The thing is, it's like some people simply cannot make a connection between Darksouls and a bad game; it's like the synapses won't trigger or something. The argument isn't that it gets good, or that it's good after you get better, it's always "yea well gargoyles are bad, and capra is bad, and blighttown is annoying to deal with, and sen's fortress is shit, and sen's fortress' roof is a BS area, and etc etc, but Dark Souls is good, I swear". Like, I get it that nintendo difficulty feels good to overcome, but there's nothing to Dark Souls other than beating bullshit bosses and dealing with annoying level design. A good game would have one or two bad elements, but Dark Souls just keeps going and going with its bullshit and you never get to the good part, it's just more bullshit. There's nothing particularly good about it, either. The combat doesn't feel very satisfying, there's no unique mechanics or awesome combat... Sure it felt fresh when it first came out, but in retrospective there's no reason to replay it now, not just because the later releases completely outshine the original.