Davison's 5 was also quite underrated I feel. Not as wacky or eccentric as Baker's 4 and a lot more controlled, even vulnerable, in his performance. The destruction of the sonic also helped alleviate the "magic wand" effect that it had started taking on by that point in the show where 99% of problems could just be swished away via a vibrator the main character carries around. His final performance in his regeneration episode was also genuinely great.
All around a very different portrayal of the character, and I think quite a good one. He
felt like an old man in a young mans body, which is exactly who the Doctor is.
The 6th doctor is fucking mess though, lmao. I think that people are more or less spot on with that era's dip in quality across the board. What in gods name happened?
I had actually forgotten how bad Colin Baker's era was. Half the stories are outright terrible and/or way too long and drawn out, the budget feels like it fell of a cliff, the doctor is dressed like a clown and is written like a ego-driven psychopath, and the whole thing feels like it had zero creative vision behind it for the entire first half, just random shit happening then out of nowhere Trial of a Time lord shows up and starts eating up everyone's remaining time. Colin's last words as the character is fucking
"Carrot juice!?".
A lame gag. The 6th doctor literally ends with a joke, then a completely different actor in a bad wig bumps his head and changes into 7. Baker didn't even get to be there for his own death scene. What the fuck.
He's just so bitchy. I love it. Sure he's a space hippy, but he just does not give a fuck.
The galactic hobo.