- Joined
- Sep 16, 2013
Heh, that's more because honor roll is bullshit, than anything about the US.
Bullshit is a strong word. It is what it is. Basically it means you are performing acceptably in school. Not everyone gets it, but it is probably more useful as a warning for kids not on it than a mark of distinction for kids on it. There are usually other prizes/distinctions for kids who are at the top of the class.
How should you use it to judge Chris academic career. In terms of effort, it means he showed up and put the required effort in for major assignments and tests. In terms of ability, it means he was able to follow along to a reasonable level in his classes, some of which were special ed, some of which weren't. I suppose whether or not that should change your view of him depends on how much you endorse the view "Chris is so lazy and stupid he can't and won't ever do anything". If you are on the extreme end of endorsing that view, then honor roll goes a little against your view. On the other hand it doesn't prove that Chris was a motivated or intelligent student, just that he wasn't spectacularly unmotivated or incompetent.