony lied that they weren't completely miserable.
 
A lot of descendants who've never been to their "homeland" are like that. Like the children of Indian immigrants who are convinced it's a glittering paradise because of the way it's described to them. Or black people who think Wakanda is a real country.

And the Dimeo crew didn't even realize what was really happening, Paulie genuinely believed he was welcomed. Tony really thought he'd impressed them. And they walked away happy because ignorance is bliss.
They didn't need to go to Italy for that experience though. All they had to do was cross the river to NYC. Tony might rule the roost in Jersey, but he's still minor league compared to Luppertazzi family. At one point they say there's like 200 full fledged members of the family which is way more than everything Tony has at his disposal, made men, associates, soldiers, allies, everyone. There is simply so much money at Carmine Sr and Jr, Johnny Sack, and later Phil's disposal and the Esplanade is just one of their projects. It's the biggest thing in the world to the Sopranos and it's just one of a dozen projects of that size for NYC at any given time. I'm of the opinion that the whole reason they didn't just show up and take over Jersey was the attitude of why bother? Jersey is just the small time so why make the effort? Tony thinks he and Johnny Sack are the same level until Johnny flat tells him after he becomes boss that they aren't going to meet like they had been because it's no dignified. Paulie thinks Carmine Sr thinks the world of him just to find out he isn't even known. Push comes to shove, the Jersey crew is just a joke at times to the NYC crew and when they become real complications, they just get crushed.
 
They didn't need to go to Italy for that experience though. All they had to do was cross the river to NYC. Tony might rule the roost in Jersey, but he's still minor league compared to Luppertazzi family.
That's not exactly true. NY was invested in Soprano family business like construction, gambling, and loan sharking. They saw the Soprano family as making so much money that they were constantly trying to absorb them. Like Johnny Sac moving to New Jersey. Or Feech moving his cars through NY instead of Tony's normal car operation. They were making enough money for NY to seriously go after them not just ignore them like they were nothing.

We know in the show that the FBI's estimation of Johnny's income was far less than Tony's income as well. And Johnny has to desperately offload his house to Tony for pennies and begs Tony to help him get cash out of New Orleans. Tony held tons of power of Johnny in the end.
I'm of the opinion that the whole reason they didn't just show up and take over Jersey was the attitude of why bother?
It's because they all die before taking over NJ. Carmine Sr. dies, Johnny goes to prison (and dies), Phil gets his head blown apart. If Tony dies in the end it opens up the NJ territory to go to a NY family for good. But it took the deaths of multiple bosses to get it. We see at least three NY bosses make plays for NJ and either back off or get killed.
Jersey is just the small time so why make the effort?
They aren't small time at all. NY only says this as a power play. It's not reality. And NY does make constant efforts. Tony is literally part of NY's boss succession and brokers meetings for them during war. Carmine meets with Tony to announce he is not going to pursue being boss. Phil is the only one to openly hate NY and this is only after Tony B kills his brother Billy.
Tony thinks he and Johnny Sack are the same level until Johnny flat tells him after he becomes boss that they aren't going to meet like they had been because it's no dignified.
That's a power move. But Johnny moved to NJ so their meetings would be in Tony's backyard not in NY anyways. It was actually easier for Tony to not travel to NY for a meeting and just go to Johnny's house. He's just posturing. Tony doesn't care and is probably happy not to have to drive to NY at night. And after this meeting multiple NJ mobsters including bosses take meetings with Tony in NJ or PA.
 
i knew carmine was in the movie but wheres big pussy?
1771546893278.png
 
Push comes to shove, the Jersey crew is just a joke at times to the NYC crew and when they become real complications, they just get crushed.

They aren't small time at all. NY only says this as a power play. It's not reality. And NY does make constant efforts. Tony is literally part of NY's boss succession and brokers meetings for them during war. Carmine meets with Tony to announce he is not going to pursue being boss. Phil is the only one to openly hate NY and this is only after Tony B kills his brother Billy.
I saw NY working with NJ as necessity because unlike NYC, NJ is landlocked and they occupy one side of the ports/docks. Of course, both sides would want equal access to that pathway for territorial reasons.
 
You guys know carmine and big pussy where in goodfellas got all of two seconds?
27 actors and actresses are in both Goodfellas and The Sopranos. Some of them are super quick in their appearances. There are another dozen people who worked behind the scenes on both projects as well. David Chase was a huge fan of Goodfellas and tried to get Scorsese to cameo on The Sopranos but he refused.
 
27 actors and actresses are in both Goodfellas and The Sopranos. Some of them are super quick in their appearances. There are another dozen people who worked behind the scenes on both projects as well. David Chase was a huge fan of Goodfellas and tried to get Scorsese to cameo on The Sopranos but he refused.
Wasn’t he on an episode briefly and Christopher shouted “Kundun! I liked it!”
 
I don’t know why people associate The Wire with The Sopranos.

The Sopranos and The Shield are the patrician’s combo. The Wire is faggy bullshit with one great season, one good one, one not so bad, and the rest fucking blows with shining spots.
Both The Wire and Sopranos are auteur driven shows with a singular creative voice running things with a tyrannical iron grip.

The Shield on the other hand was written by a guy, Shawn Ryan, who was way more hands off and allowed his writers more freedom due to the fact that the bulk of The Shield was stand alone episodes with running subplots and went out of its way to give the supporting cast stand alone plots in the episodes which were myth arc heavy. It was more akin to Buffy and the Whedon method where Whedon basically served as cat herder, whereas Sopranos and Wire has Chase and Simon as iron fisted tyrants who ran their productions with an iron fist and made their writers know that flights of fancy and diversions into things the writers wanted to write about were not allowed 99% of the time. Especially on the Wire, where Simon's message took priority on letting the characters just exist outside the context of the greater storyline.
 
And this is partly why the Shield rarely hit the same highs as The Sopranos (thought it definitely did sometimes) but never hit the same lows, either.

There are no Shields episodes where I think 'Urgh, fuck that, skip.' Shit, there's few moments in the show overall where I'll be skipping discussions, etc... The Sopranos, on the other hand, in the latter seasons, has a bunch of shit that is just pointless and I don't want to ever see again. Roe and Carmela in Paris? Fuuuuck that. Dream sequences? Even more.
 
Back
Top Bottom