When I was lurking the nba subreddit another reason they told why they kept buying the yearly release is because of online playing with their friends or people online. The servers get shut down for older games. Unsure if that's legit, but I say it isn't much of a good reason. But the fanbase of that series seems to be not as savvy as most other communities where if it was a different community people would've developed a way to play online with older games even if the server's shut down.
And I'm pretty sure there's a way to play offline, 2 player with your friend IRL. If 2k made that impossible then that means they should really ditch the game and force these greedy developers a bit, and stop playing for a while which is the best solution, bar none.
IMO detecting a consoomer is pretty easy to know. A.) Overlapping w/ what some people usually call normies. They're the ones who mostly follow the same stint, without thinking for themselves or buying crap because it's the most trendy thing to do or the most popular thing on the market. Or they buy the product for the sake of clout, brand name but doesn't really care about the things it offers (like those apple drones or nintendo switch soyboys)
B.) they do their hobby without any legit passion and love for it, desperate to make it an identity for themselves.