The game is literally a AA game from 2011. If a random no-name studio produced this back then, it would be a 7/10 because you would be like "Wow, this is buggy as shit but I'm impressed they cobbled this together".
It is still incomprehensible to me that people think that features on this game are acceptable for a AAA $60 title in 2020. It is the absolute bare minimum you are required to have. It is nowhere near worth $60. $30 is the MAXIMUM I would purchase for this. Because it has no replayability, one play style, no variation, basically one gameplay mode (murder) and has terrible support.
The engram concept could have been so cool.
Imagine you had the 'engram meter' instead of the 'adrenaline meter' and every time it fills up you can 'turn' the engram on and get all those experiences. So you just become this max level fucking murder machine, with chain insta kills with a katana or using silverhand's revolver. The engram is something you can level up separately and gain experience with. Like the engram also can offer insights in the form of memories or 'becoming alive'. It is truly like your partner and it 'killing' you is a complete lie and you get to choose how it develops in your brain, eventually having the power and experience of two people.
Like there's so much that could have been done with this concept the fact that they went so basic, so...boring with it just speaks that they wanted to make it super normie friendly and didn't much care. Like maybe instead of being forced to care, maybe doing your engram's story unlocks additional abilities and upgrade paths for it. So you get something out of doing it, especially if you enjoy interaction with them. Maybe its YOUR choice to destroy your engram or save it. To live as two people instead of one, instead of this 'oh, its just re-writing you'. There's so much cool shit to mine.
They went basic bitch with everything. That's why this won't be fixed. They're 'happy' with where it is. I can load up GTA V or Red Dead 2, I don't need a shitty GTA clone with a cyberpunk skin. Their vision for this project is fucking banal as hell. There's no two ways around it. You'd basically have to force Badowski out as lead and get someone with real fucking vision and creativity on there. He clearly doesn't have it. And I don't know if CD Projekt have any left at this point.